Potential of Using QBmix to Prevent Micronutrient Deficiencies in Emergencies
By Evelyn Depoortere, Epicentre
Evelyn Depoortere is currently a medical epidemiologist for Epicentre. Previously she worked on several MSF missions, including Southern Sudan during the 1998 famine.
The contributions of Sandra Simons (medical coordinator, Angola), Ann Verwulgen (field coordinator, Kuito), Dr. Paulina Semedo (Coordinator of the National Nutrition Programme) and Sophie Baquet (Nutrition Advisor, MSF-B) are gratefully acknowledged.
Thanks to the MSF team of interviewers in Kuito, namely Aldino Gilles, Amelia Vita, Azevedo Antunes, Custodio Albano, Daniel Alfonso, Isabel Domingas, Manuel da Saudade, Maria do Ceu, Ventura Sozinho, and Veronica da Costa. Also, the assistance of Ms. Rita Kakwarta, Provincial supervisor for Nutrition, in the supervision of the teams, is appreciated.
This article describes an assessment by MSF of using a micronutrient- rich food product, QBmix, in Angola and outlines possible strategies for the future in preventing micronutrient deficiency outbreaks in emergency affected populations1.
Household survey on how QBmix is used
Since the 1990s, Médecins Sans Frontières-Belgium (MSF-B) have worked in Kuito, Angola, as well as in several IDP (internally displaced person) camps around Kuito town. One of these camps, Kaluapanda, was established in March 2002 and has an estimated population of 4,400 people. During this period, MSF have been involved in a number of large scale emergencies in Kuito. However over the past year (2003), the situation has become much more stable, with the displaced population beginning to return home. The current MSF programme focuses on treatment of malaria and TB. MSF have also been implementing a pellagra treatment programme, which at the time of the study described in this article, was receiving 20-30 new patients every week. Most of those in this treatment programme were living in the city.
Between June 1999 and November 2002, there were four outbreaks of pellagra in Kuito town2. A total of 3859 cases were recorded during this period. During the first two outbreaks in 1999, the displaced population was the main group affected, with an attack rate of 4.7 per 1000 population. During the latter two outbreaks (2001 and 2002), it was the resident population who were most affected, with attack rates of 7.1 (in 2001) and 5.5 (in 2002) per 1000 population. In all outbreaks, women aged 15 years and older were the largest affected group.
Strategies to deal with micronutrient deficiency disease outbreaks like these, include food fortification, dietary diversification and supplementation (see box 1). However, these strategies all have inherent difficulties. For example, fortification requires that all people vulnerable to deficiency consume the food 'vehicle', while the use of supplement tablets or capsules may place a considerable strain on an already overworked local health system.
Box 1 A guide to Pellagra
Pellagra is caused by Niacin (Nicotinic acid) deficiency. The condition can be fatal and is often associated with other B vitamin deficiencies. Niacin (vitamin B3) is a water-soluble vitamin widely distributed in plant and animal food, but in very small amounts. Rich sources of niacin include groundnuts, fish, meat and pulses. The body can synthesise niacin from the amino acid tryptophan.
The recommended daily requirements range from 13 to 15 mg nicotinic acid equivalent for women and 16 to 19 mg for men. During pregnancy and lactation, an additional 2 and 5 mg nicotinic acid respectively, are required. For infants and children, 6 and 11 mg daily are recommended, respectively.
The initial clinical features of pellagra are non-specific and include anorexia, prostration, weight loss, headache and a burning sensation in the mouth. The fully developed syndrome, described by the "three D's", consists of dermatitis, gastrointestinal symptoms (diarrhoea), and finally mental impairment (dementia). The dermatological signs are usually most prominent, symmetrically affecting sun exposed areas like the arms ("pellagra gloves"), the cheeks in a butterfly distribution, and the neck and upper chest ("Casal's necklance"). Eventually the fourth 'D' can occur - death. When a niacin and/or tryptophan - deficient diet is consumed, the lead-time for developing signs of pellagra is about 2 to 3 months.
Populations consuming maize or sorghum and little else are at risk of pellagra. Niacin deficiency is now endemic at very low levels amongst the rural poor in Africa where maize is the principal cereal. Examination of rural health centre records may show a few cases - especially during the 'hungry season'. However, outbreaks of pellagra have only occurred in recent years amongst emergency affected populations, including Mozambican refugees in Malawi, Bhutanese refugees in Nepal, emergency-affected populations in Angola, and refugee returnees to Mozambique.
Strategies to prevent outbreaks of pellagra in emergencies include diversifying the general ration to include bioavailable sources of niacin, fortification of foods when maize is a staple food in the ration, allocation of surplus foods to allow food sale or food exchange for another food commodity, vitamin tablet supplementation, and cultivation or production of foods by the affected population.
