Study of the Risk Factors for the Development of Nutritional Oedema in North Kivu, DRC
By Mark Myatt and Frances Mason
Mark Myatt is a consultant epidemiologist and senior research fellow at the Division of Epidemiology, Institute of Opthalmology, University College London. His areas of expertise include infectious disease, nutrition, and survey design. He is currently working in Somalia.
Frances Mason is currently working part time as emergency nutrition advisor for Save the Children UK. Previously she spent three years as a consultant, following seven years with ACF - mainly as head of the nutrition and food security unit in Action Against Hunger UK.
This article is based on findings of a report written by Mark Myatt which, in turn, is based on the findings of research undertaken by Save the Children UK in DRC.
The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in the Great Lakes region of Africa has suffered a civil war since 1998. Prior to this, in 1994, a large influx of Rwandans sought refuge in Eastern DRC following the genocide. Despite the potential wealth and fertility of the east of the country, rates of severe acute malnutrition are often high, with kwashiorkor being the predominant form1, 2.
In response to increasing concerns about this high prevalence of nutritional oedema, Save the Children UK undertook a case-control study of the risk factors for the development of nutritional oedema in North Kivu, in the north eastern part of DRC3. The study was carried out in the Masisi Territoire which comprises of displaced Congolese, returnees and Rwandan refugees (many of whom live in villages in eastern Masisi).
|Table 1 Independent associations with nutritional oedema in children aged 6-24 months|
|Positive association with nutritional oedema (i.e. an increased risk)|
|adjusted odds ration (95% confidence interval)||p value|
|soya beans||7.40 (1.63, 33.68)||0.0015|
|sweetened or flavoured water, tea, infusion, or other liquids (including soups and broth)||12.88 (2.65, 62.62)||0.0000|
|fever||2.53 (1.22, 5.24)||0.0081|
|intestinal parasites||2.18 (1.03, 4.93)||0.0205|
|respiratory problems||2.80 (1.04, 8.67)||0.0318|
|diarrhoea||4.08 (2.19, 8.15)||0.0000|
|if mother is currently pregnant||4.50 (2.24, 10.01)||0.0000|
|Negative association with nutritional oedema (i.e. decreased risk of or protection against)|
|maize||0.53 (0.28, 0.99)||0.0222|
|other cereals||0.02 (0.01, 0.33)||0.0004|
|banana/plantain||0.09 (0.02, 0.36)||0.0000|
|avocado||0.25 (0.08, 0.78)||0.0072|
|sweet potatoes||0.06 (0.01, 0.42)||0.0002|
|any foods made with oil/butter/ghee||0.19 (0.05, 0.68)||0.0025|
|any food made with sugar/honey||0.43 (0.20, 0.87)||0.0083|
|haricot beans||0.03 (0.00, 0.24)||0.0000|
|having been breastfed in the previous 24 hours||0.16 (0.05, 0.50)||0.0000|
|having been weaned in the previous 120 days||0.16 (0.03, 0.88)||0.0071|
|Infant and child feeding index (ICFI) based on no. of food groups reported in previous 7 days||0.73 (0.60, 0.90)||0.0008|
|Increasing variety (no. of individual food items reported consumed) in the previous 7 days||0.79 (0.70, 0.90)||0.0000|
Data were collected on diet, breastfeeding (for children aged 24 months or below only), and disease. The study dataset consisted of 243 cases of nutritional oedema paired with 243 matched (i.e. 1:1 matched) controls, aged 6-65 months. Asub-set of the data, children aged 24 months or below (118 cases of nutritional oedema paired with 118 matched (ie 1:1 matched) controls), included data on breastfeeding which was analysed separately. Data analysis using appropriate methods (i.e. paired t-tests, Mantel-Haenszel methods, and conditional logistic regression) was carried out, controlling for sex, age and socio-economic status.
Dietary data were collected on whether certain listed groups of food items were consumed within either the previous 24 hours or the previous seven days. Data were re-coded so that reported consumption in the previous 7 days (as recorded) included reported consumption in the previous 24 hours. Associations between the listed food items (and indices based upon the reported consumption of the listed food items) and nutritional oedema are presented as pairwise associations between the reported consumption of a given food item and case or control status. This does not control for potential confounding effects in the data. Hence multiple conditional logistic regression (using the cLOGISTIC programme, an EpiInfo add-in programme4) was subsequently used, presenting the results as adjusted odds rations, their 95% confidence intervals, and the p-value for the maximum likelihood ratio test statistic. Only those variables with significant pairwise associations (i.e. p < 0.05) were included in the conditional logistic regression model. Non-significant variables were removed from the model using backwards stepwise elimination. The remaining significant associations are termed independent associations.
