Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme: Power, Politics and Practice
Summary of research*
Location: Ethiopia
What we know: The Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP) is an established, large-scale social protection effort by the Government of Ethiopia targeting rural, food-insecure households.
What this article adds: A recent qualitative study explored the role of power and politics in the PSNP in seven communities in two regional states of Ethiopia. The authors conclude that while there is positive impact, the implementation of the programme is problematic. In these communities, the PSNP was highly politicised, systematically neglected all of the participatory components outlined in the programme design, excluded the feedback mechanisms and entrenched political power. Understanding the existing political climate in operational environments is critical.
Ethiopia has made significant progress in reducing poverty, with a decrease of the population living in poverty from 46% in 2005 to 30% by 2010 (the population increased from 57 to 88 million during the same period). The country has one of the fastest-growing economies in the world; gross domestic product (GDP) was between 8.6 and 13.6% from 2004 to 2016. The Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP) is one of the Government of Ethiopia’s (GoE) most effective programmes to support people living in rural areas, who make up over 80% of the population.
The PSNP began in 2005 to support food-insecure households and enable them to overcome vulnerabilities without eroding their assets, and over time to support households to build assets. In 2015, more than seven million people had been supported by it, with an expected expansion to ten million people. The PSNP is mainly implemented by the GoE, with assistance from development partners. The programme, now in its fourth phase, has been widely studied and found to have positively impacted food-insecure households. Some studies claim that the impact is modest compared with progress made in comparable non-client households, although even critical assessments point to significant positive change. The PSNP has three key components (see Box 1). A recent study explored the roles of power and politics in the implementation of the PSNP. The authors contrast the plan (the Programme Implementation Manual) with its practice and explore why divergences may be occurring.
Box 1: Overview of PSNP
Public works programme
Eligible households with able-bodied adults are enrolled on this programme, with work geared towards enhancing infrastructure and enriching community-based resources, such as schools. Public works activities occur for six months each year, during which clients receive a salary based upon household size. Clients are expected to graduate from the programme when they gain sufficient assets.
Direct support programme
Those who are unable to work due to disability, illness or age are enrolled in the direct support programme (payments are for 12 months of the year).
Temporary programme
Temporary clients are pregnant or lactating mothers or caregivers for a malnourished child, who are enrolled in the public works component and temporarily shifted into direct support.
Methods
The qualitative research methods involved detailed interviews with clients and former clients of the PSNP, as well as relevant government staff (community leaders, development agents, community health workers and school staff) in seven communities in southern Ethiopia from two regional states. Given political sensitivities in the country, researcher connections were utilised to select communities for the study. These relationships were pivotal in establishing the trust needed to gain insight that might not otherwise have been shared. Interviews consisted of four group interviews with each community-based government body (in groups of two to six staff members), and 46 key informant interviews with PSNP clients, which were conducted voluntarily and anonymously. A large number of issues were raised by both government staff and community members; this research focused primarily on the common concerns and key discrepancies in the experiences of PSNP clients. Due to regional diversity within Ethiopia, this study was never expected to have great external validity.
Findings
Selection and graduation
- Fair and transparent selection is one of PSNP’s core principles, yet current clients and graduates in all the communities voiced concern regarding the lack of transparency in client selection, and why and how graduation occurs.
- Described in the Manual as “community-based targeting”, in reality local leaders and government staff selected clients without any community participation – a process that resulted in bias, with family members and friends of local leaders gaining entry preference and holding longer terms.
- Selection decisions were also linked to political affiliation, with the exclusion of known opposition party supporters.
- Data supports claims that numbers of graduates are determined at higher levels of government, based on quotas to ‘confirm’ that the programme is successful (i.e. clients are expected to graduate after five years).
- A number of political purposes are at play; the PSNP is being used for political patronage, punishment (clients were graduated for political reasons), and for broader political objectives of meeting regional and national targets.
Lodging an appeal
- According to the Manual, the grievance mechanism is run by an Appeals Committee at the community and district levels, but not one current or former client had heard of this.
- Overlapping responsibilities (i.e. staff likely to be on both committees that select clients as well as theoretical ones that handle appeals) reduce effectiveness.
- Questions were not escalated to higher levels of government due to fear of repercussions; e.g. being labelled as an anti-government agent.
Participation
- The manual states that public works’ programmes should be decided by the community members, but in practice government staff choose and direct group leaders to repair roads, etc. PSNP clients have no participation in the decision-making process.
Work commitment
- There is limited adherence to the per person working cap (no more than 15 days/month per adult household member) set out in the Manual to prevent overburdening clients.
- In practice, each public works client was responsible for working six days per week for six months of the year; also ‘voluntary’ participation in works continued beyond six months (refusal may be equated with political opposition, resulting in exclusion from benefits).
- The Government benefits from lack of adherence to labour caps, as most of the work involves government-run facilities such as schools and roads.
Power tends to corrupt
- There were multiple reports and examples of corruption, e.g. public workers made to farm land belonging to the community chairman, or people with a good relationship with the chairman were enrolled in the PSNP but not required to work.
Discussion
The study authors conclude that the programme has had a large and beneficial impact, but its implementation has been shaped and co-opted to maintain and strengthen political power. Furthermore, the findings challenge donors and practitioners to recognise the ways in which their funding and approaches to programme design are both empowering and disempowering individuals and to better understand the existing political climate in operational environments.
