Menu ENN Search

Emergency relief workers: what skills do you need to be effective?

Summary of published paper1

A recent study investigated the types of skills most valued by relief workers in order to achieve their goals. Using the Critical Incident Technique (CIT2), a sample of fifteen nurses returning from work in refugee camps were interviewed.

Methodology

Participants had engaged in emergency relief work within the past three months to five years. All were women with a mean age of 39 years. The study was undertaken with the co-operation of an umbrella organisation for returned development workers in Ireland which forwarded a letter to the addresses of a randomised quota sample of 100 people on their database. One limitation of the study was that participants were self-selected. Willingness to take part in the research may therefore reflect some bias in terms of cultural values, personal experiences, selfperception, recall of events, age and gender.

The first stage of identifying Critical Incidents is to define personal work objectives of the interviewee. Interviewees were then asked to describe one positive and negative incident which had an impact on them. In a more detailed interview, the question was then asked 'taking this incident as an example of the sort of work your job requires what would you say are the main abilities or characteristics that somebody should have in order to perform well in the job?'

Two examples of incidents are included in Boxes I and II.

The broad categories of 'necessary' skills identified by the interviewees were as follows:

The authors concluded that the job related skills identified were mainly to do with how things get done rather than with what is done, i.e. they reflect a concern with process skills rather than technical skills. The four specific skills that achieved the highest endorsement were: sense of humour, sensitivity to the values of other cultures, patience, and diplomacy/tactfulness. Few professional training or pre-departure courses can claim to provide a grounding in these skills.

Openness to learning, being able to ask for advice, willingness to negotiate, adaptability, flexibility, initiative, tolerance and resourcefulness were all cited as important ways of working. These all reflect a fluid approach to working as opposed to relying solely on more crystallised technical skills. Such skills are likely to promote tolerance of ambiguity. Given the confused, hectic and often unstructured nature of much relief work, tolerance in both social and work relationships are very important for an individual's work performance and well being.

In conclusion, this research represents the first attempt to assess job skills in emergency relief work and has identified skills, behaviour and attitudes that proved critical to the achievement of objectives towards which people worked. The critical incidents identified as part of this study could serve as a basis for role playing in training course and in the recruitment process for agencies. Critical incident analysis can provide a mechanism for returned aid workers to integrate real experiences into the training of others.

 

Box I: Negative incident

One nurse was engaged in assessing the feeding and basic medical requirements of refugees. Approximately 3000 people per week would pass through the feeding centre. A six-month old infant had been identified as being in urgent need of nutritional assistance and was provided with a gastro-nasal feeding tube. The mother subsequently removed the feeding tube and the infant died. It emerged that the mother had decided that available resources would best be given to her other children who had, in her opinion, a more realistic chance of surviving. The interviewee was shocked and distressed at first but eventually came to terms with what happened as best she could.

The principal skills identified here included the ability to respect the dignity, customs and traditions of others and to recognise the limits of the job. Other skills identified were related to coping on a personal level. These included being able to express one's emotions, developing good interpersonal relationships with colleagues and being able to 'nourish' oneself after a day's work without feeling guilty.

 

Box II: Positive incident

A satellite telephone dish was stolen from outside the residence of a donor organisation. An investigation was carried out by the local assistant co-ordinator of the project, who attributed blame to the 'opposing' tribe. This individual directed that the wages of the indigenous workers would be cut by 25% to pay for the cost of the new dish. The interviewee felt very strongly that this was an unjust course of action and found that other expatriates who agreed were disinclined to challenge this unilateral decision of the assistant co-ordinator. The indigenous workers organised a protest and the decision to cut the wages was rescinded. Instead a reward was offered for the return of the dish. The dish was returned a week later. It seems that the item had not been stolen by a member of the 'accused' tribe. A considerable amount of damage was done to the relationship between the indigenous and expatriate workers due to the way in which the matter was handled.

Show footnotes

1Critical Incidents in Emergency Relief Work: McKay.M and MacLachlan.M (2000). Development in Practice, Vol 10, No 5, November 2000.

2The CIT is a technique for collecting information on incidents that the respondent feels have been critical to his or her experience of the job.

More like this

FEX: Voices from the field: Optimising performance for humanitarian workers

By Jared Katz, Deborah Nguyen, Carla Lacerda and Gerald Daly The authors extend special thanks to Olesya Dudenkova for helping to get the project off the ground, and to...