The case-control study found positive associations (i.e. increased risk) between nutritional oedema and the consumption of soya beans and sweetened or flavoured water, tea, infusion, or other liquids (including soups and broth). These latter fluids are often used for hunger abatement, providing children with a short-lived energy boost, replacing more nutritious meals and to 'supplement' breastmilk in non-weaned infants. Reported consumption of sweetened or flavoured water, tea or infusion, or other liquids (including soups and broth) in the previous seven days was independently associated with case or control status in children aged 6-24 months or below.
An increased risk also existed where the mother of the oedematous child was currently pregnant, hence cutting short the period of breastfeeding and potentially the time for childcare practices, which might otherwise enhance or protect the infant or young child's nutritional status. According to a survey Save the Children undertook in May 20055, it was revealed that local beliefs are to stop breastfeeding when a mother becomes pregnant. However, this same survey showed:
- 0-5 months: Exclusive breastfeeding: 62.8% (CI 95%: 56.6-68.9%)
- 6-8 months: Introduction of complementary foods: 84.9% (CI 95%: 77.7-92.1%)
- 6-23 months: Continuation of breastfeeding: 78.1% (CI 95%: 72,7-83,4%)
Cases were significantly more likely to have been weaned or to have been weaned for a longer period than controls. The data is, therefore, consistent with earlier weaning in cases than in controls. Further risk factors included if the child had suffered a recent episode of disease (fever, intestinal parasites, respiratory problems and diarrhoea).
The study found a negative association (i.e. decreased risk of or protection against) of nutritional oedema and the consumption of a varied diet. This particularly included consuming maize, other cereals, bananas/plantain, avocados, sweet potatoes, Irish potatoes, oil/butter/ghee and sugar or honey. Good infant and child feeding practices were also found to be protective, particularly breastfeeding.
In younger children, cases were more likely to be reported as having had a common childhood disease (ie diarrhoea, fever, ARI) before the onset of oedema (or, for controls, one month prior to data being collected) than controls. In all children, cases were also more likely to have had intestinal parasites (a condition that may be more severe in older children) or to have suffered from other (unspecified) diseases before the onset of oedema (or, for controls, one month prior to data being collected) than controls.
Subsequent (ie conditional logistic regression) analysis of the data revealed that a lack of dietary diversity (the overall number and presence or absence of specific food items in the diet), possibly at particular times of the year, is associated with oedematous malnutrition.
The data indicates that food insecurity, poor social care and limited access to public health are all potentially at play in determining the risk of a child having nutritional oedema. Agriculture and petty trade remain the principal economic activities in the region6. The main problems faced by the population include limited access to land (a fundamental cause of inter-ethnic conflict as, over the past few decades, poorer households have been forced off their land by the large landowners), crop disease and ash from the eruption of the volcano Nyamulagira (both of which have particularly affected the production of potatoes and sorghum). A lack of access to the prewar markets in Kinshasa and Western Congo has significantly reduced the prices of agricultural products since the supply is greater than demand. The area, therefore, is more cashpoor than food-poor. This particularly affects the poorest households who are reliant on their own harvest production and are unable to buy more diverse foods in the market. Alack of cash may also reduce access to health care - hence increasing the risk of disease - and may force the child's carer to find labour, thus further reducing time for child care and household food production. Time is already limited, particularly in the mountainous regions of North Kivu where most families travel long distances for water (taking up to 25% of their time in the day). Many of these households have no adequate storage which may further contribute to limited availability of clean water, resulting in cases of diarrhoea, worms and other intestinal diseases.
The positive association between illness and kwashiorkor suggests that kwashiorkor is part of a broader public health problem. Studies7,8 have shown that the poorest households are unable to purchase necessary items to ensure health care and a sanitary environment. In the latter of these two studies, 65-75% of income goes towards expenditure on basic food sources, reducing the available resources for healthcare even further than previous years.
