Menu ENN Search

Ethics of use of ready-to-use-therapeutic foods

Dear Editor,

I have been following the debate on the ethics surrounding the research on Community Therapeutic Care (CTC) and Ready to Use Therapeutic Foods (RUTFs), and was wondering whether the issue of ethics in the current use of RUTF's in the field is also being discussed, as this also could have effects on the quality of the research and effectiveness of future CTC programmes.

I have just returned from a 5 week mission throughout three regions of Afghanistan, as part of the Quality Project implemented by Groupe URD. During my visit, I was struck to find a large number of NGOs distributing RUTFs to severely malnourished children in Supplementary Feeding Programmes (SFPs), sometimes with fortnightly distributions (mothers receiving 30 to 60 Plumpy nut packets at a time), and most often with very little if any specific medical supervision of severely malnourished patients (sometimes including pregnant or lactating women, admitted according to MUAC).

Have the following issues been raised?

I was concerned because many SFPs where RUTFs are distributed are implemented by agencies or field personnel who do not necessarily have nutritional training, are not familiar with the specificities of severe malnutrition nor are aware of the issues surrounding CTC. Furthermore, the monitoring, when it is done, tends to show poor results with very high rates of defaulters (up to 70% in some centres) which probably include mortality cases. Weight gains (when they are calculated) average around 2 to 4g/kg/day, with potentially wide differences in results between programmes.

Many staff who were asked about the pertinence of distributing RUTFs say "it's that or we do nothing". The Afghan context indeed makes it very difficult to implement TFCs. Factors such as distance for beneficiaries, difficult access to remote areas for agencies, difficulty for women in leave their homes, the lack of staff (expat and Afghan) trained in nutrition, and the lack of NGO capacity to implement TFCs are all severe constraints. But is the distribution of RUTF (in SFPs) better or worse than nothing?

I feel concerned about this issue, as I have seen a similar example of RUTF distributions in SFPs or even blanket distributions in Ethiopia, and imagine that other examples must be widespread, given the current 'publicity' around CTC & RUTFs.

In some quarters it is argued that now that we have RUTF, CTC programmes are feasible but we must go sufficiently slowly to learn the lessons. It will surely take time to do the research on the appropriate use of RUTFs, but with the products already on the market, is the practice not going too fast? And if so, what can be done to ensure these new products are 'properly' used until the research yields more results?

Yours sincerely
Charlotte Dufour

Nutritionist, Groupe URD (Urgence Rèhabilitation Dèvelopement). Email: cdufour@urd.org.Web: http://www.urd.org

More like this

FEX: Community-based Approaches to Managing Severe Malnutrition

One nutrition worker's solution to childcare at a busy feeding distribution! A three day meeting was held in Dublin hosted by Concern and Valid International between 8-10th of...

FEX: CTC Approach (Special Supplement 2)

by Steve Collins (Valid International) 2.1 Main principles of CTC Community Therapeutic Care (CTC) is a community-based model for delivering care to malnourished people. CTC...

FEX: Viability of an ENN research initiative

Food aid in Afghanistan By Christine Bousquet, Charlotte Dufour, François Grünewald, Hugues Maury, Groupe Urgence Réhabilitation Dévelopement (URD) The Quality Project is an...

FEX: Integration of CTC with strategies to address HIV/AIDS (Special Supplement 2)

By Paluku Bahwere, Saul Guerrero, Kate Sadler & Steve Collins (Valid International) The district health officer of Dowa, Malawi, briefs clinic and community workers about the...

FEX: Technical and Management issues within CTC (Special Supplement 2)

4.1 CTC from Scratch - Tear Fund in South Sudan By Ed Walker (Tearfund) Beneficiaries collecting their general ration in South Sudan. Tearfund has been working in Northern...

en-net: Management of MAM and Mortality

More and more agencies refuse at field level getting involved in prevention and treatment of MAM arguing that there is no prove that this will have an impact on mortality rates...

FEX: Ambulatory treatment of severe malnutrition

Severely malnourished child with father Commentary by Dr. Steve Collins Dr. Steve Collins is a medical doctor with a doctorate in nutrition during emergency operations. He is...

FEX: Issue 17 Editorial

Dear readers, Ethical considerations figure prominently in this issue of Field Exchange. A field article written by Dr. Eva Grabosch tackles the problem of providing...

FEX: Integration in CTC (Special Supplement 2)

by Jamie Lee Many of the articles in this supplement explore the concepts and practice of 'integration' within CTC programmes. A variety of meanings and values are attached to...

FEX: CTC in South Sudan - A Comparison of Agency Approaches and the Dilemmas Involved (Special Supplement 2)

Tanya Khara (Valid International), Jennifer Martin (Concern Worldwide), Ed Walker (Tearfund) Introduction In 2003 both Concern Worldwide and Tearfund asked Valid...

en-net: SFPs - what is wrong with them and can we fix it?

Latest after Carlos Navarro-Colorado's (et al) paper on the effectiveness of SFPs there is a tendency to turn away from them as the message seems to be misinterpreted. Do we...

en-net: Supplimentary Feeding Programme

Hi all !! I was just wondering, can SFPs be setup independently with the support of Stabilization center for inpatient care of severely malnourished children. Since we do not...

FEX: Introduction (Special Supplement 2)

Glossary ACF Action Contre la Faim CHA Community Health Assistant CHAM Christian Health Association of Malawi CNW Community Nutrition Worker CTC Community Therapeutic...

FEX: Letter on community mobilisation in outpatient management of severe malnutrition, by Saul Guerrero and Steve Collins

Community mobilisation at the core of outpatient treatment of severe malnutrition Dear Editor, There is now a robust evidence base demonstrating that the outpatient care...

FEX: Local Production of RUTF (Special Supplement 2)

By Dr Peter Fellows Introduction The development of RUTF has been an important factor facilitating the development of CTC. However at the moment, most RUTF is made in France,...

en-net: Blanket Supplementary Feeding Programs

Use of blanket Supplementary feeding programs is more and more being used to either prevent undernutrition in general as well as prevention of seasonal peaks of acute...

FEX: Series of letters on ENN conflict of interest, by Noreen Prenderville, Mark Myatt, Steve Collins and Mark Manary

A word from ENN In Issue 23 of Field Exchange, a letter by Mary Lunga'ho, Lida Lhotska and Rebecca Norton was published highlighting concerns they had regarding potential ENN...

FEX: From emergency food aid to sustainable food security: 10 years of agricultural recovery in Afghanistan

By François Grunewald François Grunewald is an agricultural engineer specialising in the rural economy. He has worked in the field of crisis and post crisis operations since...

FEX: ACC/SCN Working Group on Nutrition in Emergencies

The annual UN ACC/SCN meeting was held in Nairobi, Kenya between 2-5 April 2001. The Working Group on nutrition in Emergencies meeting was held on the 5th. Highlights of the...

FEX: Informal workshop on bioavailability of micronutrients in RUTF

Summary of workshop report1 Ready to use therapeutic foods (RUTFs) and ready to use supplementary foods (RUSFs) are two types of ready to use food (RUF) or more specifically,...

Close

Reference this page

Charlotte Dufour (2002). Ethics of use of ready-to-use-therapeutic foods. Field Exchange 17, November 2002. p22. www.ennonline.net/fex/17/ethics