Adapted from: Pellagra and its prevention and control in major emergencies. WHO/NHD/00.10 Available online at http://www.who.int/nut/documents/pellagra_prevention_control.pdf
The recent development of QBmix3, a mineral and vitamin rich condiment, offers an alternative to the above strategies (see box 2). In order to assess the feasibility and acceptability of using QBmix in an emergency-affected and food aid dependent population, MSF-B and Epicentre collaborated with the Nutrition Department in the Ministry of Health to test the product out in Angola. Specific objectives of the study were to:
- compare the overall cost involved of using Corn Soya Blend (CSB) and QBmix4
- describe advantages and difficulties related to introduction and use of QBmix
- describe the population's perception and acceptance
- make recommendations to MSF regarding the integration of QBmix in their future response to nutritional emergencies.
Box 2 Profile of QBmix
QBmix is manufactured by Nutriset. It has a shelf life of one year after manufacturing date, but studies are ongoing to improve this. It is recommended to store the product in a cool, dry place, below 30°C.
Use: QBmix is added to the family meal, like a condiment, after cooking only (not to destroy the vitamins). Preparation guidelines state to prepare the meal as usual, add QBmix® to the dish and mix well.
Recommended dose: One 210 g sachet meets the needs of 10 people for 2 weeks. A daily intake is not necessary - 21 g per person for a period of 2 weeks is sufficient (1.5 g/day) in 2 or 3 intakes per week. Overdosing is unlikely due to the very salty taste.
One 1.5 g dose of QBmix contains 7 mg iron, 400 mg folic acid, 34 mg selenium, 7 mg zinc, 600 mg vitamin A, 1.2 mg vitamin B1, 1.3 mg vitamin B2, 16 mg niacin, 5 mg vitamin B5, 1.3 mg vitamin B6, 2.4 mg vitamin B12, 90 mg vitamin C and 10 mg vitamin D. The equivalent of the height of the screw top gives 1.5 g of QBmix.
Adapted from the Nutriset QBmix guidelines for usage
Two different groups were sampled for the study. The first group consisted of pellagra patients admitted in the MSF treatment programme, while the second group targeted recently displaced families dependent on external food aid, and therefore at risk of micronutrient deficiency disease.
As the two target populations were different, they were treated as independent samples. Overall, 116 of the 168 pellagra patients who had received QBmix, and a random selection of 233 displaced families in Kaluapanda, were interviewed.
Acceptability of QBmix was assessed through a questionnaire administered during a population survey and was expressed as the proportion of families that used the product correctly and liked it. Atotal of 10 interviewers were trained to administer the questionnaire. Questions addressed included confirmation that families received QBmix, verification of how it was used, whether it was accepted by the family, and what was the perceived usefulness of the product.
Feasibility was based on estimating the micronutrient needs of 1000 people for 30 days and the weight, volume and transport costs compared to CSB. Caloric value (which is relevant for CSB but not QBmix) was not considered.
Accept ability and feasibility of using QBmix
Both groups, in general, reacted positively and liked QBmix (see table 1). The large majority used it correctly, adding it only after cooking, and using the screw top as a measure. Five pellagra patients (4%) (but no displaced families) said it tasted too salty, while seven (6%) said it made them feel unwell or sick. A small proportion of the pellagra patients (12.9%, n=15) and displaced families (5.2%, n=12) said they would not be prepared to buy it on the market, and various reasons were given for this (also table 1). Only one family did not use the QBmix at all because they did not like it.
All pellagra patients and displaced families considered QBmix to be good for health. Between 15% (patients) and 27% (displaced) said they did not add salt to a meal with QBmix.
Table 2 shows a comparison, in volume and cost, between CSB and QBmix. In order to meet micronutrient needs for a food aid dependent population, 60 100g/person/day of CSB are needed compared to 1.5g of QBmix/person/day. Thus for the equivalent micronutrient supply for 1000 people for 30 days, 40-66 times the weight of CSB is needed compared to QBmix. CSB needs to be transported by ship, which takes about 3 weeks to arrive in Luanda and 2-3 weeks for custom clearance. For QBmix, transport can be by plane (and therefore quicker) or ship.