For many years, kwashiorkor has been believed to be attributable, at least in part, to a deficiency in anti-oxidant nutrients9, resulting in high oxidative stress, primarily as a result of infection. The production of anti-oxidant enzymes that can protect the body from the harmful effects of this oxidative stress depends upon the presence of sufficient trace elements, such as selenium and zinc in the diet. Soya beans, which in the study are found to increase the risk of nutritional oedema, are high in phytic acid which, in turn, can block the uptake of essential minerals, including zinc. Only a long period of fermentation will significantly reduce the phytate content of soya beans. Soya is currently under promotion in Masisi and is used to make flour for porridge and soya milk used in tea, particularly amongst the poorer households who do not have access to cow's milk. Hence, the positive association between consumption of soya beans and nutritional oedema may be an indicator of household food insecurity, as well as the potential impact of anti-nutrient activity. Soya is also a component of the fortified flour (corn soya blend) given to malnourished children in feeding programmes. Anti-oxidant nutrients are strongly maintained in breast milk, which may also contribute to the protective nature of good infant feeding practices, demonstrated by the negative association with nutritional oedema. However, recent research has concluded that antioxidant supplementation of vitamin E, selenium, cysteine or riboflavin does not prevent the onset of kwashiorkor10. This study notes that previous research had entailed comparisons of biochemical variables in small groups of severely ill, malnourished children in hospital settings. This new research was a prospective trial investigating the role of antioxidants in the aetiology of kwashiorkor - hence indicating that antioxidant depletion may be a consequence rather than a cause of kwashiorkor.
During the past two years, Masisi has witnessed an upsurge of humanitarian interventions. Programmes are principally related to the restoration process and in particular, infrastructure rehabilitation (i.e. building roads, health centres, schools, etc.) and the provision of basic materials to some of these structures (essential drugs, school materials, etc.). Several agencies have recently initiated livestock activities. Some agencies have supported households to grow soya beans. While this remains a good source of nutrients (particularly protein), it is essential that this be cooked well to reduce the phytate content.
Future interventions should take into consideration the need of the poorer households for cash in order to provide greater dietary diversity, access to health care and support to carers/ mothers to ensure that they can afford to take care of their young children. Other recommendations include:
- Better immunisation, vaccination and pro motion of seeking early treatment.
- Diarrhoea control through hygiene promotion - protecting water sources and providing effective treatment with oral rehydration solution (ORS), and implementing measures to improve water availability, accesssibility and utilisation. If water is more accessible to the house-hold, it is likely that it may be used for sanitary purposes as well as the minimum for drinking and cooking.
- Adequate facilities for dispoal of faeces.
- Mass de-worming campaign and helminth control through hygiene promotion.
- Promotion of best weaning practices, probably within a family-planning programme.
- Promotion of best possible infant and child feeding practices and an emphasis on the inclusion in the diet of foods shown to be protective in this study. The utility of a 'kitchen garden' initiative could be investigated.
- In the longer-term, access to land and affordable health care-particularly the issue of user fees for the poorest households -must be addressed.
For further information, contact Frances Mason, Nutrition Advisor, Save the Children UK, email:F.Mason@savethechildren.org.uk
1In May 2005, SCUK undertook a nutrition assessment in which 2.8% severe acute malnutrition was found (95% CI 0.8%-4.6%) of which 1.9% was kwashiorkor and 0.1% was marasmic-kwashiorkor.
2UNSCN (2001). Report on the Nutrition Situation of Refugees and Displaced Populations. RNIS 34.
3Myatt M. (2004). Analysis of data from a matched casecontrol study of risk factors for the development of nutritional oedema in children in North Kivu, Democratic Republic of Congo. Save the Children UK.
4Dallal GE (1989). "cLOGISTIC: A Conditional Logistic Regression Program for the IBM-PC," The American Statistician, 43, 125.
5Save the Children UK (May 2005). Enquête nutritionnelle : Anthropométrie, mortalité et analyse causale de la malnutrition; Zone de Santé de Masisi (Province du Nord Kivu) ; République Démocratique du Congo; En collaboration avec le PRONANUT
6King A, Adams L (2000). Household Food Economy Assessment: Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Plaine de la Ruzizi Moyens Plateaux Savane, Foret Food Economy Zones of South Kivu Province and Zone Volcanique (Rutshuru) and Zone des Plateaux (Masisi) Food Economy Zones of North Kivu Province. Save the Children UK.
7SC UK (2000). Household Food Economy Assessment: Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, Food Economy Zones of South and North Kivu Provinces. Save the Children UK.
8SC UK. DRC Programme (2003). Update of the Household Economy Analysis of the Rural Population of the Plateaux Zone, Masisi, North Kivu, Democratic Republic of Congo. Save the Children (UK).
9Golden MHN (1998). Oedematous malnutrition. British Medical Bulletin 1998:54 (No. 2): 433-444.
