Selective Feeding Programme for Detainees in Rwanda
Authors: Michael Byrne and Annalies Borrel - CONCERN Worldwide
CONCERN is currently providing a supplementary wet-ration to over 7,500 detainees in twelve cachots (commune level detention centres) in Rwanda. The objective of this supplementary feeding programme is to reduce the burden of food provision on the families of the detainees and, indirectly, to assist households to become food secure. The programme is an interesting deviation from the wide range of selective feeding programmes that are characteristic of complex emergencies.
The Rwandan government reports that there are approximately 100,000 detainees in Rwanda's main prisons and cachots, some of whom have been waiting trial for a significant period. The numbers continue to rise and only a few have been tried or released. The Rwandan government has repeatedly requested international assistance to meet the costs of its justice system but international response has been small.
Food Security for Detainees and their Families - A Need for a Supplementary Feeding Programme
While ICRC provides food for distribution at the main prisons, the families of detainees are the only source of food for detainees in the overcrowded cachots. While such high numbers of detainees are present in the cachots, local government structures do not have, and most likely in the near future will not have, the resources to assume the responsibility for providing a nutritional supplement to the detainees in the cachots.
Detainee families are considered to be particularly vulnerable for several reasons. These include the reduction of income source and means of food production due to the imprisonment of a family member and the extra need to provide food for the detained relative. Managing to provide food is difficult for women and children because of the distances that relatives have to walk to the cachots (about 15km) and the risk of discrimination within their communities. For a significant proportion of families, the capacity to produce food has been drastically reduced as a result of a family member being detained.
This vulnerability is further exacerbated by the fragile food security situation that is evident in many parts of Rwanda, because of factors such as:
- large influx of recent returnees; over 1.3 million have returned from Tanzania and Zaire since November 1996
- limited access to arable land
- poor political security and breakdown of community structures
- loss of assets such as animals, tools and seeds; those returning home have to rebuild their livelihoods
- housing, rather than food production, is considered a priority need in the short term
- absence of animals for manure production leading to poorer soil fertility
- general increases in food prices
- poor rains during the recent agricultural season.
Under these circumstances, a large proportion of the population dependent on agricultural production is already vulnerable. The families of cachot detainees are especially so.
Evolution of CONCERN's Intervention
In September 1995, UN Human Rights requested CONCERN to discuss with local authorities the possibilities of working in the Gitarama cachot prisons. Following a needs assessment and negotiations with local authorities and ICRC, CONCERN targeted six of the 17 cachots in Gitarama prefecture for a nutritional support programme because approximately 55% of the detainees in these cachots did not receive food support from families or relatives. Between February 1996 and April 1997 there was an increase of 137% in the number of detainees in these cachots. Following repeated requests from the Prefect of Butare, CONCERN expanded into six communes in that prefecture in May and June 1997. CONCERN, currently, is the only agency implementing supplementary feeding programmes in the cachots.
During the initial stages, the objectives of the programme focused on the direct nutritional assistance to the detainees themselves. Although, the programme was in response to, and successfully addressed a very real humanitarian need there were weaknesses in the project design in the areas of:
- methods to maximise the contribution of the local community, army and the local authorities
- means to measure the impact of the programme and, most significantly
- a coherent exit strategy.
CONCERN addressed these areas in the evolution of the programme and the emphasis has been shifted from direct nutritional benefit to the detainees to assisting the families of the detainees in the community.
At the time of writing CONCERN provides a food supplement to detainees by providing one meal on three days each week, meeting at least one third of their weekly requirement. Hence, the potential for interrupting existing community links is minimised. Initially, food was provided for five days a week but this was reduced following a review of the programme and negotiations with the commune authorities. Relatives continue to visit the cachot and provide food on other days. Food brought to the cachots by relatives is shared between all detainees as approximately one third of detainees do not receive any food from relatives. By providing a nutrition supplement to the detainees, family and relatives have more resources and time for food production, school attendance and other activities.