|Table 1 Acceptance of QBmix in pellagra patients and displaced families in Kuito, Angola|
|Pellagra patients (n = 116)||Displaced families (n = 232)*|
|Frequency of QBmix use|
|. Every day||108||93.1||229||98.7|
|. 2 or 3 times a week||7||6.0||3||1.3|
|Easy to use QBmix||109?||94.0||232||100.0|
|Easy to add right quantity||111?||96.5||228?||98.7|
|Used screw top as measure||112||96.6||227||97.8|
|Added QBmix after cooking||115||99.1||228||98.3|
|QBmix left over||80||69.0||53||22.8|
|Like to use||115?||100.0||232||100.0|
|Like the sachet (packing)||114?||99.1||232||100.0|
|Easy to dose||111?||96.5||232||100.0|
|Like the texture||113||97.4||232||100.0|
|Like the colour||116||100.0||232||100.0|
|Like the smell||112||96.6||232||100.0|
|Like the taste||116||100.0||232||100.0|
|Refused by family||10?||8.7||4||1.7|
|Family wants more||110||94.8||229**||99.6|
|Someone felt unwell||7?||6.1||2**||0.9|
* The one family who did not use the QBmix is no longer included in the denominator
? One missing value, ** two missing values, ? three missing values
Source: MSF-B logistics in Luanda, Feasibility and costs assessment, Kuito, Angola, October 2003 Note: Prices originally given in US dollar, were converted to euro at the rate of 1.25 USD for 1 Euro.
Storage conditions for CSB and QBmix are similar, both needing dry conditions. CSB comes in plastic bags of 25 kg, while QBmix comes in aluminium sachets of 210g (70 sachets in 1 carton box). QBmix must be stored below 30 Centigrade. The shelf life for CSB is between 6-18 months but vitamin content declines over time. Shelf life for QBmix is at least 12 months, during which time the micronutrient content remains stable.
As required quantities of CSB are much greater, there is a time element involved in setting up appropriate distribution systems, whereas sachets of QBmix can be given out quickly. However, given its unfamiliarity, it does take time to explain why and how to use QBmix. For beneficiaries, it is obviously easier to take home a few sachets compared to a 9-15 kg bag.
Nearly all QBmix recipients found it easy to use, liked the taste and smell and would like to have more of it available in the future. Moreover, they would be ready to buy the product on the market if it were available. The majority of sachets were empty and many people spontaneously asked to receive more. Also, experience has shown that people in sub-saharan African like salty tastes, e.g. QBmix has been used to prepare meals in a prison in the Ivory coast after an outbreak of beriberi and was well accepted.
Compared to CSB, the volume and weight needed is considerably less for QBmix, leading to lower international and national transport costs. However, CSB also provides calories (380kcals per 100g) and people are familiar with it. In contrast, QBmix has few calories and people are unfamiliar with it, so resources are needed to explain the role and use of the product.
Distribution of QBmix
The results of this study cannot be generalised or extrapolated to other situations. For example, in Afghanistan, mothers in a therapeutic feeding centre did not like an earlier version of the product. Astandardised questionnaire has limitations, e.g. it may not capture all the information available from respondents. Furthermore, recipients were in a position of dependence on food aid so they may have not felt free to say what they really thought. They may have been afraid of being excluded from food distribution and felt that if they said what was expected, this would ensure they received the product again.
In the pellagra group, interviews were not necessarily conducted with those who prepared the meal. It was the patient who received the QBmix who was interviewed, so that the information was second hand.
Strategies for the future
In Angola, the need for QBmix has become less relevant, as fortified maize is scheduled for distribution and the situation is increasingly stable, with more people having access to a diversified diet. In other situations where MSF intervenes, QBmix and/or other products now on the market such as Topnutri-Fam , a nutrient concentrate that comes in the form of powder, may be more appropriate, and clear operational indications have now been defined. Even though these products are not the solution, they do provide one possible tool to prevent micronutrient deficiencies where there are no other sources of vitamins or minerals.
Explaining the use of QBmix
In large-scale emergencies, when the general ration programme is erratic, or unbalanced in terms of micronutrients, ready-to-use micronutrient supplementation products should systematically be distributed to vulnerable populations. This type of supplement can also be used in other situations. For example, for hospitalised patients, patients in TB or HIV treatment programmes, or in a prison setting, where the product could be systematically added to prepared meals 2 or 3 times per week. Although medical humanitarian agencies may not be directly involved in the distribution of general food rations, they do have a role in ensuring people have an adequate supply of micronutrients. Activities for such agencies could, therefore, involve lobbying for the use of this form of micronutrient supplementation with those agencies resourcing and/or implementing nutritional interventions, and social marketing in order to promote and explain the use of this type of product.
When introducing this type of new product onto the market, clear and adapted information should be given to the target population. For example, specifically for QBmix, key information to give at the time of distribution should include the following practical messages:
- the mix contains vitamins and minerals essential for health
- use one screw top per person
- use every day if possible, but 2-3 times per week is sufficient
- salt can be added if desired
- the mix should be added to the meal after cooking.
