|
MANAGING THE
COMPLEXITY OF AID FLOW
In recent years, increased
concerns about inappropriate donations of milk as emergency
aid have led IBFAN to a major conclusion: the need for an
integrated approach - including the existence of appropriate
policies and guidelines, coordination, training, awareness
raising among the general public, donors and the media, infant
feeding programmes with a strong monitoring component and
research.

An uncontrolled infant
food pipeline
During the Kosovo crisis
in 1999, Marie McGrath (Institute
of Child Health/Save the Children UK) carried out research
on infant feeding in Macedonia. She observed that :"There
was no way of monitoring unsolicited donations of infant
feeding items arriving by road... Much of the distribution of
infant formula was untargeted, uncoordinated and
unmonitored."
FOR
EXAMPLE
…
|
Unsolicited Donations
|
A
significant proportion of the aid that arrived in
Macedonia was unsolicited. NATO countries provided
planes which worked on a ‘load up and go’ policy
with little documentation other than tonnage. A large
proportion of unsolicited donations also arrived by
road. |
|
Untargeted Distribution
|
Convoys of trucks containing humanitarian aid
arrived and drove directly to the camps where items were
distributed without a record being kept. The amount of
infant formula distributed appeared to depend on the
quantities in stock rather than on any estimated
need. |
|
Uncoordinated Actions
|
In
spite of a UN early assessment in April 1999 which
identified the lack of promotion and/or protection of
breastfeeding and possible problems regarding the use of
breastmilk substitutes in absence of education and
information, no coordinated approach to address the
issues was established in the field. It was only after
the arrival of a United Nations High Commission for
Refugees (UNHCR) nutritionist in June 1999 that a
significant improvement in coordination and monitoring
of infant feeding programmes was noted. |
|
Unmonitored Products
|
No system of monitoring ensured that the World
Food Programme (WFP) guidelines advising against the
general distribution of dried milk powder were
respected. |
Source : "Meeting the nutritional needs of infants during
emergencies: recent experiences and dilemmas", M. McGrath,
A.Seal, A.Taylor, L. Gostelow, Report of an international
workshop, Institute of Child Health, London, November 1999.
Save the Children, UK.
|
Policies and
Guidelines DO Exist
Even if
there is to date no single common UN policy on infant
feeding in emergencies, there is substantial consensus
on the need to protect breastfeeding in emergencies.
Some of the basic documents to guide policy makers,
programme managers and field workers are:
-
Infant and Young
Child Feeding in Emergencies, operational guidance for
emergency and relief staff and policy-makers. Document
prepared by the inter-agency working group on infant
feeding in emergencies and supported by a number of
key relief organisations, 2001. Request a copy from
Fiona O’Reilly, Emergency Nutrition Network: foreilly@tcd.ie.
-
Infant Feeding in
Emergencies. Policy, Strategy and Practice. Report
of the Ad Hoc Group on Infant Feeding in Emergencies.
May 1999. ENN, Emergency Nutrition Network: http://www.ennonline.net (Printed version
available in Baby Milk Actions Virtual Shop).
-
Policy of the
UNHCR related to the Acceptance, Distribution and Use
of Milk Products in Feeding Programs in Refugee
Settings. UNHCR, 1989.
-
The International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk
Substitutes and relevant WHA
Resolutions.(Printed version available in Baby Milk Actions
Virtual
Shop).
-
Protecting Infant
Health. A Health Workers’
Guide to the International Code of Marketing of
Breast-milk Substitutes. 9th Edition, IBFAN Penang,
April 1999. (Printed version
available in Baby Milk Actions Virtual
Shop).
-
Guiding Principles
on Feeding Infants and Young Children during
Emergencies. WHO
Nutrition. Annex to: The Management of Nutrition in
Emergencies, WHO, 2000.
-
The SPHERE
project. Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in
Disaster Response.
1st edition. 1998. http://www.sphereproject.org/
-
Feeding in
emergencies for Infants under six months Practical
Guidelines. OXFAM. Carter
K. / OXFAM Public Health Team, 1996.
|
3 |