ENN/SC UK investigation of impact and effectiveness of SFPs
A SFP as part of a community therapeutic care programme in Niger
The ENN and Save the Children UK (SC UK) have just begun a joint research study to assess the impact and effectiveness of emergency supplementary feeding programmes (SFPs). The rationale for the study is that there has been no credible overall assessment of the impact or effectiveness of these programmes. Critics of emergency SFPs have raised questions about their appropriateness in the absence of adequate general rations (a frequent occurrence during emergencies) and the relative cost-inefficiency of setting up a separate infrastructure from the general ration programme in order to allocate small quantities of food to vulnerable groups. Furthermore, there are many examples of emergency SFPs that have failed to meet SPHERE targets due to factors like insecurity, difficult terrain and resulting poor access, and staffing problems. A recent review of published evidence for impact of SFPs in emergencies between 1980 and 2004 involving five data bases revealed that only a minute percentage of programmes have been rigorously evaluated in terms of impact with findings published.
The ENN/SC UK study will include targeted and blanket SFPs in acute and chronic emergencies with a main focus on children under five years of age. A minimum of 156 SFPs implemented by 15 agencies over the past three years will be included in the review. These programmes have been implemented in Africa (19 countries), Central Asia (2 countries), South Asia (2 countries), Far East Asia (1 country), and Central and South America (3 countries). Aconsortium of agencies is providing funding for the work.
There are four primary objectives for the study:
Objective 1: To describe the characteristics of emergency SFPs implemented in recent years (targeted and blanket), e.g. objectives, protocols, adherence to current guidelines, type of population served and characteristics of population, etc. Blanket and targeted programmes will be presented separately. Where possible, major events that affected the programme during implementation will be described, e.g. breaks in food aid pipeline, attacks, absence of staff, overcrowding, etc.
Objective 2: To assess the effect of emergency SFPs on patients enrolled in the programmes (efficacy of the protocol) and the organisation and contextual factors impacting outcome. Outcomes will include recovery rates, rates of weight gain, and duration of stay in programme. Attendance and defaulter rates will also be considered.
Objective 3: To assess the impact of emergency SFPs in the population (effectiveness of the programme) and the contextual factors influencing impact. The key indicator for this will be malnutrition and mortality rates in the population as well as programme recovery rates and coverage.
Objective 4: To describe and compare the costs of SFPs in different emergency contexts and to compare these costs with other types of intervention with similar objectives, e.g. expanded general ration programmes.
It is hoped that the study will be completed and written up by September 2006. Findings will be summarised in Field Exchange.
For further information contact Frances Mason, SC UK, email: f.mason@savethechildren.org.uk or Jeremy Shoham, ENN, email: jshoham@easynet.co.uk.
1Duffield. A et al (2004). Review of the published literature for the impact and cost-effectiveness of six nutrition related emergency interventions. Report prepared by the ENN, December 2004. Available in print from the ENN or online at http://www.ennonline.net
More like this
en-net: SFPs - what is wrong with them and can we fix it?
Latest after Carlos Navarro-Colorado's (et al) paper on the effectiveness of SFPs there is a tendency to turn away from them as the message seems to be misinterpreted. Do we...
FEX: Meeting on approaches to address moderate malnutrition in emergencies
The Emergency Nutrition Network (ENN) and Save the Children UK (SC UK) recently held a meeting on approaches to address moderate malnutrition in emergencies (29th-30th May...
FEX: Learning from nutrition interventions in Eritrea, Ethiopia and Kenya
Summary of evaluations1 SC UK survey team in Eriteria SC UK recently evaluated a number of emergency nutrition responses undertaken in Eritrea (Gash Barka and Northern Red...
Review of the efficacy and impact of emergency programmes
Donor: CIDA Collaborators: SCUK and Westminster University ENN Project Lead: Jeremy Shoham Timeframe: Project completed in 2011 Background This project was undertaken in...
FEX: Minimum Reporting Package (MRP) on Supplementary Feeding Programmes
In order to evaluate the quality and impact of nutrition interventions, agencies need effective monitoring and reporting systems in place for programmes. A retrospective...
FEX: ENN secures funding for SFP Research Projects
The ENN has just received a grant from USAIDs Office of U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA) to carry out two projects related to emergency supplementary feeding programmes...
Resource: A summary of the study protocol for a cash transfer intervention study in Niger
Background A review of emergency Supplementary Feeding Programmes (SFPs) was undertaken in 2005/2006, which concluded that such programmes which are targeted to already...
Defaulter and Access Study
Donor: OFDA Collaborators: CDC, ACF, Concern Worldwide, Save the Children UK ENN Project Lead: Jeremy Shoham Timeframe: Project completed in 2011 (report forthcoming)...
FEX: Update on Minimum Reporting Package (MRP) trainings in London and Nairobi
By Emily Mates, Nutrition Advisor, MRP, Save the Children UK The ‘Minimum Reporting Package’ (MRP) has been developed to support standardised data collection for emergency...
FEX: Difficulties of impact assessment in ‘semi-emergencies’
By Tayech Yimer, Anne Marie Mayer and Arabella Duffield Tayech Yimer is a nutritionist with SC UK in Ethiopia. Anne-Marie Mayer has worked with SC UK for nine months in...
FEX: Issue 30 Editorial
Many pieces in this issue of Field Exchange strengthen our understanding of best practice in nutritional emergencies. We highlight four in this editorial. Victoria Sibson from...
en-net: Vacancies for Save the Children UK / ENN project supporting the introduction of the Minimum Reporting Package for SFPs
Save the Children UK and the ENN are excited to have four positions open (for nutritionists/similiar background with familiarity with SFPs) to lead and run this 18 month ECHO...
FEX: Emergency Supplementary Feeding
Supplementary Feeding Programmes (SFPs) are amongst the oldest and most common type of nutritional intervention in developing countries. The main aim of SFPs in both emergency...
FEX: Issue 28 Editorial
This issue of Field Exchange features four field articles about community based therapeutic care of the severely malnourished, a type of programming that is increasingly being...
en-net: Blanket Supplementary Feeding Program(BSFP) Does it need anthropometric measurements?
Dear Team, we are in an emergency sitruation where GAM rate is 30%, Food Insecurity status(IPC 4), and crisis. As a response to that, one of our emergency response is General...
en-net: RUTF made with locally available products
The majority of RUTF being used in CMAM programmes are peanut and milk based pastes. I am aware of several groups who are working on developing RUTF pastes using locally...
FEX: Issue 27 Editorial
Every emergency has a habit of throwing up fresh challenges which force us to re-examine our understanding of vulnerability and how best to respond. However, as shown in this...
FEX: WHO consultation on management of moderate malnutrition in U5s
The WHO, in collaboration with UNICEF, WFP and UNHCR, hosted a second consultation to discuss the programmatic aspects of the management of moderate malnutrition in children...
FEX: Contextual data collection in nutrition surveys in Ethiopia
Women carrying grass grown in the Awassa region of Ethiopia, which they sell in the market to get a small income. Summary of analysis1 The study described in this article was...
FEX: Revised MSF Nutrition Guidelines II
By Saskia van der Kam, MSF Holland, Senior Nutritionist This is the second in a series of pieces published in Field Exchange* which summarises key sections of the newly...
Reference this page
ENN/SC UK investigation of impact and effectiveness of SFPs. Field Exchange 27, March 2006. p11. www.ennonline.net/fex/27/sfp
(ENN_2284)