Menu ENN Search

Famine Cry: Iraq

May 5, 2003

Dear Field Exchange

As we prepare to mount a colossal humanitarian intervention in Iraq, we should be circumspect and humble about our past foodaid operations in Afghanistan, Sudan, Somalia, Ethiopia and other countries where an overreaction of food imports has done more harm than good.

Even in the short term, it is imperative that we do everything possible to restore the agricultural self-sufficiency of Iraqis and not deepen a cycle of dependency. Although as many as sixty percent of Iraqis had received rations distributed through the Oil for Food Program, this food parcel was not the primary or sole source of family nutrition; it was more often a supplement. Since the initiation of the Oil for Food Program in 1997, there had been measurable improvements in malnutrition and even a rise in obesity. The twelve years of international sanctions and economic embargo on Iraq have made the Oil for Food Program a necessary food provision program. Iraq had been effectively isolated from the outside world. In anticipation of this war, the Baathist regime had been stockpiling foodstuffs for several months. Moreover, indigenous grain production in Iraq had begun rebounding over the past two years. Individual families were stocking their household pantries with reserves for months before the initial bombing began.

In our enthusiasm to prevent unnecessary suffering in Iraq, we are about to repeat the very same mistakes that other huge food logistics enterprises have made. When it comes to food handouts, our guild is slow to learn.

The most common occupation in Iraq is farming. More Iraqis derive an income from agriculture than from the oil industry. Support and promotion of Iraq's agricultural economy will be as critical to Iraq's recovery as will be its petroleum reserves. In addition, the large-scale unemployment in Iraq is creating a security problem that only meaningful vocation can remedy. Iraq has some of the most fertile land in the Middle East - hence "the Fertile Crescent" - and this land is copiously irrigated by the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers. Throughout the past decade, Iraq has been a net-exporter of dates and other produce. Are huge grain exports from affluent western countries to Iraq such a good idea? What the Iraqi farmer needs is reestablishment of trade links, restoration of international commerce, and the end to over a decade of economic isolation. What they need is trade, not aid.

The colossal exports of US and European-grown cereals does less for the subsistence farmer in Iraq, Afghanistan, or southern Africa than it does for the corporate interests of agribusiness and the modern western farmers receiving subsidies from their affluent governments. U.S. agricultural groups have been lobbying the Bush administration for months to ship American grown commodities to Iraq as this represented a new foreign export market for its surpluses.1

Large exports of grain from prosperous western countries to poorer ones - cynically referred to in the field as 'wheat dumping' - permits agribusinesses to legitimately dispense of the extraordinary surpluses of food that highly mechanized and subsidized western farmers produce. This is a supply-side solution and is not necessarily driven by demand. We should, rather, be exporting tools, irrigation technology, high-yield seeds, fertilizers, and technical expertise.

The nutritional challenges and interruptions in food supply in Iraq do not constitute a famine nor does it justify an over-reaction of food imports that may well compete or distract from efforts to increase local food production. Since food has become financially out of reach for people because of inflation, loss of income, and disruption of livelihoods then these root causes must be addressed, not only their symptoms. Cash-for-work programs and direct marketstimulus interventions that promote supply and drive prices down are effective antidotes to food crises. Employment programs, vouchers, and small cash grants given directly to displaced families-referred to as 'cash transfers'-are often effective, although still somewhat revolutionary and controversial among aid agencies that are used to distributing food rather than money. The injection of cash into a local market stimulates demand. Markets react by generating supply. Food suppliers will be attracted to the situation and beneficial transactions between food surplus areas and food shortage areas will be made.

Not unlike any large-scale commodity distribution program, a successful cash transfer project will require an experienced market analyst to monitor prices and effectively rebalance supply and demand variables and, ultimately, increase transactions on both sides. Although direct cash interventions are not a panacea, in many food crises this radical approach might be the most humane and intelligent gesture of compassion.

If the international community responds to Iraq as a famine - as we did in Afghanistan and numerous other humanitarian tragedies - the result will be the same: depression of market prices for locally grown commodities, disincentives for farmers to grow food, conversion of farmland to more profitable cash crops (read opium poppy), micro- nutrient deficiencies from eating unbalanced aid rations, and dependency on foreign food imports.

When the senior UN official said that the US should be "sending ships of wheat to the Persian Gulf along with ships of soldiers", did he even realize the irony of this statement? Although the coalition forces dropped bombs on Iraq, it would be cruel to dump our surplus wheat on them as well.

