Weekly menu for midday meal in Bangladeshi schools: Caregivers’ choices
By Abu Ahmed Shamim, Jannaty Mayna, Ishrat Jahan, Syed Muntasir Ridwan and Rudaba Khondker
Abu Ahmed Shamim is the Nutrition Advisor (Consultant) at the Research and Evaluation Division of BRAC. He has previously managed nutrition programmes and research projects at the Bangladesh National Nutrition Council, CARE, Johns Hopkins University, FHI 360 and Helen Keller International.
Jannati Mayna has a Master’s degree in Nutrition and Food Science from the Institute of Nutrition and Food Science, Dhaka University and is currently serving as a lecturer at the Khulna City Corporation (KCC) Women’s College, Khulna, Bangladesh.
Dr. Ishrat Jahan studied dental surgery (BDS) and public health (MPH) form James Pitter Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University and is currently working as a researcher at the ARK Foundation, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Syed Muntasir Ridwan works at the Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN), conducting research in health economics, econometrics and behavioral economics.
Dr Rudaba Khondkar is the Country Director of GAIN, Bangladesh. She is a Medical Doctor with expertise in pediatrics and over 15 years’ experience in humanitarian and development with Concern Worldwide, Save the Children, UNICEF and BRAC in Asia, Africa and the Pacific.
The authors wish to acknowledge the financial and technical support of GAIN, Bangladesh. However, the views expressed are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the view of GAIN.
The writers also acknowledge the insights provided by Dr. Mahbubur Rashed, Ex Head of Programme, GAIN, Bangladesh, and the support of the District Coordinator (Sherina Akther), Shushilan Barguna and the field-team of the School Meal Programme Bamna Barguna.
What we know: School feeding programmes have the potential to improve child nutrition status, school attendance and achievements, and therefore to improve to future wellbeing and productivity.
What this article adds: In Bangladesh undernutrition is prevalent among schoolchildren as evidenced by indicators of underweight (42%), stunting (31%) and wasting (28%) in girls aged 5 to 10 years as well as deficiencies in iodine, vitamin A, iron, calcium and zinc. In a small cross-sectional survey, data were collected from mothers/caregivers in 71 households with children participating in an existing World Food Programme-supported pilot school midday meals (MDM) programme, versus 40 non-MDM households. Results revealed higher intakes of energy, calcium and vitamin A among MDM schoolchildren (although numbers are small and so should be interpreted with caution). Three focus group discussions with mothers/caregivers and local female vegetable growers (n=22) revealed perceptions of school meals as monotonous, with demand for a wider variety of nutritious foods. New menus were developed at the same/similar cost to provide approximately 30%, 39%, 30%, 56%, 43%, 32% and 14% of recommended daily allowance (RDA) for dietary energy, protein, fat, iron, zinc, vitamin A and calcium, respectively. These new menus now require field testing.
Early-life malnutrition is reported to have long-term consequences. Improvements in height-for-age in pre-schoolers are linked with increased height as young adults and increased number of school grades completed (Alderman et al, 2006). A recent review commissioned by the World Bank and World Food Programme (WFP) reported that school feeding programmes increase school attendance, cognition and educational achievement, particularly if supported by complementary actions such as deworming and micronutrient fortification or supplementation (Bundy et al, 2009).
In response to such evidence and prevalent undernutrition, the Government of Bangladesh (GoB) and WFP launched a school feeding programme (SFP) in 2002, through which fortified biscuits were distributed to primary schoolchildren in poverty prone areas of Bangladesh to improve child nutrition status. To complement this initiative, a partnership was formed in between GoB, Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN) and Dubai Cares in 2011 to implement a pilot School Nutrition Project (SNP) in both rural and urban areas of Bangladesh to provide cooked midday meals (MDM) in primary schools.
