An investigation of anthropometric training by NGOs

By Naomi Tilley

Naomi has just completed her MSc in Public Health Nutrition at the LSHTM. A qualified nurse, she has previously worked with MSF in Ethiopia and Sudan.

A recent cross-sectional study reported in Field Exchange1 investigated weighing scales used in emergency nutrition programmes specifically for infants less than six months old. The purpose of the study was to see which type of scale was used in emergency nutrition programmes and the type of scale that would be most appropriate. In response to the deficiencies identified, the University of Southampton is developing weighing scales for field conditions suitable for children 0-5 years. While this will improve capacity to assess young infants accurately and precisely, this outcome will also depend on the competency of the measurer. If the staff that are undertaking the anthropometric measurements have limited training and standardization, the measurement error could continue to be significant.

MUAC measurement in Malawi

The aim of this project2 was to investigate anthropometric measurement training in nutrition programmes. The main objectives were:

Methodology

A literature review was undertaken to look at anthropometric measurement error, training and standardisation methods that have been employed in emergency nutrition programmes. Staff and students at LSHTM who had previously worked for a NGO in a nutritional intervention capacity were solicited to be involved in the study and recruitment emails were targeted at international NGOs and to contacts supplied by the Emergency Nutrition Network (ENN). Both self-administered and interview-administered questionnaires were used.

Participants were split into three categories:

One questionnaire was devised for each of the three categories of interviewee. The questionnaire was pilot tested by five individuals with experience in nutritional interventions.

Fourteen nutrition and anthropometric measurement manuals were tested for:

The Flesch/Flesch-Kincaid Readability Tests were used to measure how difficult a pasage of text was to read and what level of education would be needed to comprehend the text (American grading converted to age in years) Clarity of instruction was assessed according to defined criteria and scored (1-3). Diagrams were also scored 1 (clear diagram present), 2 (diagram present) and 3 (no diagram).

Participants

Thirty-two individuals participated in the study (91% response rate). Countries represented included Somalia, Ethiopia, Niger, Malawi, Zimbabwe, and Uganda. The participants worked for a variety of NGOs including Samaritans' Purses, Medecins sans Frontieres (MSF) Holland, MSF UK, MSF France and MSF Spain, Concern Worldwide, Valid International, Action Contre la Faim (Spain, UK and USA offices), Save the Children UK and Medecins du Monde.

The limitations of the study included:

Results

Questionnaires

Of the 32 study participants, 94% had received anthropometric training. Five respondents (16%) had received only theoretical training from reading a book or listening to a lecture. One fifth (20%) of the supervisors have not received anthropometric measurement training in the last 5 years.

In general, national staff received longer anthropometric training - 87% reported training of 2 or more days, compared to 7% and 10% of coordinator/advisors and supervisors respectively. Over half (55%) of the national staff were trained by the nursing or nutritional supervisor.

Twenty two percent of the trainings received did not include infants less than 6 months and adult assessment.

Ten of the 13 medical / nutritional coordinator or advisors had been actively involved in training nursing or nutritional staff within a nutritional programme. One third (33%) of the coordinator/ advisor participants described the training at the project sites as "very good".

Of the nursing and nutritional supervisors, 64% were content with the anthropometric measurement training they received. Half of the 36% of participants who were unhappy with the training received attributed this to a lack of practical training and experience. Recurring issues regarding anthropometric measurements/training reported by nursing and nutritional supervisors included:

Calibration

Half (50%) of the supervisors said calibration of the weighing scales occurred every time the scales were used, 25% said calibration occurred monthly and 12.5% said calibration never occurred. A quarter of nursing / nutritional staff had never calibrated, whilst three-quarters reported calibration with each use3. However over half (63%) of the supervisors highlighted calibration as an area of concern with little consistency of calibration or zeroing in the project sites.