A basic weekly food menu is followed which uses a combination of the locally available foods, (depending on availability and prices), such as beans, maize flour, sweet potato, cooking oil, salt and cassava flour. In addition, CONCERN provides a ration of UNAMIX to women and children detainees. To date, CONCERN has purchased all items in the local towns in Kigali as well as at commune markets near the prison. Large quantities of these commodities are required to meet the overall demands (see Graph 1) resulting in problems such as: dependency on CONCERN as the only food supplier; creation of temporary market demand locally (causing price increases); increased cost of overall programme and logistical difficulties in delivering food supplies on a regular basis. However, WFP have recently agreed to supply the basic food items to the programme via ICRC; this assistance will inevitably reduce these difficulties.
The local commune authorities support the programme by ensuring a supply of firewood, a food store and store-keeper and by permitting detainees to assist with water supply and food preparation. Local authorities are involved in programme planning, programme reviews and problem resolutions. While authorities have assumed greater responsibility for the implementation of the programme, CONCERN has still been able to maintain its role in monitoring food usage.
Given the sensitive nature of the programme there is a very real risk of local communities reacting unfavourably to CONCERN's work with the detainees. Therefore, concurrent activities within the communities are required to provide a balance for the support role in the cachots. Hence, CONCERN is addressing needs in the community and is involved in projects such as support to community associations, literacy, water rehabilitation and housing construction in the same communities.
Constraints, Problems and Issues facing the Programme
The programme continues to try to identify more sustainable alternatives. Establishing and working through local associations to collect and cook food for the detainees, working through local church structures, directly assisting the families of the detainees with food and creating food gardens at the cachots, have all been extensively investigated. None have yielded a viable solution. In particular, when the possibilities of increasing the role and capacity of local associations was considered, however, two major constraints were identified:
- the associations were put at increased risk within the community since they were perceived to be assisting those who were guilty
- under the current circumstances, assisting detainees and their families is not seen as a priority need for existing associations.
The potential contribution by detainees themselves, through participation in small scale food production, is limited. Two constraints are:
- lack of military staff present at the cachots to supervise this activity.
- lack of land within reasonable distance of the cachots.
The latter approach is currently unrealistic but may be more feasible in the future.
Access to a more direct and secure pipeline of food from WFP or ICRC on a longer-term basis is essential towards making the programme more sustainable. Strengthening of the government's legal and administrative capacity to process the large number of detainees will also be necessary.
The current CONCERN programme is a relief operation and is unsustainable. The need for and the time frame of the programme are dependent on a number of external factors. The continuation or withdrawal of the programme will therefore depend upon recommendations based on reviews at periodic intervals. The following indicators can be considered as triggers which would warrant an exit strategy:
- an improvement in the regional food security on the basis that a general improvement will enable the families to have an increased capacity to support the detainees. The food security situation should be reviewed on a periodic basis and the programme phased down when appropriate, over a six month period
- a significant decrease in numbers of detainees held in the cachots, perhaps down to pre-war levels (prior to 1995). Once detainees are transferred to the main prisons, food is provided by the local government structures.
Some of the detainees are most likely to be suffering from some form of nutritional deficiency. There have been a number of reported 'deaths as a result of malnutrition' however, the actual cause of death in most of these cases is rarely confirmed. Under the current design of the programme, severe malnutrition among the detainees can not be addressed for the following reasons:
- the diet is not suitable for adult therapeutic feeding
- current security and access restrictions in the cachots do not allow for the frequency and intensity of individual follow-up that are required to treat severe malnutrition.
Detainees suffering from severe malnutrition are referred to nearby health facilities, by ICRC delegates, responsible for monitoring the detainees' health status, or the commune authorities. No anthropometric assessment and monitoring of the nutritional status of the detainee population is being carried out in the cachots where CONCERN is working. Monitoring procedures such as these are difficult to implement due to security restrictions.