A ‘cluster kitchen model’ was used whereby one basic kitchen provided a meal (often ‘khichuri’, made from rice, lentils or other pulses with added vegetables) to 1,500 to 2,500 students from five to six schools, using domestically produced and locally available ingredients cooked on traditional stoves. This model reduced dependence on electricity and ensured quicker delivery of food (within 40 to 60 minutes) compared to a large, centralised kitchen; avoided the need to build kitchen extensions in schools; reduced costs per school of kitchen workers; and avoided disturbing schoolteachers from their primary duty of teaching. Research showed that the nutrition status of children in participating schools, as well as school enrolment and attendance rates, improved significantly (Afroze & Tukun, 2014). The WFP supported programme continues to run in selected areas of Bangladesh and the GoB is now formulating a national school feeding policy and a plan for scale-up. To inform this process, GAIN conducted the current study to develop an acceptable and cost-effective MDM menu, taking into consideration the menus from the pre-existing programme.
A literature review was conducted to investigate the prevalence of undernutrition and micronutrient deficiencies of Bangladeshi primary school-age children. A pilot study that included a cross-sectional survey was then carried out among 111 mothers and caregivers in 71 pilot MDM households (of randomly selected students from a primary school in Bamna, sub-district of Borguna district, with the MDM programme) and 40 non-pilot households (of students from the nearest school from the adjacent sub-district with no MDM programme) to estimate energy, calcium and vitamin A intakes using the 24 hour-recall method1. Three focus group discussions (FGDs) (with 22 participants in total) were conducted with groups of mothers and caregivers of students attending MDM schools and local female vegetable suppliers of the MDM programme to gather their opinions on alternative MDM menus within the same budget.
Literature review findings
In Bangladesh prevalence of malnutrition is high; it is estimated that around 42% of school girls aged 5 to 10 years are underweight, 31% are stunted; and 28% are wasted, with a similar prevalence among boys (Akhtaruzzaman et al, 2013). Bangladesh has a high prevalence of iodine deficiency among school age children (40%) and vitamin A deficiency (19%). Although anaemia is prevalent in this age group (19.1% and 17.1 % in children aged 6-11 and 12-14 years respectively), prevalence of iron deficiency is not considered high (3.9% and 9.5 % in children aged 6-11 and 12-14 years respectively) (UNICEF, 2013). Daily intake of vitamin A, iron, calcium and zinc fall far short of daily recommended allowances for children (RDAs) at 20-47%, 35-48%, 50-77% and 36-60% respectively (Jahan & Hossain, 1998; UNICEF, 2013).
Intakes of energy, calcium and vitamin A among schoolchildren in pilot MDM households were higher than in non-pilot households, although the differences were small (hence figures are not presented) and the result should be interpreted with caution due to the small number of children included in the study. Field findings also suggested that a typical home breakfast and lunch of a child provides about 28-32% of dietary energy in both pilot-MDM and non-MDM households.
When the mothers or caregivers of schoolchildren were asked about their opinion regarding the school meal currently being provided, 52% expressed dissatisfaction with the taste of the meal, while being satisfied with the amount of food served and its nutritional quality. When asked about the benefits of the MDM, 44% of caregivers mentioned that it helped to reduce child hunger; 27% mentioned that it helped to reduce family costs; and 22% mentioned that it improved child health. Results revealed that 66 % of schoolchildren ate most of the meal provided, but 34% did not consume the meal regularly as they felt it was monotonous (100%) and not tasty (28%).
There was agreement among all participants in FDGs that school meals in the existing MDM programme are monotonous. Almost all (96%) mothers and caregivers of schoolchildren suggested the inclusion of eggs in the school meal as affordable, nutritious and acceptable foods for children; 82% of mothers also suggested milk and 73% suggested vegetables. Other suggestions for alternative menus included boiled rice, fried or curried egg, smashed or fried potato, fried or curried fish, bread, banana and other seasonal fruits. They also suggested these items to be served alternatively with khichuri and biscuits to further avoid monotony.
