Menu ENN Search

Is food aid effective?

Summary of published research1

A recent article by food aid guru Ed Clay sets out current thinking about the effectiveness of food aid. While some agencies and experts advocate increasing food aid because of high levels of poverty-related malnutrition and increasing frequency and scale of natural disasters and conflict situation, others argue that food aid distorts local markets by discouraging agricultural development and displacing trade.

Clay argues that any assessment of the impact of food aid must consider the different types of food aid and donor practices. For example, emergency food aid saves lives and limits nutritional stress in crises. However, tying aid can restrict what foods are available and late arrival frequently hampers post-crisis agricultural recovery. Clay asks whether tying food aid matters. Most food aid channelled through the World Food Programme (WFP) and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) come 'in kind' and is sourced in the donor country. This is tied aid. WFP and NGOs would prefer to receive cash (untied aid), which would allow them to buy food locally or in neighbouring countries as this provides more appropriate and timely food and is more likely to benefit the local community. Untied aid is also cheaper. A DAC study by OECD in 2002 found that;

Around 90% of global food aid was tied in 2002. This proportion fell to 74% in 2004 but remains at over 99% for the USA who favour tied food aid because it supports their own farmers, food processors and USA-registered shipping. In contrast, European donors buy most of their food aid in developing countries.

During 2004 to 2005, Australia, Canada, Denmark, and France moved to further untie their food aid. USA aid administrators are trying to change the law so the US government can finance some developing country food purchases for distribution in crisis situations. However, Congress has so far rejected such proposals. As the biggest contributor of food aid to the WFP and NGOs, it is vital that the USA achieves this policy change.

Clay also asserts that food-based longerterm programmes, including so-called protracted relief and development projects, to reduce the impact of shocks are overlapping categories and therefore are an area of ambiguity. The decision to fund local purchase or imported food depends on risks of distorting the local economy, whether the transfer of food is efficient and whether other poverty reduction objectives are addressed. Monetisation, where tied imports are sold to finance development projects, is seen as a useful additional resource by some USA-based NGOs, but is controversial because of the high risk of distorting local and regional markets.

Programme food aid for budgetary support to governments has declined with the reduction in stored surpluses, especially from the USA. Assessments have highlighted ineffectiveness, especially in promoting national economic development, poor transfer efficiency and likely trade displacement. Furthermore, food aid is becoming more volatile and pro-cyclical (least available when international prices are high). The increasing priority given to humanitarian crises means that some countries are excluded or marginalised.

Clay asks how food aid can provide effective support to longer-term poverty reduction and other development objectives. He answers the question thus; "financial aid or cash is almost always the most effective and efficient way of funding either food distribution or providing budgetary support. A context-specific justification should always be provided for using food aid in preference to financial aid".

Show footnotes

1Clay. E (2006). Is food aid effective? Id21 insights, vol 61, April 2006, pp 6

More like this

FEX: Global factors shaping food aid

Summary of published paper1 USAID funded vegetable oil being distributed at Kassab IDP camp, North Dafur A paper in a recent special issue of Disasters on food aid, reviews...

FEX: WTO Negotiations on Improving Food Aid

By Susanne Jaspars and Chris Leather, Oxfam GB Susanne Jaspars was the team leader for Oxfam's emergency food security and livelihoods team from October 2002 to June 2005. She...

FEX: US and Canadian responses to global food crisis

In response to the global food crisis, a press release on 1 May 20081 detailed a call by President Bush to the US Congress to provide an additional $770million to support food...

FEX: Does food aid support or undermine livelihoods? (Special Supplement 3)

4.1 Introduction A WFP ship carrying food aid docks in Indonesia Food aid remains the over-riding response to emergencies, regularly constituting over half of consolidated...

FEX: The Future of Food Aid

Development food aid in the 1990s has proven relatively ineffective as a way of combating poverty and increasing food consumption according to a new study. Authors of the...

FEX: Food aid targeting in Ethiopia

Summary of published paper Food Distribution, Ethiopia '95 Based on data from a nationally representative survey of 4166 farm households by the Grain Market Research project...

FEX: Launch of DfID’s new strategy paper on eliminating hunger

Summary of Publication1 The Department for International Development in the UK (DfID) recently launched a strategy paper (May 2002) 'Eliminating Hunger; Strategy for Achieving...

FEX: Canadian Foodgrains Bank

Name: Canadian Foodgrains Bank Annual income (expenditure) (2011/12): $44,259,143 ($39,544,210) Website: www.foodgrainsbank.ca Director(s): Governed by Board of...

FEX: Equity in Donor Aid Allocation to Iraq

Loading food aid in Iraq Two short articles in a recent issue of the Lancet question the overall level of aid given and pledged to post-conflict Iraq1,2. One author (Singh)...

en-net: UNICEF is looking for a Nutrition Cluster/Sector Coordinator in Niger

Location: Niamey, Niger
Position: P4/TA
Opening Time: Tue May 16 14:05:00 UTC+0100 2017
Closing Time: Tue May 30 23:55:00 UTC+0100 2017

UNICEF works in...

FEX: References for Special Supplement 3

Beatrice, a beneficiary of the CRS seed voucher scheme in Burundi 1. Abdulai A., Barret, C., Hoddinott, J. (2004, June). Does food aid really have disincentive effects? new...

FEX: The use of evidence in humanitarian decision making

Summary of study1 Location: Ethiopia, DRC and Philippines What we know: Decision making in humanitarian response requires timely information and analysis and there are...

FEX: Understanding the food crisis in Zimbabwe

By Fiona Watson Fiona has recently been in southern Africa with the Overseas Development Institute (ODI), looking at the role of needs assessments during the current...

FEX: Famine Cry: Iraq

May 5, 2003 Dear Field Exchange As we prepare to mount a colossal humanitarian intervention in Iraq, we should be circumspect and humble about our past foodaid operations in...

FEX: Donor debate over food for cash

Summary of published report1 Adebate is raging among donors over whether aid to address food insecurity should be sent as food or cash. A report, published at the end of...

FEX: Cash and Vouchers in Emergencies

Summary of published paper1 Women have not been found to be disadvantaged by cash for work programmes A recently published discussion paper examines the use of cash and...

FEX: Local versus offshore costs of RUTF and LNS

Summary of Research1 Segrè J, Liu G and Komrska J. (2016) Local versus offshore production of ready-to-use therapeutic foods and small quantity lipid-based nutrient...

FEX: Evolution of a Crisis: a Save the Children UK perspective

By Mark Wright Mark Wright was the Save the Children Programme Officer for Southern Africa from November 2000 to November 2002. This article details Save the Children UK's...

FEX: From the editor

Ethiopia is a diverse country where a significant proportion of the population live on or below the poverty line, where food insecurity is widespread and rates of acute...

FEX: Emergency Food Security and Livelihoods Project in Amhara and Oromia regions

By Sarah Coll-Black and Matt Hobson Sarah Coll-Black is a Social Protection Specialist working with the World Bank in Ethiopia and Kenya. She has been involved with Ethiopia's...

Close

Reference this page

Is food aid effective?. Field Exchange 29, December 2006. p7. www.ennonline.net/fex/29/foodaid