Perceived competency

While 88% of national nursing and nutritional staff said they felt very competent at undertaking weight measurement for children aged between 6 months and 5 years, this fell to 29% for infants less than 6 months. The majority (86%) of participants said they were 'very competent' at measuring height, while a lower proportion (71%) felt 'very competent' at measuring length.

The study identified some confusion amongst participants on when to measure height and length (75cm v 85cm cut off).

Policy on training

Two-thirds (67%) of participants said there was no agency recommendation for the frequency of training, while 17% of participants said that training depended on a number of variables, namely:

When asked about refresher training, 11% of the participants said it occurred prior to the surveys or randomly rather than routinely.

Evaluation of training manuals

Most of the manuals scored '1' in clarity, i.e. the anthropometric measurement instructions were clear and broken down into a step-by-step process. Overall, nearly half (46%) of the participants said the manuals were "very good", because the manuals were clear, comprehensive, user friendly and complete. One third (33%) of respondents considered the manuals were "OK", describing them as not stimulating or interactive and too focused on the 6 - 59 months age bracket. This report varied between the three groups - three quarters (75%) of the nursing and nutrition staff said the manuals provided by the NGOS were very good, compared with only one third (33%) of supervisors. One fifth (19%) of the supervisors and advisors/coordinators said the manuals were not good. For the manuals to be more engaging participants suggested the diagrams needed to be updated and a training CD should accompany the manual.

The average readability score of those manuals assessed was rated 60, which is considered consistent with average readability. With a score of 84, the Sudan Nutrition Manual had the highest readability score, which indicated it was 'easy' to read. The World Health Organisations' The Management of Nutrition in Major Emergencies8 and Valid International's Community Based Therapeutic Care (CTC); A Field Manual had the lowest readability score of 34, which indicated they were 'difficult' to read.

The average number of years of education required to read the manuals was 12. This indicates that most of these manuals would not be ideal for staff that have a limited education or are reading in a second language. The Sudan Nutrition Manual required the lowest level of education, as individuals only needed 5 years of education to be able to understand the manual. The most difficult manuals required over 13 years of education to understand them.

There appeared to be no recommended frequency of calibration or clarity between the use of calibration and zeroing in the anthropometric measurement manuals.

Some of the coordinators and supervisors said interactive training tools would help reduce their burden of work. Standardising training plans would ensure that all the important topics are covered in the training.

Recommendations

The following recommendations will hopefully reduce the irregularities in anthropometric measurement in emergency programming:

The following issues are suggested areas to concentrate on in the anthropometric measurement training:

This study has highlighted some of the problems that the participants faced with regards to anthropometric measurement and training and will hopefully provoke further thought and discussion on anthropometric measurement training.

For further information or to obtain the project report, contact: Naomi Tilley, email: naomitilley@hotmail.com

Show footnotes

1Field Exchange 29. Dec 2006. Angood C. Weighing scales for young infants. A survey of relief workers.

2Investigation into Anthropometric Measurement Training in Emergency Nutrition Programmes. LSHTM. Report of a project submitted in part fulfillment of the regulations for the degree of Master of Science in the Faculty of Medicine, University of London. August 2007.

3The study findings suggested that there was confusion amongst respondents on the difference between calibration and zeroing. The high reported calibration is likely a reflection of this.

More like this

Resource: Investigation into anthropometric assessment training in emergency nutrition programmes

Abstract Aim: The aim of this project is to investigate anthropometric measurement training in emergency nutrition programmes. Methods: there were two sections to the study,...

FEX: Weighing scales for young infants: a survey of relief workers

By Chloe Angood Chloe has a background in Development Studies, and previously spent thee years working with an NGO in Zimbabwe. For the past year she has been working...

en-net: Precision of equipment to assess infants in surveys

I have a question from an NGO regarding including infants in an anthropometric survey. What precision is needed for anthropometirc assessment of infants, including those less...

