Counselling on infant feeding choice: Some practical realities from South Africa
By Tanya Doherty (pictured), Mickey Chopra and Mike Colvin
Tanya is currently a senior scientist at the Health Systems Trust and Medical Research Council in Capetown, South Africa. For the past five years, her research has focused on PMTCT of HIV involving national evaluations of programme coverage, qualitative investigation of infant feeding, and a multi-site cohort study assessing HIV transmission. Her main area of interest is implementation of infant feeding recommendations in operational settings.
Mickey Chopra is Director of the Health Systems Research Group of the South Africa Medical Research Council.
Mark Colvin is a Director of the Centre for Aids Development, Research and Evaluation (CADRE), and is based in Durban, South Africa.
A health worker interviewing a mother on a home visit
Avoiding transmission of HIV from mother to child after birth has become one of the greatest challenges in HIV prevention. Approaches to date to reduce or prevent postnatal transmission through breastfeeding have included the avoidance of all breastfeeding through the use of exclusive replacement feeds, or exclusive breastfeeding for a limited duration with early and rapid cessation of breastfeeding as soon as it is feasible (see box).
Implications of infant feeding choice
Programmes for prevention of mother to child transmission (MTCT) need to focus not only on preventing HIV transmission but also on improving child survival. Exclusive breastfeeding has been identified as the single most effective way of saving the lives of millions of young children in developing countries1, a fact that is supported by international policy2 and operational guidance for emergency contexts3. Although most infants in sub-Saharan Africa are breastfed, rates of exclusive breastfeeding are low as early introduction of liquids is a common practice. It is against this background that infant feeding recommendations for women with HIV are being implemented. If women with HIV are to succeed in practising exclusive infant feeding, then improvements in infant feeding practices in the general population are necessary to ensure that exclusive breastfeeding is the norm rather than an exception.
A recent study4 from South Africa has confirmed earlier findings5 that exclusive breastfeeding results in a lower rate of postnatal HIV transmission compared to mixed feeding. This study, undertaken in a rural area in KwaZulu- Natal province, found a cumulative postnatal HIV transmission risk of 4.04% after five months of exclusive breastfeeding. Infants who were fed both breast and formula milk at age twelve weeks were twice as likely as exclusively breastfed infants to be infected (HR 1.82, 95% CI: 0.98-3.36).
Recent data from Mozambique6 and the ZVITAMBO study in Zimbabwe7 have highlighted the dangers of early cessation of breastfeeding under conditions of underlying poor socio-economic status and food insecurity. In Mozambique, commonly consumed, locally available foods would not meet the nutritional needs of non-breastfed infants between 6-12 months of age and replacing breastmilk with local foods would double the estimated daily cost of feeding a 6-12 month infant. In Zimbabwe, most of the infant diets only met 58% of the infant's energy needs and were insufficient in animal milks or formula.
Replacement feeding means feeding an infant a diet that provides the necessary nutrients while receiving no breastmilk. Recent research and experiences from Botswana (see research summaries in this issue of Field Exchange) highlight the risks of formula feeding and reinforce the importance of individual assessments of home and environmental circumstances in the process of decision-making. In low and middle income countries and in emergency contexts, replacement feeding is unlikely to be the most appropriate choice for HIV positive women due to socio-economic environments that are not conducive to safe replacement feeding.
The importance of counselling
Given the implications that infant feeding choice may have for child survival, infant feeding counselling and support is one of the most important components of PMTCT programmes.
In many countries, shortcomings in the implementation of the WHO guidelines have been found. Inadequate training of health workers, particularly infant feeding counsellors, about the relative risks associated with infant feeding in the context of HIV, lack of culturally sensitive counselling tools, and the stigma associated with replacement feeding, all make appropriate and effective infant feeding counselling difficult.
Within the context of busy antenatal clinics, it is not surprising that the quality of infant feeding counselling has generally been found to be poor.
One intervention that has been shown in a variety of settings to increase exclusive breastfeeding is peer counselling. Peer counselling is a proven cost-effective approach for changing behaviour. Community-based interventions using local women's groups have also been shown to change behaviour in relation to infant feeding and birth outcomes.
