Menu ENN Search

Famine in North Korea: Markets, Aid and Reform

Summary of book review1

'Famine in North Korea: Markets, Aid, and Reform' is a newly published book2 with a foreword by Nobel prize winning economist, Amartya Sen. It provides a pithy analysis of the mass starvation that began in North Korea in the early 1990s leading to an estimated 600,000 - 1 million deaths out of a population of 22 million people. This is a summary of a book review appearing in a recent edition of the Lancet.

Anti-flooding operation in Congjin that was supported by WFP in Food for Work programme in 2004.

Although North Korea had suffered from bad weather, external shocks and low food production, the authors suggest that the cause of famine was primarily the collapse of entitlements, notably the ability of people to command food from the public food distribution system in an authoritarian state. According to the authors, locked into a landmass of which only about 20% can be cultivated, North Korea adopted a misguided strategy of food selfreliance. Chronic difficulties in agriculture and food spiralled into a full-blown crisis in 1995 with a series of set backs: withdrawal of aid from the then Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) (USSR), flooding and a succession of natural disasters, and geopolitical isolation resulting from the country's attempt to develop a nuclear arsenal.

However, it was neither the weather or shocks which caused the famine but rather state failure of denying people their food entitlement from a collapsed public food distribution system. Not all Koreans suffered equally. Hardest hit were the young and elderly, people in the north-eastern provinces and those from lower status occupational groups, such as farmers housekeepers and the jobless.

The authors place responsibility for the famine squarely with the North Korean government. They argue that the crisis was systemic, intimately related to the authoritarian structure of government, the absence of accountability to the citizenry, and the denial of political and civil liberties and property rights. "The government requested international food aid only in 1995, although food difficulties were evident as early as 1991". How much of the government's procrastination and ineptitude were due to malfeasance or lack of information is unclear, which the authors generously accept by considering a range of explanations for failure of the state. Such entitlement failures of socialist political systems are the source of some of the greatest 20th century famines: the USSR in 1921-22 and 1946-47; Ukraine in 1932-34; China in 1958- 62; Cambodia in 1976; and Ethiopia in 1984-85.

The international humanitarian aid community is not let off the hook either. Between 1995- 2005, North Korea received about $2.3 billion in foreign aid, two-thirds as food aid. Government insisted upon controlling food aid by restricting the number and movement of foreign staff, blocking agencies from developing independent channels for food delivery, and forcing them to accept assigned Korean translators. Data show that as donated food volumes increased, the government reduced its purchase of imported food. Aidgivers were forced to accept North Korean "exceptionalism", tight restrictions on their oversight, and supervision of donated food. Consequently, aid-givers worried over access to people in need, monitoring and tracking, and outright leakages. The authors estimate that about 30% of food aid was diverted, mostly to the county's elite, including the military.

North Korean workers packing fortified biscuits at factory in Sinuiju city, North Pyongan province supported by WFP and UNICEF in 2003.

The routing of food aid reflected, respectively, harder line versus softer line in pushing for North Korean cooperation in security negotiations. Aid-givers thus had mixed humanitarian and political motives, with the latter heightened during political negotiations over North Korea's ambition to develop nuclear armaments.

The authors are quick to point out that these difficulties do not mean that aid was without positive benefits. The ruthless behaviour of a self-preserving regime unresponsive to the needs of its citizens was balanced by the mixed motives and poor coordination of foreign aidgivers.

The collapse of the public distribution resulted in a bottoms-up marketisation of food, changing the basic economic pattern of food distribution in North Korea and opening up space to secure food beyond the public distribution system. An expanding food market in North Korea was an unintended consequence that the regime now treats with mixed signals of tolerance. Markets in food, if sustained and expanded, could become the seeds of major reforms of North Korea's economy that are essential for sustainable food security and famine prevention.

The final conclusion of the authors is that "we see no substitute for a policy of seeking to aid the North Korean people while engaging the government and encouraging its political, as well as economic, evolution."

Show footnotes

1Chen. L and Lam. D (2007). A penetrating analysis of famine in North Korea. www.thelancet.com. Vol 370, Dec 8th, 2007, pp 1897-1898

2Haggard. S and Noland. M (2007): Famine in North Korea: Markets, Aid and Reform. Columbia University Press, 2007. Pp 368, US$35.00. ISBN o-231-14000-2

More like this

FEX: DPRK in Crisis, What Do We Know?

This overview of the current situation in the DPRK and its context, was researched and written for Field Exchange by Killian Forde with editorial assistance from Lola Gostelow...