In order that the recipient population fully comprehend the role and significance of a product like QBmix, 'reference' persons from the community should be appointed who can be referred to at all times.
In conclusion, new products are now available on the market, which should facilitate the prevention of micronutrient deficiencies in food aid-dependent populations in emergencies. Aid agencies should be aware of the existence of these products and be ready to use them when indicated.
For further information, contact: Evelyn Depoortere, Epicentre, p/a MSF-Belgium, Dupréstraat 94, 1090 Brussels, Belgium. Email: email@example.com
1Micronutrient supply in emergencies. Logistic feasibility and population acceptability of food supplementation with QBmix, Kuito, Angola. Evelyn Depoortere, January 2004
2See Field Exchange 10, A Pellagra Epidemic in Kuito, Angola, by Sophie Baquet and Michelle van Herp
3QBmix is a registered trademark and is part of a range of products patented by IRD/Nutriset
4The World Food Programme (WFP) policy dictates that fortified Corn Soy Blend (CSB) is provided for populations completely dependent upon food aid and, therefore, at risk of micronutrient deficiency disease
5Produced by DANature Foods/Compact AS, Norway
More like this
By Sophie Baquet and Michelle van Herp Sophie Baquet is the headquarter nutritionist in MSF Belgium and Michel van Herp, Headquarters epidemiologist in MSF Belgium. This...
Summary of report* Since March 1999, successive waves of people have arrived in the town of Kuito, Angola, displaced by fighting in their native Bie province. As a result,...
By André Briend Andre Briend is a medical doctor, working for the Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), a French public research institution with a mandate to...
Unpublished report A pellagra outbreak hit war affected Kuito town, the capital of Bie Province in Angola in the second half of 1999 (see article in this issue of Field...
FEX: Issue 10 Editorial
Dear Readers, Over the past ten years large-scale outbreaks of pellagra have only occurred amongst populations dependent on emergency food aid. The most recent outbreak in...
Summary of published research 1 Signs of pellagra observed during survey A recent study initiated by the World Food Programme (WFP), in conjunction with the government of...
FEX: Issue 22 Editorial
The more cynical amongst us in the emergency nutrition sector may sometimes be heard complaining that there is nothing new in this profession and that we just keep re-inventing...
Report summary : The Institute of Medicine In 1995 the Senate Appropriations Committee Report directed USAID to initiate a pilot programme to increase the vitamin C content of...
FEX: Scurvy outbreak among South Sudanese adolescents and young men – Kakuma refugee camp, Kenya, 2017-2018
Read the postscript to this article here. Summary of research1 Location: Kenya What we know: Refugee populations dependent on food assistance are at risk of micronutrient...
By Dianne Stevens, Patricia Araru and Buwa Dragudi, Save the Children (UK) Dianne Stevens is a nutritionist with a Masters in Public Health and Tropical Medicine. She has been...
Name NUTRISET Tel +33 (0)2 32 93 82 82 Formed 1986 Fax +33 (0)2 35 33 14 15 Director Michel Lescanne Email firstname.lastname@example.org HQ staff...
Taken from draft guideline material prepared by Fiona Watson, Institute of Child health, London. Micronutrients are essential for life and are distinct from macronutrients...
By Steve Collins & Jeya Henry Developing CTC programmes that use Ready to Use Therapeutic Food (RUTF) made locally, from locally available produce, and used to treat...
Summary of Unpublished Study* Afgani boy with swollen and bleeding gums typical of scurvy. Micronutrient deficiencies have been reported in emergencies in populations who are...
FEX: Issue 15 Editorial
Two of the field articles in this issue of Field Exchange address to varying degrees the subject of advocacy. The dictionary definition of the word is 'recommendation' or...
Summary of published research1 Haemacue survey in Tanzania Five cross-sectional surveys were conducted in refugee camps in north and east Africa between 2000-2002 to assess...
We are planning to integrate MUAC measurement into Child Health Week. Our aim is to identify as many SAM as possible who will be referred to the closest CMAM site and to get a...
Summary of review1 Field haemoglobin testing using a hemacue machine Micronutrient deficiencies have been reported for years in emergency settings, especially in refugee...
A Joint Statement has been issued by WHO, WFP and UNICEF on preventing and controlling micronutrient deficiencies in populations affected by an emergency. It focuses on...
Summary of published field trial1 Premixing at the refugee camp site Nangweshi refugee camp was opened in 2000 in response to the influx of refugees fleeing the Angolan civil...
Reference this page
Evelyn Depoortere (2004). Potential of Using QBmix to Prevent Micronutrient Deficiencies in Emergencies. Field Exchange 22, July 2004. p11. www.ennonline.net/fex/22/potential