The Changing Role of Aid Policy in Protracted Crises
Published paper1
A recent HPG research briefing paper provides an overview of the changing role of aid policy in protracted crises. It starts with the premise that there has been a significant shift in the 'linking relief and development' debate over the past decade and that there has been an expansion of interest by the development community in these environments which presents both opportunities and challenges for humanitarian action. On the one hand greater attention and resources may go to supporting the basic welfare needs of populations living in difficult environments who have historically not received a proportionate level of aid. On the other hand, as the aid landscape in crisis countries becomes increasingly crowded, it may be difficult (particularly for belligerents) to distinguish between the different forms of aid and security being offered by the international community.
The researchers argue that there is evidence suggesting that a shift in the policy environment has resulted in increased spending and activity by development aid actors in countries undergoing protracted crisis. The research looked at a group of 16 countries experiencing protracted crises in Africa, Asia, the Caucasus and Latin America and the Caribbean. In 2002, these 16 countries received $6.3 bn of ODA, the highest level they had ever received. In late 2003 the World Bank had over 80 projects totalling $5.5bn in 13 conflict-affected countries. This is nearly equivalent to the entire official humanitarian aid budget for 2001. The EU has disbursed high levels of development funds over the past decade in countries such as Afghanistan, Angola and Somalia. Commitments made at the Financing for Development conference in Mexico in 2002 together with programmes such as the Global Fund for AIDS, TB and Malaria mean that global development aid budgets could continue to grow significantly in those countries that are the primary concern of the humanitarian community.
The study states that "while acknowledging that there is little formally articulated policy, let alone consistently implemented approaches it is possible to identify some important implications arising out of the global trends in international aid in these new environments".
- Countries around the world are experiencing very diverse forms of protracted crisis and aid responses differ significantly between countries and over time. The emergence of debates regarding aid to 'poorly performing' countries has the potential to influence how aid resources are managed in these situations. However these debates remain at an early stage.
- There is scope for much greater understanding across the humanitarian and development communities regarding the determinants and dynamics of crisis, and how these impact on populations and societies. Incentives and the appropriate skills for developmental staff working in these difficult environments remain poor. Reviewing the incentives, career structure and skills mix would appear to be a common priority for both the relief and the development community.
- The trend towards deeper engagement by the development community in situations of protracted crisis is likely to continue. In situations other than those where there is a process of 'post'-conflict transition, the predominant form of aid is likely to remain grants, rather than loans; issues of public debt will remain difficult to manage and aid will remain highly projectised, rather than programmatic, in form. In other words aid engagement will remain 'relief-like'. However there is the potential for new actors, in particular the World Bank, to play an increasingly assertive role in the coordination of this aid, and in effect to serve a quasi-sovereign role in 'governing' resource mobilisation and disbursement and prioritising service delivery for welfare provision.
- While the utilisation of non-state actors has enabled significant increases in the capacity of the international community to disburse funds quickly, major questions remain regarding how and whether these mechanisms will link to efforts to re-establish state capacity for the financing and management of public services. Despite the increasing prevalence of weak state capacity and legitimacy, there remains significant resistance to addressing these problems strategically and systematically.
- There is considerable variation in what is feasible. The parameters of aid engagement are influenced by a range of bureaucratic and procedural issues, as well as by 'higher' politics. How humanitarian actors seek to engage with their developmental colleagues in responding to the securitisation of aid, and in providing aid in highrisk environments will be important.
1HPG (2004): Beyond the continuum. An overview of the changing role of aid policy in protracted crises. HPG Research Briefing, number 16, July 2004
More like this
FEX: Importance of non-DAC donors in humanitarian aid
The bulk of humanitarian financing comes from a set of wealthy industrialised countries, a group best represented by the Development Assistance Committee (DAC) of the...
FEX: HIV/AIDS and Humanitarian Action
Summary of published report1 The Humanitarian Policy Group (HPG) have just published a report which examines the implications of HIV/AIDS for understanding crisis and the role...