10Ciliberto H, et al (2005). Antioxidant supplementation for the prevention of kwashiorkor in Malawian children: randomised, double blind, placebo controlled trial. BMJ, doi:10.1136/bmj. 38427.404259.8F (published 25 April 2005). See summary in this issue of Field Exchange.
More like this
By Dominique Brunet and Frances Mason Dominique Brunet is currently working as a nutritionist with SC UK. She has 10 years of experience with SC UK, ACF and Oxfam. This...
FEX: Improving child nutrition and development through community-based child care centres (CBCCs) in Malawi
Summary of presentation1 View this article as a pdf By Aisha Twalibu, Natalie Roschnik, Aulo Gelli, Mangani Katundu, George Chidalengwa, Peter Phiri and Helen Moestue Aisha...
By Anna Taylor, Nutrition Advisor, SC UK Summary of internal evaluation Save the Children UK (SC UK) began implementing emergency health and nutrition interventions in...
en-net: Causality Analysis
Does someone know where I can get resources or information on experiences and standard design for conducting causal analysis of malnutrition?
as far as I know,...
NEX: The challenges faced in providing sustainable management of acute malnutrition services in Ituri Province, Democratic Republic of the Congo
Cosma Bakemwanga Sapeke is the coordinator of the Ituri National Nutrition Programme (Pronanut by its French acronym) in Bunia, Democratic Republic of Congo. He has worked at...
Summary of evaluation1 Masisi Centre fair In late 2008, escalated fighting among rebels and the Congolese Armed Forces (FARCD) provoked renewed and widespread displacement in...
FEX: Improving the quality of nutritional survey data worldwide: Putting Child Kwashiorkor on the Map Initiative
By Lauren Browne Lauren Browne is the Data Manager for the Kwashiorkor Mapping project and joined the team after interning with ACF-UK and Save the Children UK. She completed...
Women carrying grass grown in the Awassa region of Ethiopia, which they sell in the market to get a small income. Summary of analysis1 The study described in this article was...
Based on the nutritional information of the two products, there is no difference in nutritional composion (energy,protein, Fat, and micronutritient) except plumy nut has animal...
Summary of published research1 A village of mothers waiting to enroll their children in Chipalonga A recent study set out to evaluate the efficacy of antioxidant...
Jose Luis Alvarez, Nicky Dent, Lauren Browne, Mark Myatt and André Briend Putting Kwashiorkor on the Map started as a call for sharing data to give an idea of...
FEX: Determining predictors for severe acute malnutrition: Causal analysis within a SQUEAC assessment in Chad
By Ruwan Ratnayake, Casie Tesfai and Mark Myatt Ruwan Ratnayake is the Epidemiology Technical Advisor with the International Rescue Committee based in New York. He supports...
Intrepreting weight measurements Summary of published research1 A recent published study set out to assess community volunteers' effectiveness in monitoring the growth of...
By Abigail Moyo, Eunice Bwalya Chishimba and Mary Corbett Abigail Moyo is the Nutrition Facilitator with Self Help Africa (SHA), working in Luwingu District since May 2014....
FEX: Effects of nutritional supplementation for HIV patients starting antiretroviral treatment in Ethiopia
Summary of research1 Location: Ethiopia What we know: Poor nutritional status at initiation of ART is associated with impaired treatment outcomes among African patients with...
Summary of published paper1 An infant having MUAC measured during the study in Kenya Current WHO guidelines for the management of severe malnutrition in children recommend...
FEX: New implications for controversial kwashiorkor treatment discussed in Paediatrics and International Child Health
Summary of research1 The latest issue of Paediatrics and International Child Health sees leading experts in the field of malnutrition address the ongoing controversy...
Author: Goete Hertz, Supply Officer, UNICEF Emergency Programme in Kenya 1992-1995. Now head of Product Development in House of Menji, Nairobi The use of supplementary...
Moringa is a nutritious tree grown in the tropics, sometimes called the ‘miracle tree’. Does anyone have any good programming examples that they can share with us at Save...
en-net: Treatment of kwashiorkor child
Below is a question received by a field colleagues. Advice will be appreciated. QUOTE: I currently treat in the pediatric ward an 8 year old, 12 kg girl with a miliary Tb and...
Reference this page
Mark Myatt and Frances Mason (2005). Study of the Risk Factors for the Development of Nutritional Oedema in North Kivu, DRC. Field Exchange 26, November 2005. p4. www.ennonline.net/fex/26/riskfactors