Menu ENN Search

Issue 27 Editorial

Every emergency has a habit of throwing up fresh challenges which force us to re-examine our understanding of vulnerability and how best to respond. However, as shown in this issue of Field Exchange, our success in adapting and responding effectively to 'new' situations and conditions of vulnerability is variable. This highlights the fundamental importance of getting vulnerability analysis right. At the same time there appears to be no let up in our quest to improve our 'programming techniques'. All the field articles in this issue have lessons for improved programming and provide examples of innovative practice and thinking.

A WFP evaluation of the tsunami response in Sir Lanka and Indonesia found that although more women than men were killed and injured during the tidal wave and that they were the most vulnerable after the disaster, the response did not always cater adequately for their needs. Much of the response centred on supporting income generation activities, especially amongst men, while rehousing was given less priority leaving women and children in often overcrowded IDP settlements. A key reason for this was that women were excluded from the decision-making process. In a similar vein, HelpAge found that the tsunami response missed out on the specific needs of the elderly who were also particularly affected by the disaster. The elderly were often poorly served in chaotic distributions while food rations failed to take account of their chronic health problems including high blood pressure, diabetes, cancer, etc.

The impact of climate change on vulnerability is now beginning to register on the radar of the humanitarian sector. A special issue of the IDS bulletin (summarised in the research section) contains a series of cases showing adaptation to the impact of climate change, which is gradually altering the nature of vulnerability for different livelihood groups. Examples include community adaptation to repeated floods and droughts in Bangladesh and Rajasthan, agricultural intensification in Senegal, climate proofing and diversifying livelihoods in Zimbabwe and benefiting from global warming in Zimbabwe. In some cases, adaptive responses are working while in others they are not. A key conclusion of the work is that vulnerability analysis in relation to adaptations to climate change should be incorporated systematically into policy and institutional frameworks for development and disaster relief.

An excellent example of how vulnerability analysis can inform best practice in crisis is seen in the Tufts university study on the impact of the conflict on livelihoods in Darfur (research section). Here, vulnerability and its causes is analysed at the micro and macro level in terms of governance, discrimination against ethnic groups, access to services and impact of the conflict on remittances and pastoral systems. The wide ranging analysis leads to an equally wide set of multi-sectoral recommendations that, if implemented, will have far greater impact than standard food aid responses.

Field articles in this issue of Field Exchange demonstrate an encouraging capacity for critiquing programme approaches and finding creative solutions. Taken together, the articles show that agencies are most definitely not prepared to sit on their laurels.

An article by Jason Stobbs describes the experience of using the centric sampling system in Uvira, Zaire in order to improve the accuracy of programme coverage data. Such data are often derived from nutrition surveys and are may be intrinsically flawed by virtue of the type of sampling adopted. Both the strengths and weaknesses of the relatively new centric sampling approach are clearly demonstrated by the authors. A second article (by Johannah Wegerdt, Monica Zanchettin and Mark Myatt) describes the use of the 'capture/ recapture' method for assessing population size. Accurate census data are notoriously difficult to obtain in emergency contexts so that any new and improved means of acquiring such data has to be a good thing. Assumptions and difficulties of the capture/recapture method are spelt out based on case study experience. In another article, ACF describe their innovative use of GIS in Mali to better understand vulnerability of pastoral systems. Kara Greenblott from C-Safe, a consortium of INGOs based in the southern Africa region, has written an article describing experiences of applying exit strategies to food aid programming in Lesotho, Zambia and Zimbabwe. Reflecting the thinking of C-Safe members she concludes that exit strategies should not just be seen as a way of 'getting out' of long-term commitments but rather as a means of leaving sustainable programmes. The final field article is written by Tayech Yimer, Anne Marie Mayer and Arabella Duffield from SC UK and describes the difficulties of impact assessment based on experience of the RDIR programme in Ethiopia. The authors clearly set out the methodological challenges of impact assessment while at the same time proposing a number of technical and institutional solutions.

Finally, and very much in keeping with the theme of 'critiquing what we do in order to implement better programmes', the ENN and SC UK have begun a review of the effectiveness of emergency SFPs (see research section) with a view to determining whether this standard nutritional emergency response is always the most appropriate and effective means of dealing with mild and moderate malnutrition. The review involves at least 14 INGOs/UN agencies who are expected to provide data sets from over 150 emergency SFPs conducted during the past four years. The methodology for this study, which is still in its early stages, is set out in the research section. Watch this space for the study findings.