Guidelines for infant feeding and HIV/AIDS
Current UN guidelines state when replacement feeding is acceptable, feasible, affordable, sustainable and safe, avoidance of all breastfeeding by HIV-infected mothers is recommended. Otherwise, exclusive breastfeeding is recommended during the first months of life and should then be discontinued as soon as the above conditions are met. HIV and Infant Feeding. A guide for healthcare managers and supervisors. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2003.
revalence of HIV infection, the risk to infants of being infected with HIV through breastfeeding should be carefully weighed against the risk of their becoming seriously ill or dying from other causes if they are not breastefed".
Guiding principles for feeding infants and young children during emergencies. WHO, Geneva. 2003
Investigation of Infant feeding choice and practices in South Africa
Due to the poor follow up of HIV positive women through routine public health services in South Africa, very little is known about the actual infant feeding practices of this group. In order to describe these practices, the national Department of Health of South Africa (DoH) commissioned a group of research institutions to conduct a prospective cohort study known as the 'Good Start' study in three PMTCT sites; Paarl (rural/peri-urban Western Cape), Umlazi (peri-urban KwaZulu- Natal) and Rietvlei (rural Eastern Cape) in South Africa.
Paarl is situated 60 km from Cape Town in the heart of the Winelands region. The approximate total population for the district is 198 546. Paarl East Hospital currently renders 97% of antenatal care services in the district with an average of 210 - 381 new bookings per month. All deliveries are done at Paarl Regional Hospital. The antenatal HIV prevalence is 9% and the infant mortality rate is 30 per 1000 live births.
Umlazi is a peri-urban formal township with interspersed informal settlements situated roughly 20km southwest of Durban, in the Durban-Ilembe health district in KwaZulu- Natal Province. There is one regional hospital, Prince Mshiyeni Memorial Hospital that serves as a referral hospital for the surrounding feeder clinics. Maternity services (including a 40-bed antenatal ward and 40-bed labour ward) and paediatric services (including a neonatal unit and paediatric outpatient services) are available at the hospital. The antenatal HIV prevalence is 47% and the infant mortality rate is 68 per 1000 live births.
Rietvlei is situated in one of the poorest sub-district of South Africa. The infant mortality rate is 99/1000 live births. Diarrhoea, malnutrition and lower respiratory tract infections are the major causes of infant mortality. A community survey in the neighbouring Mount Frere district found out that 40% of mothers reported delivering their last child at home. The antenatal HIV prevalence is 28%.
This study recruited 665 HIV positive women and followed them until their infants were 36 weeks of age through regular home-based interviews and assessments of infant feeding practices and HIV transmission.
The infant feeding intentions (i.e. how they planned to feed their infant following counselling) of women enrolled in the study differed greatly between the sites (Figure 1) and did not reflect what would be expected for the socio-economic or geographic region, i.e. more women in the rural Rietvlei site chose to formula feed. Qualitative research8 has shown that women rely heavily on the advice of health workers in guiding their feeding choices. The power and influence of health workers over mothers feeding choices was also found to have increased with the new knowledge that they possessed regarding HIV and infant feeding.
The home circumstances of women choosing to breastfeed and women choosing to formula feed were similar in terms of access to piped water, a sustainable source of cooking fuel, household income and use of a fridge. There were, however, higher rates of disclosure of HIV status amongst women who chose to formula feed (figure 2). This clearly indicates that the WHO/ UNICEF guidelines are not being utilised in counselling resulting in poor infant feeding decisions being made on both sides, i.e. inappropriate choices to breastfeed and to formula feed.
Given the finding that many women in this observational study did not appear to be making appropriate infant feeding choices, we sought to identify key individual and environmental criteria that could be used to guide appropriate infant feeding choices in operational settings, and to assess the effect of inappropriate feeding choices on infant HIV-free survival.
Criteria to guide infant feeding choice
Criteria deemed to constitute appropriateness of formula use based on the WHO/UNICEF guidelines (acceptable, feasible, affordable, sustainable and safe) were identified as piped water in the house or yard; electricity, gas or paraffin for cooking fuel; disclosure of HIV status by three weeks postpartum; having someone in the household employed; and access to a fridge for storage of prepared formula. Further analysis was undertaken to determine which of these criteria best predicted infant HIV-free survival.