Taken together, the findings from this pilot project suggest that the menu provided at school should be at least equal to a typical lunch or breakfast that a child receives at home (~30% of dietary energy). Otherwise if a school meal replaced a typical home meal, it can plausibly be assumed that the overall nutrient intake could be lower. The exercise also revealed that the menu should be nutritious, tasty, varied and acceptable to the children to increase uptake. Results also show that mothers and workers implementing school meal programmes may provide valuable insight in planning menus.
Revised menu plans
Based on these results two weekly rotational menus were developed; one at the same cost as the existing programme and the second at a 15% additional cost (shown in Table 2). This menu would provide approximately 30%, 39%, 30%, 56%, 43%, 32% and 14% of RDA for dietary energy, protein, fat, iron, zinc, vitamin A and calcium, respectively.
Table 1: Proposed menus for MDM programme
Conclusion and recommendations
Alternative healthy menus are proposed for school lunches in Bangladesh, based on the results of a literature review and field study in the context of a pilot school meals programme. The GAIN meal-based school feeding project generated valuable learning which should be used in the process of planning the future national school meals policy and programme, such as the use of the cluster kitchen model. The field survey covered too small a sample size to measure statistically significant differences, but provided insights that complemented interviews and FGDs with caregivers and mothers. These indicated the need to create more varied and acceptable meals to increase uptake. The new menus identified through this pilot project can be plausibly expected to be more acceptable to children and consequently more effective in increasing child nutritional status. Findings must now be field tested before implementation at scale.
For more information, please contact Abu Ahmed Shamim.
1Iodine, zinc and iron intake from iodized salt and iron- and zinc-fortified rice were not estimated.
3Bangladeshi Taka (BDT); $1= BDT 8 (Department of Agricultural Marketing (www.dam.gov.bd/); accessed 15 June 2017)
4Locally and seasonally available mixed vegetables (including 50% leafy vegetables)
5Reconstituted from whole milk power/locally collected cow’s milk
6Calculated from Food and Agriculture Organization & World Health Organization, 2005; WHO, 2007; and Otten et al, 2006
7Upper values were used for calculation.
Afroze R & Tukun AB. (2014). Evaluation of school nutrition programme of BRAC and Banchte Shekha: Learning from a pilot project. BRAC Education.
Akhtaruzzaman M, Khan MNI & Islam SN. (2013). Nutrition, health and demographic survey of Bangladesh 2011. Dhaka: Institute of Nutrition and Food Science University of Dhaka.
Alderman H, Hoddinott J & Kinsey B. (2006). Long-term consequences of early childhood malnutrition. Oxford economic papers, 58(3), 450-474.
Bundy D, Burbano C, Grosh ME, Gelli A, Juke M and Lesley D. Rethinking school feeding: social safety nets, child development, and the education sector. World Bank, 2009.
Food and Agriculture Organization & World Health Organization. (2005). Vitamin and mineral requirements in human nutrition.
Jahan K & Hossain M (1998). Nature and Extent of Malnutrition in Bangladesh. Bangladesh National Nutrition Survey 1995-1996, Dhaka, Bangladesh. Dhaka: Institute of Nutrition and Food Science, University of Dhaka.
Otten JJ, Hellwig JP & Meyers LD (Eds). (2006). Dietary reference intakes: the essential guide to nutrient requirements. National Academies Press.
Shaheen N. (2013). Food composition tables for Bangladesh. Final Research Results, 187.
UNICEF (2013). National Micronutrient Status Survey.
World Health Organization (WHO) & United Nations University. (2007). Protein and amino acid requirements in human nutrition (Vol. 935). World Health Organization.
More like this
Shariqua Yunus Khan is a medical doctor and a public health practitioner currently managing the nutrition portfolio at the India office of the World Food...
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Emma Khachatryan manages the school meals programme for the World Food Programme (WFP) in the Kyrgyz...
