Rapid Assessment Method for Older People (RAM-OP): Progress Report
Summary of online field article1
This article presents a summary of an online Field Exchange article that details field testing and other ongoing development work on the Rapid Assessment Method for Older People (RAM-OP).
The second trial was undertaken in a coastal district of Tanzania in August and September 2014. This trial also compared RAM-OP and SMART simultaneously in the same population. The SMART survey method followed published guidelines. The first stage sample size for RAM-OP was reduced from twenty to twelve clusters and a within community sample of sixteen older people was taken using systematic sampling of dwellings in the villages (or parts of villages) organised as ribbons of dwellings and a random walk (EPI3) sampling strategy in villages (or parts of the villages) organised as clusters of dwellings. The EPI3 method selects the first household to be sampled using the EPI strategy (as with SMART) with subsequent households selected by choosing a random direction and selecting the third nearest house in that direction. This sampling method has been shown to give results as good as simple random samples and to be better than the unmodified EPI strategy when a wide range of indicators is being assessed.
Both trials found that SMART and RAM-OP are functionally similar methods (i.e. the two methods return similar results) and that the RAM-OP method was considerably cheaper than the SMART method. Precision of RAM-OP in the second trial remained useful but was a little worse than that achieved by the SMART survey in the same population. This could be remedied by increasing the size of the first-stage sample (i.e. to sixteen clusters) whilst decreasing the size of the second-stage sample (i.e. to twelve older people) without increasing survey costs for RAM-OP much above about 50% of an equivalent SMART survey.
The online article3 describes key elements of the RAM-OP method, presents the results of the second trial, compares the results of the two field trials, and describes other ongoing RAM-OP development work.
Footnotes
1See the full article at: http://bit.ly/1WEKcQt
2Pascale Fritsch, Katja Siling and Mark Myatt (2015). RAM-OP: A rapid assessment method for assessing the nutritional status, vulnerabilities, and needs of older people in emergency and development settings. Field Exchange 49, March 2015. p67. www.ennonline.net/fex/49/ramop
3See footnote 1
More like this
en-net: SMART HHs Sampling
Dear Colleagues, We are planning to conduct a SMART survey in one area in Sudan. This area is a mixture of IDPs camps and host communities with no specific arrangement of HHs...
FEX: RAM-OP: A rapid assessment method for assessing the nutritional status, vulnerabilities, and needs of older people in emergency and development settings
By Pascale Fritsch (HelpAge International), Katja Siling (VALID International), and Mark Myatt (Brixton Health) Dr Pascale Fritsch is an experienced public health specialist....
en-net: Second stage sampling
We are doing a SMART survey in province X, which has 20 districts. We plan to have a representative sample in each district, then a weighted provincial prevalence. Our...
en-net: Modified EPI vs Segmentation in Urban Settings
Hello, Id like to know what is the best recommended methodology for SMART Survey in Urban Setting with large population (total population: 500,000p, pop/cluster -2000...
en-net: Nutrition assessment in small pieces livelihood zones
Unfortunately, our nutrition program fall under three livelihood area. The total program catchment population is about 120,000. The proportion of population in the three...
en-net: Sample size for rapid nutritional assessment of U5 using MUAC
Hi all, We would like to conduct a rapid nutritional assessment in an area affected by flood three times in the last quarter. Could anyone suggest about the size of the...
en-net: S3M
In looking at materials on CSAS, there are several references to S3M but I can't find anything that actually explains it. Does anyone have any resources for that? Hi Mark, I...
en-net: Nutrition assessment for Urban population
The exiting guidelines for nutrition survey/assessment and responses are mainly focused on rural farming populations. now days, the urban population is getting...
en-net: Is it possible to use LQAS methodology to assess the prevalence of stunting in non-emergency settings?
We are wanting to assess the prevalence of stunting in a non-emergency setting. Only stunting (height and age) and no other variables. Does anyone know if it is possible to use...
en-net: DESIGN EFFECT FOR MULTIPLE SMART SURVEY
I need guidance on how to get a single design effect for three separate surveys done last year at Sub-county level. We need to conduct a SMART survey at County level and...
en-net: Allocation of sample by proportion
we are on process to conduct caregivers satisfaction towards the services through systematic random sampling. The plan is to conduct in five health facilities. we have...
FEX: Nutrition programme coverage: implementation strategy and lessons learnt from the Sahel trip in Chad
By Hermann Ouedraogo, Ismael Ngnie-Teta, Mahamat Bechir, Esaie Diongoto Domaya, Adama N'Diaye, Paola Valenti Hermann Ouedraogo, MPH, PhD, is Nutrition Cluster Coordinator with...
en-net: Single two-stage cluster survey in multiple livelihood zones
The current approach is to have single two-stage cluster survey by agro-ecology. If a given district has two agro-ecological zone, this means there should be two independent...
en-net: Sampling households from a community
Hi there! I have less than a month to conduct a study. My sample size is 60 and my target population is non pregnant women between 18-49 years. I am recruiting women from a...
FEX: Comparison of LQAS and 30-by-30 two-stage cluster sampled survey method for the assessment of coverage indicators
By Asrat Dibaba, Charles Chimombo, Ari Uotila, Whitney King and Mark Myatt Asrat Dibaba is the Maternal, Newborn and Child Health Advisor for World Vision East Africa Region...
en-net: SMART on-site selection of village
In the absence of ENA software, doing on-site sampling of a district to select one village where we would do the data collection and lets say we need to visit 24 households Do...
en-net: SMART urban sampling
We have been asked to do a SMART survey in a township of a large African city. The section is a mix of blocks with pockets of less ordered housing. We are trying to get the...
en-net: Urgent Help!! Please!! Sampling and study design!!!
There is a project that aims to determine change in the knowledge-attitude-practice (KAP) among general public after certain intervention and after 12 months period. The design...
en-net: Sample size determination
Hi there, I am planning a nutrition survey in an area where previous estimates indicated 45% stunting prevalence. I would like to cover the entire district so I am not using...
en-net: CSAS survey for TSFP only
Dear Sir, We are planing to determine the coverage of a TSFP program that has been runing quite a while. Hence, according to the CSAS sampling, we calculated that we have to...
Reference this page
Pascale Fritsch (HelpAge International), Katja Siling (Valid International), Ernest Guevarra (Valid International), and Mark Myatt (Brixton Health) (). Rapid Assessment Method for Older People (RAM-OP): Progress Report. Field Exchange 50, August 2015. p13. www.ennonline.net/fex/50/rapidassessmentolderpeople
(ENN_5044)