Children playing in the Paarl informal settlement, one of the survey sites
Implications of inappropriate choice on HIVfree survival
An assessment score with piped water in the house or yard, electricity, gas or paraffin for cooking fuel and HIV status disclosure, was deemed to be the best measure of appropriateness in terms of yielding the greatest benefit for HIV free survival. Based on this score, amongst women who intended to formula feed, 67.4% made an inappropriate choice and amongst women who intended to breastfeed, 30.5% met the defined criteria for appropriate formula feeding. Infants of women who were classified as inappropriate formula feeders (i.e. not meeting the criteria in the score) had a three times greater risk of HIV transmission or death compared to women who chose to formula feed who did meet the three criteria. This finding highlights the importance of adequate assessment of individual and environmental circumstances during infant feeding counselling.
These infant feeding choices and practices lead to different rates of late HIV transmission across the three sites (figure 3). Only the Paarl rate was similar to a previous Breastfeeding and HIV International Transmission Study (BHITS) meta-analysis9. In Umlazi, the late transmission (3-36 weeks) accounted for almost half of the overall transmission and in Rietvlei it accounted for over half of total transmission and almost triple the rate at 36 weeks found in the BHITS meta-analysis.
Dried blood spot method for mother's viral load testing
Based on our research we make the following recommendations;
- Exclusive breastfeeding for six months is recommended as the preferred infant feeding method for HIV positive women in the first 6 months until replacement feeding is acceptable, feasible, affordable, sustainable and safe (AFASS) for them and their infants
- All HIV exposed infants should receive regular follow up care and periodic reassessment of infant feeding choices based on individual and environmental circumstances.
- At six months, if AFASS criteria are not met, HIV-infected women should continue to breastfeed their infants and give complementary foods in addition, and return for regular follow-up assessments. As soon as AFASS criteria are met all breastfeeding should stop.
- Breastfed infants who are HIV-infected should continue to be breastfed according to the infant feeding recommendations for the general population.
- Protection, promotion and support for optimalbreastfeeding practices in the general population should be re-vitalized in order to help HIV-infected and other women who choose exclusive breastfeeding to practise their choice without stigma or discrimination.
- All HIV-exposed infants and their mothers should receive the full package of maternal health and child survival interventions with strong linkages to HIV prevention, treatment and care services.
For further information, contact Tanya Doherty, email: Tanya@hst.org.za For more details on related work, see online at: CADRE: http://www.cadre.org.za Health Systems Trust: http://www.hst.org.za MRC South Africa: http://www.mrc.ac.za
1Black RE, Morris SS, Bryce J. Where and why are 10 million children dying every year? Lancet 2003;361(9376):2226-34. and Jones G, Steketee RW, Black RE, Bhutta ZA, Morris SS, Bellagio Child Survival Study G. How many child deaths can we prevent this year? Lancet 2003;362(9377):65-71.
3Operational Guidance on Infant and Young Child Feeding in Emergencies. For Emergency Relief Staff and Programme Managers. Version 2.0, May 2006. Avaialble from the ENN and at http://www.ennonline.net
4Rollins N. HIV transmission and mortality associated with exclusive breastfeeding: implications for counselling HIVinfected women. International AIDS Conference. Toronto: PATH Satellite Session, 2006
5Coutsoudis A, Pillay K, Spooner E, Kuhn L, Coovadia HM. Influence of infant-feeding patterns on early mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1 in Durban, South Africa: a prospective cohort study. South African Vitamin A Study Group. Lancet 1999;354(9177):471-6. Iliff PJ, Piwoz EG, Tavengwa NV, Zunguza CD, Marinda ET, Nathoo KJ, et al. Early exclusive breastfeeding reduces the risk of postnatal HIV-1 transmission and increases HIV-free survival. AIDS 2005;19(7):699-708.