This programme has highlighted yet another scenario where some form of supplementary feeding programme may be deemed an appropriate intervention. The design and approach of the programme takes into account a number of considerations i.e. the involvement of local authorities, supporting rather than breaking family support links, presence of concurrent community activities in the same area and an exit strategy that is not defined by quantitative targets. There is an increasing need to recognise and to include this type of (detainee) supplementary feeding programme within the overall framework of different types of selective feeding programmes, by both donor and international agencies, particularly in the context of complex emergencies.
See also the Post Script to this article.
More like this
We asked Ariana Curdy of ICRC to comment on this article: This article raises most of the points I would want to make about the prison feeding programme in Rwanda. I will...
Delivering WFP wheat to the CONCERN store in Gjimij Connell Foley is part of the Concern Policy Development and Evaluation Directorate and went to Albania as part of Concern's...
en-net: standards for kitchens/storage/hygiene for institutional feeding or wet feeding, do they exist?
Dear colleagues I am looking for a document. guidelines, standards that give information on norms of hygiene, food storage, aeration, surface etc related to wet feeding...
Frances O'Keefe field worker Gisenyi - Concern Worldwide Between October and December last year escalating civil conflict led to hundreds of thousands of Hutu refugees...
en-net: scale model for adults
During assessment in places of detention (so for ADULTS) I had always used mechanical scales (the everlasting SECA). I would like to test a digital scale, and I am looking for...
By Lola Goselow This article is based on a field trip made by Lola Gostelow (SCF HQ emergency advisor) to the SCF programme in Huambo province, Angola in November 1999. The...
By Kate Ogden Since July 2000, Kate Ogden has been a food security advisor in ACF headquarters, Paris. Previously she spent three years working in food security and nutrition...
An ICRC Evaluation The ICRC has been operating agricultural programmes of various types in Angola since the 1980s. In the earliest phases, the programme distributed food aid,...
Summary of Published Review Field Exchange 10 highlighted a study underway by the Humanitarian Policy Group and Nutrition Works on the principles and practice for food...
By Emmanuel Mandalazi and Saul Guerrero, Valid International Ltd Emmanuel Mandalazi is a Social & Community Development Advisor working for Valid International. Over the last...
By Bruce W Larkin and Julie Tanaka View this article as a pdf Bruce W Larkin is a doctoral candidate (MD) at the Medical School for International Health at Ben-Gurion...
By Kate Sadler & Tanya Khara (Valid International), Alem Abay (Concern Malawi) In February 2002, the Malawi government declared a national nutritional emergency and the UN...
The author of this article is Zhara Mirghani with assistance from Rita Bhatia. Rita is the senior nutritionist in the Professional and Technical Support Services of UNHCR....
In the early to mid-1990s, Oxfam developed a one programme approach that combined relief, development and advocacy. The Wajir programme, which is described below, is considered...
Summary of assessment report1 Team members participate in a group session on mapping This article summarises the food security aspects of an innovative study by CARE,...
Name International Committee of the Red Cross Address 19, Avenue de la Paix, 1202 Geneva, Switzerland President Mr Jakob Kellenberger Telephone 00 41 22 734 60...
By Renuka Bery, Sahada Traore and Lonna Shafritz Lisez cet article en français ici Renuka Bery is the Integration Manager of the WASHplus project managed by FHI 360....
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), an independent humanitarian organization whose mandate is to provide protection and assistance for victims of armed...
8.1 Introduction The previous sections of this supplement have highlighted various challenges in livelihood support programming in emergencies. Most of these are within the...
Summary of a mid-term review Oxfam have recently completed a mid-term review of a cash for work programme implemented in Eastern Kitgum in Uganda. The micro-projects involved...
Reference this page
Michael Byrne and Annalies Borrel (1997). Selective Feeding Programme for Detainees in Rwanda. Field Exchange 2, August 1997. p3. www.ennonline.net/fex/2/selective