FEX: Prevalence of moderate malnutrition in infants

Summary of en-net discussion By Tamsin Walters, en-net coordinator Contributors: Nina Berry, Mike Golden, Mark Myatt, Marie McGrath A recent discussion on en-net concerning...

FEX: Assessment of agreement between a new electronic scale and mechanical suspended scale for measurement of children’s weight in Ethiopia

By Asrat Dibaba, Barbara Main and Mark Myatt Location: Ethiopia What we know already:Mechanical spring suspended scales are commonly used for measurement of weight in...

FEX: Investigation of anthropometric training by NGOs

In Issue 29 of Field Exchange, we highlighted some of the constraints to anthropometric assessment of infants in emergency contexts related to weighing scales.1...

en-net: Prevalence of moderate malnutrition in infants

Are there any data on the prevalence of moderate malnutrition in infants and if so how do these rates compare with prevalence amongst 6-59 month cohorts? Marie jogged my...

FEX: WHO consultation on management of moderate malnutrition in U5s

The WHO, in collaboration with UNICEF, WFP and UNHCR, hosted a second consultation to discuss the programmatic aspects of the management of moderate malnutrition in children...

en-net: Measuring infants < 6 months of age - training

I have received a request from a team in Afghanistan, regarding any training materials/guides for anthropometric measurement of infants under six months of age. They are...

Resource: Weighing scales for young infants: A survey of relief workers

Field Exchange 29 December 2006, p.11 Survey of weighing scales used for young infants, by staff working in emergencies. This led to the concept of a scales for 0-5 years...

en-net: Nutritional status and vulnerability of older adults/older people (aged 50 +)

Happy New Year to En-net colleagues, I have recently been contracted by HelpAge International (in partnership with NutritionWorks) to write a module on nutrition in older...

FEX: UNHCR standardised nutrition survey guidelines and training

By Melody Tondeur and Andrew Seal Melody Tondeur is an ENN Consultant and one of the team members implementing the Anaemia Control, Prevention and Reduction Project, a...

FEX: Anthropometry in infants under 6 months in rural Kenya

Summary of research1 Reliability study participants It is currently estimated that worldwide 8.5 million infants under 6 months are wasted. In poor communities, low rates of...

FEX: ACC/SCN Working Group on Nutrition in Emergencies

Excerpts from Working Group Report The ACC/SCN held its 27th Session at the World Bank in Washington DC last April. About 60 participants from NGOs, bilateral and UN agency...

FEX: A food-based strategy to improve nutrition in emergencies

Improvement of Household Food Security through Home Gardening and Nutrition Education in Southern Somalia By Alison MacColl Alison MacColl is working as Liaison Officer in...

FEX: Putting IFE guidance into practice: operational challenges in Myanmar

By Victoria Sibson Victoria Sibson has been the emergency nutrition adviser for Save the Children UK since April 2007, with a focus on treatment of acute malnutrition and...

en-net: Steps to measure MUAC

Countries like Ethiopia is already introduced new method of MUAC measurement for extension health workers. it is just Estimating the midpoint of the left upper arm. the the old...

FEX: Measuring infants aged below 6 months: experience from the field

By Martha Mwangome and James Berkley Dr Martha Mwangome is a postdoc researcher at KEMRI/Wellcome Trust Collaborative Programme; Centre for Geographic Medical Research Coast,...

Resource: Milk powder and diapers greatly needed in quake-hit areas, China, News article

Milk powder & diapers greatly needed in quake-hit areas *By* Pang Li (China.org.cn May 19, 2008) "Presently milk powder is not available here and the relief food is not...

FEX: Integration of CMAM into routine health services in Nepal

By Regine Kopplow Regine is a former CMAM Advisor with Concern Nepal. She is a nutritionist with a background in rural development. She has worked in the field of nutrition...

Close

Reference this page

Naomi Tilley (2008). An investigation of anthropometric training by NGOs. Field Exchange 32, January 2008. p5. www.ennonline.net/fex/32/investigation