6Johnson W, Alons C, Fidalgo L, Piwoz E, Kahn S, Macombe A, et al. The challenge of providing adequate infant nutrition following early breastfeeding cessation by HIV-positive, food insecure Mozambican mothers. International AIDS Conference. Toronto, 2006.
7Humphrey J. Why consider breastfeeding cessation at six months for HIV positive mothers? International AIDS Conference. Toronto: PATH, 2006
8Doherty T, Chopra M, Nkonki L, Jackson D, Greiner T. Effect of the HIV epidemic on infant feeding in South Africa: "When they see me coming with the tins they laugh at me". Bull World Health Organ 2006;84(2):90-96.
9Coutsoudis A, Dabis F, Fawzi W, Gaillard P, Haverkamp G, Harris DR, et al. Late postnatal transmission of HIV-1 in breast-fed children: an individual patient data meta-analysis. J Infect Dis 2004;189(12):2154-66.
More like this
Summary of research* Location: South Africa What we know: Stunting is an indicator of chronic undernutrition and is often linked to poverty-related factors. There is mixed...
FEX: Issue 29 Editorial
There are two major themes running through this issue of Field Exchange. The first is a focus on Southern Africa and the programmatic challenges presented by HIV/AIDS and the...
Summary of published research1 Arecently published paper compares the efficacy and safety of two infant feeding strategies for the prevention of postnatal mother-to-child HIV...
Summary of published research1 Feeding recommendations for infants of infected HIV-mothers in developing countries remain controversial. As HIV can be transmitted to the infant...
Summary of published research1 Feeding bottles in a camp in Pakistan A recently published paper presents an analysis of the impact of WHO infant feeding recommendations in...
By Joanne Csete, Regional Programme Planning Officer UNICEF Regional Office for Eastern and Southern Africa Among the greatest programme challenges of recent years for United...
Summary of Published paper The observation that mother-to-child transmission by HIV-1 infected women can occur through breastfeeding has resulted in policies that recommend...
en-net: Should you recommend wet nursing in HIV prevalent areas where replacement feeding is not safe but there is no HIV testing available?
Current WHO guidance on infant feeding and HIV (2010) emphasises a public health approach to infant feeding choice in the HIV context. It emphasises that feeding...
Letters in the Lancet1 In the last issue of Field Exchange we summarised an article published in the Lancet by Anna Coutsoudis and colleagues which found that there are...
Summary of published paper1 Feeding recommendations for infants of HIV-infected mothers in developing countries remain controversial. The World Health Organisation (WHO)...
Summary of published paper1 Current WHO guidelines recommend that HIV positive mothers should avoid breastfeeding only if replacement feeding is acceptable, feasible,...
Summary of report and presentation1 Between November 2005 and February 2006, there were unusually heavy rains and flooding in Botswana, and by January 2006, there was an...
Summary of published clinical trial Transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) is known to occur through breastfeeding, but the magnitude of risk has not been...
What knowledge gaps are there currently in breastfeeding? What are some of the challenges mothers are getting in practising exclusive breasfeeding, especially in third world...
There has been significant programmatic experience and research on HIV and infant feeding since the World Health Organisation's (WHO) recommendations on infant feeding in the...
Summary of published paper1 The promotion of exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) to reduce the postnatal transmission (PNT) of HIV is based on limited data. The recently published...
By Tom Oguta, Abiud Omwega and Jaswant Sehmi Tom Oguta is currently a PhD student of Nutrition at the University of Nairobi. He has worked as a Research Officer at KIRDI...
Am greatly interested in literature about flash heating of breastmilk, in the context of HIV. Are there any publications about the effectiveness and efficacy of this...
In South Sudan, many women report not being able to breastfeed. Whilst in some cases this is about traditional beliefs and practices around infant feeding, maternal nutrition...
Summary of published research1 An increasing number of mothers with HIV in Uganda are breastfeeding their babies after UNICEF stopped donating free infant formula, according to...
Reference this page
Tanya Doherty, Mickey Chopra and Mike Colvin (2006). Counselling on infant feeding choice: Some practical realities from South Africa. Field Exchange 29, December 2006. p26. www.ennonline.net/fex/29/counselling