Jeremy Shoham, Editor

Any contributions, ideas or topics for future issues of Field Exchange? Contact the editorial team on email: office@ennonline.net

More like this

en-net: resources on CSAS

I'm trying to learn more about CSAS, but can only find summary or simple documents. Does anyone know where there is a proper, detailed manual on CSAS? That does help. Thanks...

FEX: ActionAid International

Agency ActionAid International Fax +27 (0) 11 880 8082 Chief Executive Ramesh Singh Website http://www.actionaid.org ActionAid UK Director Richard Miller Staff international...

FEX: Assessing sensitivity of case-finding using capturerecapture techniques

By Johannah Wegerdt, Monica Zanchettin and Mark Myatt Marking the midpoint during MUAC measurement Monica Zanchettin is a coverage surveyor for Valid International. She has...

FEX: Editorial

There are three themes running through this issue of Field Exchange. We have four field articles which describe the very real practical challenges of having to adapt...

FEX: Issue 35 Editorial

In this issue of Field Exchange, there are two themes which previous editorials have not addressed - sustainability of interventions and how markets can create, as well as be...

FEX: Issue 19 Editorial

This issue of Field Exchange is dedicated to Prof. John Kevany (ENN Director) who died on 20th April 2003. John was instrumental in establishing the ENN. Given John's...

FEX: Issue 18 Editorial

By Fiona Watson Fiona Watson has been involved in assessment and evaluations of emergency nutrition and food security programmes for the last 10 years. She is currently a...

FEX: Issue 32 Editorial

The devil is in the detail In this edition of Field Exchange we have a number of field articles that address very detailed programming issues. A field article by ACF deals...

FEX: Issue 30 Editorial

Many pieces in this issue of Field Exchange strengthen our understanding of best practice in nutritional emergencies. We highlight four in this editorial. Victoria Sibson from...

FEX: Achieving resilience in different livelihood contexts

Summary of report1 Location: Africa and Asia What we know already: Building resilience is widely referred to in Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) and Climate Change Adaptation...

FEX: Adapting to climate change

Summary of published paper1 A house destroyed by flooding in Bangladesh A special issue of the IDS bulletin contains a series of case studies from different countries showing...

FEX: Understanding the food crisis in Zimbabwe

By Fiona Watson Fiona has recently been in southern Africa with the Overseas Development Institute (ODI), looking at the role of needs assessments during the current...

FEX: From the editor

This issue of Field Exchange gives extended coverage to a briefing paper just released by Oxfam and SC UK on the 2011 response to the Horn of Africa crisis. This paper argues...

FEX: The Challenge of Applying CSAS in DRC

By Jason Stobbs, AAH-USA Jason Stobbs is a long-serving member of Action Against Hunger - USA, volunteering over the past four years in diverse contexts such as Afghanistan,...

FEX: Nutrition programme coverage: implementation strategy and lessons learnt from the Sahel trip in Chad

By Hermann Ouedraogo, Ismael Ngnie-Teta, Mahamat Bechir, Esaie Diongoto Domaya, Adama N'Diaye, Paola Valenti Hermann Ouedraogo, MPH, PhD, is Nutrition Cluster Coordinator with...

FEX: Editorial

View this article as a pdf In this issue of Field Exchange we are delighted to feature, for the second year running, a special section that shares key outputs of Action...

FEX: Editorial

View this article as a pdf Dear readers, A warm welcome to the 68th edition of Field Exchange. As we bring you this edition, the world is facing a series of challenges:...

FEX: Editorial

View this article as a pdf Dear Field Exchange readers, Welcome to the 64th edition of Field Exchange. We are delighted to kick start 2021 featuring a special section on...

en-net: WFP looking for consultant for development of guidance document ‘Integration of Nutrition in VAA’

1. Background The SADC Regional Vulnerability Assessment and Analysis (RVAA) Programme was established in 2005 with an aim to “strengthen national and regional vulnerability...

FEX: Issue 06 Editorial

Dear Readers, This issue of field exchange heralds the second phase of the ENN. Our first two years appear to have been sufficiently successful to prompt continued support...

Close

Reference this page

Jeremy Shoham (). Issue 27 Editorial. Field Exchange 27, March 2006. p1. www.ennonline.net/fex/27/fromtheeditor

(ENN_2270)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.