FEX: Novel Methods of 'Work for Food'

Steve Harrison is currently undertaking a PHD in the Department of Anthropology, University of Toronto. The following article is based on his experience in Rwanda in the summer...

en-net: 15-581: Country Director

Essential Job Duties/Scope of Work: International Medical Corps is a global, humanitarian, nonprofit organization dedicated to saving lives and relieving suffering through...

en-net: 15-402: Country Director - Afghanistan

Country: Afghanistan Department: International Operations Essential Job Duties/Scope of Work: International Medical Corps is a global, humanitarian, nonprofit organization...

FEX: Development of a competency framework for the nutrition in emergencies sector

Summary of published paper1 Location: Global What we know: There has been increased investment in and attention to professional development of humanitarian staff. There are...

FEX: Treatment of severe acute malnutrition through the Integrated Child Development Scheme in Jharkand State, India

By Grana Pu Selvi and Colleen Emary View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Grana Pu Selvi has postgraduate qualifications in food and nutrition...

en-net: Surge Health & Nutrition Manager Emergency Response Team

Role & Responsibilities
Provide short term support to the Emergency Response Team (ERT) in the direct implementation of health and nutrition interventions. May...

en-net: Surge Health & Nutrition Manager Emergency Response Team

Provide short term support to the Emergency Response Team (ERT) in the direct implementation of health and nutrition interventions. May include screening and management of...

FEX: Relief International nutrition and health programme in Lebanon

By Jamila Karimova and Jo Hammoud Jamila Karimova is the Health and Nutrition Programme Manager at Relief International (RI) Lebanon. She has been working with RI for 12...

en-net: Food Technologist P3

The United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) is the world's largest humanitarian agency, fighting hunger worldwide. We are seeking to fill the position of Food Technologist...

FEX: The reality of research in emergencies

Marie McGrath is a qualified paediatric dietician/nutritionist. She has an abundance of experience in emergencies, working previously with Merlin. SCF (UK) employed her to...

FEX: Participatory risk analysis and integrated interventions to increase resilience of pastoral communities in Northern Kenya

By Daniel Nyabera, Charles Matemo and Muriel Calo Daniel Nyabera is Food Security and Livelihoods Programme Manager, ACF-US, Yemen Mission. Daniel has over nine years of...

en-net: Health and Nutrition Project Manager

Develop, lead, monitor and evaluate the assigned health project(s). Effectively manage and report on projects in line with the objectives, timeframe and budget with a focus...

FEX: ALNAP Annual Review 2002

The ALNAP Annual Review 20021 provides a synthesis of the principal findings and recommendations of evaluations of humanitarian action, completed and made available to ALNAP in...

en-net: Health and Nutrition Manager

Role & Responsibilities
Assist in the direct implementation of nutrition interventions which may include screening, treatment of severe acute malnutrition, moderate...

en-net: Cooking demonstrations

As part of the prevention of malnutrition, can I have a document outlining lessons learned from an experience in cooking demonstrations for implementing a...

FEX: Africa Forum 2009 - An experience in adult learning

By Kara Greenblott Kara Greenblott lived and worked in Africa and Southeast Asia for 11 years managing a diverse range of humanitarian programmes. She has a Masters degree in...

FEX: Community Based Targeting in Myanmar

By Jeremy Shoham In May/June 2005, Jeremy Shoham was part of a WFP Office of Evaluation (OEDE) team which fielded a mission to Myanmar as part of a five country case study...

FEX: Joint WFP/UNHCR evaluation of Kenyan refugee programme

Summary of report1 In September 1999, WFP and UNHCR conducted a joint evaluation of their assistance (Protracted Relief Operation (PRO)) to Somali and Sudanese refugees living...

FEX: Challenges and Opportunities in Integrating CTC and Food Security Programmes in Malawi (Special Supplement 2)

By Jim Goodman (Concern Malawi) As with the majority of famines and food crises, the 2002-3 Malawi crisis was caused by the interaction of many pre-existing factors of...

Close

Reference this page

Emergency relief workers: what skills do you need to be effective?. Field Exchange 13, August 2001. p6. www.ennonline.net/fex/13/emergency

(ENN_3514)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.