FEX: Measuring the Impact of Humanitarian Aid
Summary of published paper1 A recent HPG Briefing Paper reports on research into how the humanitarian community measures and analyses the impact of humanitarian assistance....
FEX: Remittances during crises
Summary of published paper1 In disasters, remittances can play an important part in how people survive and recover. A recent Humanitarian Practice Group (HPG) briefing paper...
FEX: Synthesis of Key points from the SCN Symposium ‘Nutrition in the context of crisis and conflict’
Statement for endorsement by the UN Secretary General on Nutrition in Conflict and Crisis - 15th March 2002 As reported in the last Field Exchange, the ACC/SCN Sub Committee...
FEX: Issues and challenges for livelihoods programming in emergencies (Special Supplement 3)
8.1 Introduction The previous sections of this supplement have highlighted various challenges in livelihood support programming in emergencies. Most of these are within the...
FEX: Issue 24 Editorial
All the field articles in this issue come from either AAH or ACF staff. Two pieces deal with programmes targeted at the severely malnourished. Thierry Muriele writes about the...
FEX: References for Special Supplement 3
Beatrice, a beneficiary of the CRS seed voucher scheme in Burundi 1. Abdulai A., Barret, C., Hoddinott, J. (2004, June). Does food aid really have disincentive effects? new...
FEX: Critical gaps in drought response in Greater Horn of Africa
Summary of published research1 The drought currently affecting an estimated 11 million people in the Greater Horn of Africa is said to be the worst in more than a decade, with...
FEX: Dependency and Humanitarian Relief
Summary of research report1 In many emergency contexts, aid agencies hesitate to provide food and other aid for extended periods because of fears that this may create...
en-net: Re: Impact of food aid on agricultural labour supply and productivity
Dear en-net, There are so many arguments on the merits of food aid-short and long term. This appears rather a new topic in the forum. May some one link me to a web or provide...
FEX: Global Humanitarian Response 2017
Summary of overview1 A recent global humanitarian overview by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA) reports that, for 2017,...
FEX: Review of scale and drivers of persistent global acute malnutrition
Summary of research1 Location: Global What we know: The prevalence of global acute malnutrition (GAM) regularly exceeds the emergency threshold of >15% in protracted...
FEX: The state of the humanitarian system
Summary of report1 A recent report by ALNAP presents a system-level mapping and analysis of the performance of international humanitarian assistance between 2009 and 2011...
FEX: Cash-based responses in emergencies
Summary of published research1 A recent study explores the suitability of cash and vouchers in the full range of emergency contexts and finds that such responses are possible,...
FEX: Issue 26 Editorial
Over the years, Field Exchange has had its fair share of criticism to which the editorial team have always tried to respond positively. More often than not, we publish critical...
Blog post: Reflections from ENN - maximizing on the value and potential of the GNC and SUN Movement
ENN has returned from the Global Nutrition Cluster (GNC) annual meeting in Amman, Jordan, where it seemed that everyone was talking about the humanitarian development nexus as...
FEX: Gatekeepers in Mogadishu
Summary of report1 Summary prepared by Dina Sinigallia. Report authors: Erik Bryld and Dina Sinigallia (Tanya Copenhagen), Christine Kamau (iDC) Mogadishu Location:...
FEX: Regional humanitarian challenges in the Sahel
News Summary of research* Location: The Sahel What we know: The Sahel is currently in complex crisis fuelled by conflict, climate change and weak governance. What this...
FEX: Donors in humanitarian action: changing roles, trends and issues
changing roles, trends and issues Summary of a published review1 The changing role of donor governments in the management of humanitarian assistance is the subject of a...
Reference this page
The Changing Role of Aid Policy in Protracted Crises. Field Exchange 24, March 2005. p8. www.ennonline.net/fex/24/changingrole
(ENN_2404)