*Cochrane, Logan, and Y Tamiru. 2016. Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Program: Power, Politics and Practice. Journal of International Development 28 (5): 649–665. doi:10.1002/jid.3234.
More like this
FEX: National social assistance programmes to improve child nutrition
This is a summary of a Field Exchange field article that was included in issue 69. The original article was authored by Chloe Angood, Christiane Rudert and Tayllor Renee...
FEX: National social assistance programmes to improve child nutrition: Lessons from Burundi, Ethiopia and Tanzania
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Chloe Angood is a Knowledge Management for Nutrition Consultant for UNICEF Eastern and Southern Africa...
FEX: Emergency Food Security and Livelihoods Project in Amhara and Oromia regions
By Sarah Coll-Black and Matt Hobson Sarah Coll-Black is a Social Protection Specialist working with the World Bank in Ethiopia and Kenya. She has been involved with Ethiopia's...
FEX: Food insecurity and mental health among community health volunteers in Ethiopia
By Sarah Coll-Black and Matt Hobson Sarah Coll-Black is a Social Protection Specialist working with the World Bank in Ethiopia and Kenya. She has been involved with Ethiopia's...
FEX: An overview of REST’s implementation of the Productive Safety Net Programme
By The Relief Society of Tigray (REST) Mekelle Team The Relief Society of Tigray (REST) has been in existence in Ethiopia for over 30 years, starting out as a relatively small...
FEX: Integrating Infant and Young Child Feeding and the Productive Safety Net Programme in Ethiopia
By Adèle Fox Adèle Fox is currently based in Concern Worldwide Burundi office as Maternal, Newborn and Child Health Trainee. Adèle completed a Masters in Public Health from...
FEX: REACH OUT food assistance in Uganda
By Peter Paul Igu, Reach Out and Mary Corbett, ENN Peter Paul Igu has been a full-time volunteer with the organisation, Reach Out, since Jan 2002, and is the food programme...
NEX: Keyhole gardens in Ethiopia: A study of the barriers to scale-up
Yohannes Haile is a public health professional working in Ethiopia with Catholic Relief Services. He has a Master's degree in Public Health from Mekele University in...
FEX: Emergency Food Security and Livelihoods Project in Amhara and Oromia regions
By Shekar Anand, Oxfam Shekar is Programme Director for Oxfam GB in Ethiopia. Past experience includes working with OXFAM, CARE, CIDA, and Government in Aceh, India, Zimbabawe...
FEX: From the editor
Ethiopia is a diverse country where a significant proportion of the population live on or below the poverty line, where food insecurity is widespread and rates of acute...
FEX: Feasibility of private micro flood insurance provision in Bangladesh
Summary of research1 Women head for a nearby flood shelter established by the government in Bangladesh A recent paper describes a study to test the viability of a flood...
FEX: Joint Emergency Operation Plan NGO response to emergency food needs in Ethiopia
By Alix Carter Alix Carter has worked in the humanitarian sector in Ethiopia for almost three years. She is currently working as the Humanitarian Accountability Advisor at...
FEX: Market-led Livelihood Recovery and Enhancement Programme and integrating ENAs
By Andrew Simons, Daniel Gebeyehu, Getachew Gemtesa and Markos Kidane Andrew Simons is the National Programme Director for Food for the Hungry (FH) Ethiopia. He holds an...
FEX: Linking PSNP and NNP: experiences and challenges
Summary of report1 Audience of drama held during PSNP meeting (Laygiant) A recent pilot project focused on identifying implementation and eventually scale-up opportunities to...
NEX: Lessons from Namibia’s Nutrition Assessment Counselling and Support Programme for addressing child, adolescent and maternal undernutrition and HIV/AIDS
Hilde Liisa Nashandi and Marijke Rittmann Hilde is the Senior Health Programme Officer in the Food and Nutrition Sub-Division of the Ministry of Health and Social Services in...
FEX: Crop failure in Dalocha, Ethiopia: a Participatory Emergency Response:
Howell. P (1998), Disasters, Volume 22, No 1, March 1998, pp57-76 The following is a summary of a paper recently published in Disasters. The views expressed are those of the...
FEX: Review of urban food security targeting methodology and emergency triggers
Summary of report1 People queuing at an Oxfam feeding programme in Mbare, Harare A recent report compiled by Oxfam GB, Concern Worldwide and Action Contre la Faim (ACF)...
FEX: The impact of Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme on the nutritional status of children
Research snapshot1 Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP) is a large-scale, social protection intervention aimed at improving food security and stabilising asset...
FEX: Delivery of Social Protection Programmes in Kenya
By Clemensia Mwiti and Nupur Kukrety Clemensia Mwiti is a Humanitarian Support Professional (HSP) in Emergency Food Security and Livelihoods. Nupur Kukrety is the Social...
FEX: Micro-credit in refugee situations
Summary of published research1 Micro-credit and other types of loan programmes have not been widely attempted within refugee and internally displaced population (IDP) contexts...
Reference this page
Cochrane, Logan, and Y Tamiru (). Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme: Power, Politics and Practice. Field Exchange 53, November 2016. p14. www.ennonline.net/fex/53/ethiopiassafetynetprogramme
(ENN_5360)