New WHO Growth Standards: more harm than good?
Summary of published letter1
A recent letter in the LANCET questions whether the new WHO growth standards,2 reported in issue 28 of Field Exchange, may do more harm than good. The authors argue that most mothers and health professionals are concerned about their infant's growth, particularly for the first six months. If they believe their infants are not growing adequately, they are more likely to introduce supplementary foods, including 'top ups' with infant formula or even switching to formula completely. It is further argued that 'insufficient milk' is the most common reason for the early cessation of breastfeeding and mothers often self-diagnose this on the basis of perceived slower growth.
The new WHO growth standards show the maximum growth rates that can be achieved with breastfeeding under optimum conditions. But, for the first six months of life, the new WHO growth standard weights, for boys and girls, are heavier than those produced by the NCHS (National Centre for Health Statistics) for every Z score from -3 to +3. The difference is greater for weights below the mean, and it is in this region of the chart that mothers are more likely to be anxious about the growth of their infants.
The authors state that the new WHO growth standards are a triumph of modern statistical technique but go on to ask whether the real purpose has been lost in technology. They conclude that what is really needed is a growth reference that presents growth rates that can be realistically achieved during the first six months of life, and maximises the duration of exclusive breastfeeding.
1 Binns. C and Lee.M (2006). Will the new WHO growth references do more harm than good? The Lancet, volume 368, Nov 2006
More like this
FEX: Evaluation of Relactation by the Supplemental Suckling Technique
A mother feeding her baby using the SST By Odile Oberlin and Caroline Wilkinson, Action Contre la Faim (ACF) Odile Oberlin is a paediatrician working in a Paris hospital and...
FEX: Diarrhoea risk associated with not breastfeeding in Botswana
Summary of report and presentation1 Between November 2005 and February 2006, there were unusually heavy rains and flooding in Botswana, and by January 2006, there was an...
FEX: Counselling on infant feeding choice: Some practical realities from South Africa
By Tanya Doherty (pictured), Mickey Chopra and Mike Colvin Tanya is currently a senior scientist at the Health Systems Trust and Medical Research Council in Capetown, South...
en-net: Zinc supplementation to SAM and/or MAM with acute diarrhoea?
Can we give zinc supplementation to the severely and/or moderately acute malnourished children with acute diarrhoea? The Unicef and WHO document "Diarrhoea treatment guideline...
FEX: Infant Feeding in Emergencies: Experiences from Indonesia and Lebanon
By Ali Maclaine and Mary Corbett Ali Maclaine has a MSc in Human Nutrition from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. She has been involved in infant feeding and...
FEX: Ethical considerations for international research in low- and middle-income countries
View this article as a pdf This is a summary of the following paper: Doherty T, Engebretsen IMS, Tylleskär T et al (2022) Questioning the ethics of international research...
FEX: Infant and young child feeding support in Lebanon: strengthening the national system
By Pressila Darjani and Linda Shaker Berbari Pressila Derjany is the Infant and Young Child Coordinator at IOCC. She has a B.Sc. in Nutrition and Dietetics. She joined IOCC...
FEX: Effect of nutrition survey ‘cleaning criteria’ on estimates of malnutrition prevalence and disease burden: secondary data analysis
Summary of research1 Location: Global What we know: Standardised methods for collection and reporting malnutrition prevalence data in nutrition surveys are used. What this...
FEX: Caring for premature babies in a conflict zone
Summary of published experiences1 This paper describes aspects of the authors work as a midwife with Médecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) in a north-western regional hospital in Côte...
FEX: The Lancet 2023 series on breastfeeding: Unveiling the predatory tactics of the formula milk industry
View this article as a pdf This is a summary of the 2023 Lancet Series on breastfeeding: https://www.thelancet.com/series/Breastfeeding-2023 This series on breastfeeding...
FEX: Food insecurity and child malnutrition in North Bangladesh
By Kimon Schneider, Pranab K. Roy and Dr. Hasan Kimon Schneider is a development practitioner and Country Delegate with Tdh Foundation. He has a M.A. in Anthropology and a...
FEX: Managing at risk mothers and infants under six months in India – no time to waste
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici By Praveen Kumar, Sila Deb, Arjan de Wagt, Piyush Gupta, Nita Bhandari, Neha Sareen and Satinder...
FEX: Infant feeding strategies and PMTCT - Mashi trial from Botswana
Summary of published research1 Arecently published paper compares the efficacy and safety of two infant feeding strategies for the prevention of postnatal mother-to-child HIV...
en-net: Prevalence of moderate malnutrition in infants
Are there any data on the prevalence of moderate malnutrition in infants and if so how do these rates compare with prevalence amongst 6-59 month cohorts? Marie jogged my...
en-net: Infant feeding and the European refugee crisis
Dear en-net, We have been alerted to appeals on Facebook pages and elsewhere for baby milks and bottles etc as part of the response to the Refugee crisis in Europe. Can anyone...
FEX: Managing infant and young child feeding in refugee camps in Jordan
By Sura Alsamman Sura Alsamman is nutrition supervisor at Save the Children Jordan, responsible for the overall all coordination of the IYCF technical functions and activities...
FEX: Ending the marketing of breastmilk substitutes: An amazing push to increase breastfeeding rates.
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici This article describes recent initiatives that were taken to better regulate the marketing of breastmilk...
FEX: A reflection on the 2021 Lancet Maternal & Child Nutrition Series through a WaSt lens
View this article as a pdf This article provides a summary of the Lancet Maternal & Child Nutrition Series to date, reflecting upon the 2021 series from the perspective of the...
FEX: Summary of Lancet Series on Maternal and Child Undernutrition
Below are short summaries of the recently launched Lancet series of papers on Maternal and Child Undernutrition1. This high profile series focuses on the disease burden...
FEX: Editorial
This rather large issue of Field Exchange has a typically wide range of material from field practitioners and researchers. Some examples of innovative practice include an...
Reference this page
New WHO Growth Standards: more harm than good?. Field Exchange 30, April 2007. p15. www.ennonline.net/fex/30/newwhogrowthstandards
(ENN_2092)