FEX: Delivery of maternal nutrition interventions at scale and mainstreaming into the health system in Bangladesh
View this article as a pdf By Deborah Ash, Zeba Mahmud, Kristen Kappos, Santhia Ireen and Thomas Forissier Deborah Ash is Project Director for the Alive & Thrive initiative...
By Abu Ahmed Shamim, Kathrin Tegenfeldt, Kerry Aradhya, Tarana Ferdous, Nasrin Banu, Sumitra Roy, Raisul Haque, Saydur Rahman Siddiquee, Mosiqure Rahman and Nazma Shaheen Abu...
Combining a mid-day meal, health service package and peer support in Karnataka State, India View this article as a pdf Uma Mahadevan is Principal Secretary in the Department...
Kondwani Nanchukwa and Blessings Mphande Kondwani Nanchukwa holds a Bachelors degree in Family Science and a Masters degree in Rural Development. He is currently the...
Joyce Barakat is the Food Security Programme Coordinator at International Orthodox Christian Charities (IOCC) in Lebanon. She has a BSc in Biology and Premedical Studies from...
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici By Diane Baik Diane is a Technical Adviser for Health and Nutrition with the Technical Services...
By Greg Sclama View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Gregory Sclama is an Assistant Professor of International Development and Economics at the...
By Sophie Goudet Sophie is a nutritionist with over nine years experience with international agencies in nutrition and health within developing countries. Her research...
Based on the nutritional information of the two products, there is no difference in nutritional composion (energy,protein, Fat, and micronutritient) except plumy nut has animal...
NEX: The nutrition-sensitive potential of agricultural programmes in the context of school feeding: Lessons from Haiti
Summary of Field Exchange 51 article by Nathan Mallonee, Jason Streubel, Manassee Mersilus and Grace Heymsfield Haiti is the poorest country in the western hemisphere, with...
Summary of research1 The major cause of anaemia in pregnancy is iron deficiency, which is preventable. It is estimated that 56% of pregnant women in developing countries...
News By Dr Erick Boy, Nutrition Head, HarvestPlus Dr Erick Boy is a public health practitioner and has a doctoral degree in nutrition from University of California, Davis. He...
en-net: Upto what extend iron flour fortification can increase the Hb level of anemic adolescent women if iron fortified wheat flour is feed to these anemic adolescent women for 3 months?
i am doing my Mphil research on iron wheat flour fortification for anemic adolescent women. can any one have any information or relevant site or paper that how much it will...
Using an in-depth assessment of young children’s diets to develop a Multisectoral Nutrition Communications Strategy in Punjab province, Pakistan
View this article as a pdf Dr Muhammad Nasir is a medical doctor and Programme Manager in the Primary and Secondary Healthcare Departments of the Government of Punjab. Eric...
Addressing micronutrient gaps to reduce anaemia in Bhutan’s young children: Early experiences in home fortification
View this article as a pdf Laigden Dzed is Deputy Chief Programme Officer in the Nutrition Programme, Ministry of Health, Bhutan. Hari Prasad Pokhrel is a Senior Nutritionist...
Summary of research1 Location: Global What we know: RUTF is as effective as F100 in treating SAM, where weight gain is the recovery outcome. Food supplements for moderate...
By Alexandra Pirola, Benedict Tabiojong Mbeng and Mica Jenkins View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Benedict Tabiojong Mbeng is Head of...
How do low-cost, home-grown school-feeding programmes work? Lessons learned from Malawi By Devon Jaffe-Urell, Bernard Chigaya, Alexander Mwangonde, Victor Kadzinje, Paul...
Reference this page
Abu Ahmed Shamim, Jannaty Mayna, Ishrat Jahan, Syed Muntasir Ridwan and Rudaba Khondker (2018). Weekly menu for midday meal in Bangladeshi schools: Caregivers’ choices. Field Exchange 58, September 2018. p27. www.ennonline.net/fex/58/weeklymenubangladeshischools