Dependency and Humanitarian Relief
Summary of research report1
In many emergency contexts, aid agencies hesitate to provide food and other aid for extended periods because of fears that this may create 'dependency'. A newly published HPG research report explores what 'dependency' means in a humanitarian context, how the term is used and the implications this has for how relief is provided.
The paper sets out how dependency is:
- generally seen as negative and to be avoided
- associated with the provision of relief, and contrasted with development approaches
- seen as undermining people's initiative
- contrasted with a variety of positive values or terms, notably independence, self-suffi - ciency, self-reliance and sustainability, and
- seen as a particular problem when relief assistance has been provided over a prolonged period.
According to the report authors, there are four main ways in which the term is used:
- Relief risks creating a 'dependency mentality' or 'dependency syndrome' in which people expect continued assistance. This undermines initiative, at individual or community levels.
- Relief undermines local economies, creating a continuing need for relief assistance and trapping people in chronic dependency on outside assistance.
- Dependence on external assistance is viewed as one of the features of extreme poverty, associated with a sense of shame or defeat.
- Dependency on relief resources on the part of governments - at local or national levels, warring parties or aid agencies.
The research report draws a number of important conclusions;
People depend less on relief than is often assumed. There is little evidence that relief undermines initiative, or that its delivery is reliable or transparent enough for people to depend on it. In practice, many concerns about dependency seem to stem from a preoccupation with the disincentive effects of food aid. Framing these real concerns in terms of dependency is unhelpful because this can provide an excuse for cutting back relief for people who may still be in desperate need. The more important question is what forms of assistance are most appropriate to prevent hunger, save lives and alleviate suffering. In situations where people's lives and livelihoods are under acute threat, and local capacities to cope with crisis are overwhelmed, being able to depend on receiving assistance should be seen as a good thing. The focus should be not on how to avoid dependency, but how to provide sufficiently reliable and transparent assistance so that those who most need it understand what they are entitled to, and can rely on it as part of their own efforts to survive and recover from crisis.
Discourses around dependency often blame the symptom, rather than the cause. Relief aid has often been the most visible, if not the only, form of international engagement in long-running crises. In these contexts, there is a tendency to criticise relief for failing to improve the situation, and enabling a movement towards recovery or development. Yet humanitarian aid may be a wholly inappropriate instrument for that purpose. The problem lies not with relief and its failings, but with the lack of other forms of international engagement with crises.
Relief should not be withheld without solid evidence that the needs which prompted it in the first place have been met. This is not to imply that agencies should ignore the potentially negative effects of aid, but it does suggest a need for caution about how the label 'dependency' is applied, and how it is used to justify reductions in relief.
1Harvey P and Lind. J (2005). Dependency and humanitarian relief. A critical analysis. HPG Research Report No 19, July 2005
More like this
FEX: Issue 26 Editorial
Over the years, Field Exchange has had its fair share of criticism to which the editorial team have always tried to respond positively. More often than not, we publish critical...
FEX: HIV/AIDS and Humanitarian Action
Summary of published report1 The Humanitarian Policy Group (HPG) have just published a report which examines the implications of HIV/AIDS for understanding crisis and the role...
FEX: SWP-CPN Pilot Study on Humanitarian Assistance
In recent years the nature of emergencies have changed so that the vast majority of humanitarian crises are now acknowledged to be conflict related. These emergencies are often...
FEX: References for Special Supplement 3
Beatrice, a beneficiary of the CRS seed voucher scheme in Burundi 1. Abdulai A., Barret, C., Hoddinott, J. (2004, June). Does food aid really have disincentive effects? new...
FEX: Remittances during crises
Summary of published paper1 In disasters, remittances can play an important part in how people survive and recover. A recent Humanitarian Practice Group (HPG) briefing paper...
FEX: Aid and Erosion of Humanitarian Principles in Sierra Leone
Guinea - Sierra Leonean refugees in the Gueckeodou region Published paper David Keene's article which is largely based on a review of humanitarian agency documents about...
FEX: Introduction (Special Supplement 3)
Glossary AAH Action Against Hunger ACF Action Contre la Faim ACF-E ACF-Spain ALDEF Arid Lands Development Focus AREN Association pour la Revitalisation de l'Elevage...
FEX: Use of cash in the tsunami response
As part of its Cash Learning Project, the Humanitarian Policy Group (HPG) at the Overseas Development Institute (ODI) is undertaking research into the use of cash in the...
FEX: Cash-based responses in emergencies
Summary of published research1 A recent study explores the suitability of cash and vouchers in the full range of emergency contexts and finds that such responses are possible,...
en-net: Re: Impact of food aid on agricultural labour supply and productivity
Dear en-net, There are so many arguments on the merits of food aid-short and long term. This appears rather a new topic in the forum. May some one link me to a web or provide...
FEX: New variant famine in southern Africa
Summary of presentation paper1 A paper, presented to a SADC2 Vulnerability Assessment Committee (VAC) meeting in Victoria Falls in October 2002, has argued that the famine...
FEX: Jordan Hashemite Charity Organisation
Name: Jordan Hashemite Charity Organisation (JHCO) Year founded: 1990 Address: Sa'eed Bino St, Khalda, Amman, Jordan President: Ayman Reyadd Almefleh Phone: +...
FEX: Global Humanitarian Response 2017
Summary of overview1 A recent global humanitarian overview by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA) reports that, for 2017,...
FEX: Emmanuel International
By Andrew Mellen, Emmanuel International Andrew Mellen has been the relief programme manager with EI Malawi since 2003. With a background in agriculture, he previously worked...
FEX: The Changing Role of Aid Policy in Protracted Crises
Published paper1 A recent HPG research briefing paper provides an overview of the changing role of aid policy in protracted crises. It starts with the premise that there has...
FEX: HIV/AIDS and Food Security
Summary of meeting Child-headed households benefiting from a home based care project Action Against Hunger (AAH) and Oxfam GB hosted an inter-agency meeting in London on Food...
FEX: Critical gaps in drought response in Greater Horn of Africa
Summary of published research1 The drought currently affecting an estimated 11 million people in the Greater Horn of Africa is said to be the worst in more than a decade, with...
FEX: Issue 19 Editorial
This issue of Field Exchange is dedicated to Prof. John Kevany (ENN Director) who died on 20th April 2003. John was instrumental in establishing the ENN. Given John's...
FEX: Cash and Vouchers in Emergencies
Summary of published paper1 Women have not been found to be disadvantaged by cash for work programmes A recently published discussion paper examines the use of cash and...
FEX: Issues and challenges for livelihoods programming in emergencies (Special Supplement 3)
8.1 Introduction The previous sections of this supplement have highlighted various challenges in livelihood support programming in emergencies. Most of these are within the...
Reference this page
Dependency and Humanitarian Relief. Field Exchange 26, November 2005. p13. www.ennonline.net/fex/26/dependency
(ENN_2321)