FEX: When is a Famine a Humanitarian Crisis?

When is a Famine a Humanitarian Crisis? Dear Editor, All available evidence suggests that the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) is suffering, to use the word in the...

FEX: Nutrition in the DPRK - a field view

By Marie-France Bourgeois Marie-France Bourgeois spent four months at the end of 1997 monitoring and co-ordinating ECHO funded programmes in DPRK. In that time, she travelled...

FEX: Issue 03 Editorial

Dear Readers, Welcome to our third edition of Field Exchange. Our reminder about the questionnaire is opposite so we will not continue to harp on about that! Instead we take...

FEX: Reconstruction in Bosnia: Implications for Food Security and the Future of Food Aid

The authors of this article are Fiona Watson and Aida Filipovitch. Both authors were nutrition Consultants working in B&H for WHO between 1993-6. This article describes the...

FEX: Milling vouchers in Dafur to optomise food aid

By Hanna Mattinen and Loreto Palmaera Hanna Mattinen has been Food Aid Advisor at the ACF headquarters since 2005, with a focus on food assistance and cash-based...

FEX: Disparate responses to need in Southern Africa

By Gaëlle Fedida Blanket food distribution in Bunjei, Angola, August, 2002 Since 1993, Gaëlle Fedida has worked in humanitarian aid in a wide variety of countries, including...

FEX: Evaluation of ECHO Actions in DPRK

Summary of evaluation1 The European Commission's Humanitarian Office (ECHO) recently conducted an evaluation to assess the appropriateness of their interventions in the...

FEX: Evaluation of the Response to the Montserrat Volcano

Published Evaluation The UK Department for International Disasters (DfID) commissioned an evaluation1 of the British government response to the Montserrat volcanic emergency...

FEX: Inadequate Refugee Rations: Is this a Result of Planning?

Published Lancet letters Two recent letters to the LANCET draw attention to two separate situations in which emergency food may have been used to promote longer term political...

FEX: The 2011 famine in Somalia: lessons learnt from a failed response

Summary of published research1 Location: Somalia What we know: In July 2011, a famine was declared in Southern Somalia despite sufficient, timely and robust early warnings....

FEX: The Nutrition Situation of Refugees and Displaced Persons

Summary of the ACC/SCN Refugee chapter by Jane Wallace The quarterly 'Reports on the Nutrition Situation of Refugees and Displaced Populations' (RNIS) are compiled and...

FEX: What Triggers Humanitarian Intervention?

Summary of published paper1 It is commonly assumed that massive media coverage of a humanitarian crisis will lead to increased allocations of emergency funds. This is often...

FEX: Human rights, politics and ethics

Summary of published paper1 A recent article in the Lancet argues that very little attention has been devoted to the relationship between external human rights contexts and the...

FEX: Children’s Aid Direct

Name Children's Aid Direct Address Crown House, 6-8 Crown Street, Reading RG31 2SE, UK Executive director Nick Thompson Telephone 0044 118 958 4000 HQ Staff 49 Fax 0044...

FEX: Blanket BP5 distribution to under fives in North Darfur

By Hanna Mattinen, ACF Since 2005, Hanna Mattinen has been Food Aid Advisor at the Action contre la Faim (ACF) headquarters, focusing on policy and operational issues around...

FEX: Impact of food aid on two communities in Niger

By Sarah McKune and Nicole Hood Dr Sarah McKune is the Director of Public Health Programmes at the University of Florida. She has worked in the West African Sahel since 2004,...

FEX: Promoting Good Nutrition and Food Security in the Gaza Strip

by Jane Hanon (Terre Des Hommes, Gaza) The Gaza strip lies on the Mediterranean Coast between Egypt and Israel. It has an area of 360 square kilometres and just under one...

FEX: References for Special Supplement 1

Women selling food in South Sudan AbuSaleh A, 1993. Cost effectiveness of feeding programs in Hartisheik A camp, for Somali refugees, Ethiopia 1988-1989. Unpublished report...

FEX: Grass Pea Consumption and Neurolathyrism

Summary of published paper1 Field of green pea grown in Ethiopia Neurolathyrism is a neurodegenerative and irreversible spastic paraparesis2 that can be crippling and lead to...

Close

Reference this page

Famine in North Korea: Markets, Aid and Reform. Field Exchange 32, January 2008. p7. www.ennonline.net/fex/32/famine

(ENN_2006)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.