Gerald Martone
Director of Emergency Response
International Rescue Committee
122 East 42nd Street New York, NY 10168?
Tel: (212) 551-3061 Fax: (212) 551-3184
Email: gerald@theIRC.org

Show footnotes

1'U.S. Steps Up Plans for Food Aid to Iraq', Reuters, 18 March 2003, Richard Cowan

More like this

FEX: Iraq - Sanctions Take Their Toll

By Killian Forde Under article 41 of the United Nations Charter, the UN Security Council (UNSC) may call upon member states to apply measures not involving the use of armed...

FEX: Syrians in Iraq: Refugee response within a major humanitarian and political crisis

By Lynn Yoshikawa Lynn Yoshikawa is an analyst with the Syria Needs Analysis Project (SNAP) based in Amman, Jordan. She has worked in the humanitarian sector for over 10 years...

FEX: Division Over Sanctions on Iraq

In the last issue of Field Exchange we published an article which focussed on the effects of sanctions on Iraq. The likely impact of the 'oil for food' deal on food security...

FEX: Food Preparation an Obstacle to Education

This article is written by Betty Kidan Muni who is a field officer working for SCF with women's groups in south Sudan*. Background Betty Kidan (author of the article)...

FEX: China’s great famine 40 years later: a need for historical closure

Published Review Forty years ago China was in the middle of the world's largest famine where some 30 million people starved to death (see Field Exchange 8). A review1 article...

FEX: One hundred years of famine – a pause for reflection

Dublin '99 This piece was written by Fiona Watson, Institute of Child Health - NutritionWorks with contributions from the editors As the millennium draws to a close, memories...

NEX: Cash transfers for Somali refugees: experiences from a pilot programme in Ethiopia

Samuel Tadesse Samuel is working as a Nutrition and Food Security Consultant with UNHCR Ethiopia. He has more than 15 years experience in humanitarian response programs,...

FEX: How to assess and respond to Iraqi refugee needs in Syria

By Lucia Oliveira Lucia Oliveira has been working with ACF Spain since 2005 and is currently Head of Mission in Syria. Her background is International Relations, European...

FEX: Feeding the unborn babies

By Severin Kabakama Dr Severin Kabakama (MD Dar) is Assistant Project Officer (Early Child Development) in the Western Tanzania Refugee Program, UNICEF Kasulu Field Office. He...

FEX: Access to markets and services (Special Supplement 3)

6.1 Introduction In emergencies, access to markets may be lost for a number of reasons. Since most people live in a cash economy, restoring and maintaining adequate access to...

FEX: Suspected toxic ingestion outbreak in central Afghanistan

By Gerald Martone, International Rescue Committee (IRC) Gerald Martone is the Director of Emergency Response at the International Rescue Committee's Headquarters in New York....

Resource: Breastfeeding provides critical protection for Iraqi infants: news article

UNICEF warning that the policy of distributing infant formula free to all infants as part of Iraq's Public Distribution System (PDS) for food rations could lead to potential...

FEX: Household Food Economy Assessment in Kakuma Refugee Camp

Based on SCF (UK) field team experience in Turkana District, north west Kenya. Report by Mark Lawerence, Tanya Boudreau and Alexandra King summarised below. Over the past...

FEX: WTO Negotiations on Improving Food Aid

By Susanne Jaspars and Chris Leather, Oxfam GB Susanne Jaspars was the team leader for Oxfam's emergency food security and livelihoods team from October 2002 to June 2005. She...

FEX: Market analysis and humanitarian action in Niger

Summary of published research1 Women and children, in the village of Barmou, gather and wait to receive WFP distributed food In April 2005, a typical household in Niger...

FEX: DPRK in Crisis, What Do We Know?

This overview of the current situation in the DPRK and its context, was researched and written for Field Exchange by Killian Forde with editorial assistance from Lola Gostelow...

FEX: Has financial speculation in food commodity markets increased food prices?

By Noemi Pace, Andrew Seal, Anthony Costello Noemi Pace is research fellow at University College London, Centre for International Health and Development. She was previously a...

en-net: Nutritious food list

We are implementing nutrition capacity building program in Pakistan ,we are also identified malnourished children if we find SAM ,MAM case that we registered that family ,and...

FEX: WFP Assessment Mission

Children Posing next to a flag made out of the sacks used by WFP to drop food in Koch, upper Nile A three month assessment mission to Bahr El Gazal Region in Southern Sudan...

en-net: Nutritional implications of consumption of unmilled grain

Hello colleagues,

When unmilled grain is provided to a refugee or emergency affected population, and there are insufficient grinding mills, some of the grain will be...

Close

Reference this page

Gerald Martone (2003). Famine Cry: Iraq. Field Exchange 19, July 2003. p12. www.ennonline.net/fex/19/famine

(ENN_3664)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.