Menu ENN Search

Finding the best criteria to identify children at high risk of mortality

View this article as a pdf

This article is a summary of the following paper: Khara T, Myatt M, Sadler K, Bahwere P, Berkeley J, Black R (TBC) Anthropometric criteria for best identifying children at high risk of mortality: A pooled analysis of 12 cohorts [submitted for publication].

Background

Previously published research has highlighted that being concurrently wasted and stunted (WaSt), even at moderate levels, is associated with considerable excess mortality in children comparable to that associated with severe wasting (McDonald et al, 2013). Given this high level of mortality risk, the question has been raised as to whether these children should be included in therapeutic feeding services if they are not already reached, as well as how these children might be identified at the community level for treatment.

To explore these questions and to understand how anthropometry can be used to identify children with WaSt who have a high risk of mortality, an analysis of data from a community-based cohort study in untreated children in Senegal in 1983-84 was conducted and published by ENN, with the Wasting and Stunting Technical Interest Group (WaSt TIG), in 2018. This analysis suggested that two anthropometric measures commonly used at community level – weight-for-age z-score (WAZ) and mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) – were independently associated with near-term mortality and that if severely low MUAC (<115 mm) was used in combination with WAZ <-2.8, all deaths associated with severe wasting (weight-for-height z-score (WHZ) <-3) and with WaSt could be predicted in the studied context (Myatt et al, 2018). The paper concluded that many of these deaths could likely be avoided if those cases were included for treatment in community-based management of acute malnutrition programmes and suggested that therapeutic treatment may achieve a higher impact on averting mortality if a combination of WAZ and MUAC admission criteria was to be used (in addition to the presence of nutritional oedema). However, implications related to increased caseloads were noted.

Recognising that the results of a single study were unlikely to be valid across all contexts, this follow-on paper aims to expand the same analysis to 12 similar mortality cohorts of largely untreated children, captured when treatment options were not available. It reviews anthropometric criteria for the identification of children at elevated mortality risk across several parameters and explores the potential programmatic implications of applying the most appropriate criteria in therapeutic treatment programmes. 

Methods

Data from 12 cohort study datasets from 12 different low-income countries, which included data on children aged 6-59 months collected between 1977 and 2013, was analysed. The original studies were all large prospective cohort studies or follow-up studies within randomized trials examining various health and nutrition interventions and outcomes in Africa, the Americas, Asia, and the Pacific. The outcome of interest for this analysis was near-term mortality, defined as death within six months of anthropometric assessment.

Ten anthropometric case definitions were proposed for analysis with each evaluated against multiple evaluation criteria for its suitability for use in identifying the most at-risk children for entry into therapeutic feeding programmes. The ability of each case definition to predict mortality within six months of anthropometric assessment was assessed. Analysis was performed separately for all children, children aged 6-23 months and those aged 24-49 months. Evaluation criteria included sensitivity (ability to detect deaths), specificity (ability to exclude those who do not go on to die), informedness (the probability of an informed decision being made as opposed to a random guess), face validity (the extent to which the definition appears to measure what it is intended to measure), inclusivity (the possibility of identifying all, or nearly all, children with severe anthropometric deficits who are likely to die within six months of measurement), and compatibility/ practicability (the degree to which a case definition is compatible with current practices, tools, and case-defining thresholds). The operational consequences of the findings were modelled by exploring the effects on programme caseload and workload for health staff.

Results

Of the 10 anthropometric case definitions analysed, three measures, namely MUAC<115mm, WAZ<-3 and MUAC<125mm, had the highest level of informedness in predicting mortality. A combined case definition (i.e., MUAC <115mm or WAZ <-3) was better at predicting deaths associated with WHZ<-3 and WaSt than a single WAZ<-3 definition. When assessing all criteria, it appeared that WAZ<-3 and MUAC<115mm, or WAZ<-3, performed best, also meeting, for example, criteria of compatibility/ practicability (particularly as MUAC and WAZ are both measures commonly used at community level), and face validity. It was found that the simulated caseload for programmes admitting on MUAC <125mm was 5.23 (95% CI = 2.76, 25.99) times larger than programmes admitting on MUAC <115mm and 3.01 (95% CI = 1.48, 15.33) times larger if admissions were based on MUAC<115mm or WAZ<-3.

When different levels of risk within the sub-groups of children identified was calculated and used to stratify the group into varying intensities and durations of treatment, it was found that the simulated workload for programmes admitting on MUAC <115mm or WAZ<03 was 1.87 (95% CI=1.03, 14.17) times larger than programmes admitting on MUAC <115mm alone.

Discussion

This analysis of 12 cohorts concurs with the findings from the 2018 Senegal analysis, concluding that a combined case definition of MUAC<115mm or WAZ <-3 performs best against all evaluation criteria and can predict nearly all deaths associated with severe anthropometric deficits (including WHZ<-3 and WaSt). Weight-for-age measures are used in many countries within several community-based child health and nutrition interventions, such as growth monitoring programmes and integrated management of childhood illnesses interventions. Thus, a case definition of WAZ <-3 could potentially be used within these established platforms for the identification of children at a high-risk of mortality requiring nutritional treatment. Furthermore, given that the combined case definition can detect all near-term deaths associated with WHZ<-3, the authors suggest that its use could remove the need for the current facility-based WHZ admission criterion by already including the most at-risk children in that group. This study illustrates that the use of the combined case definition would mean an increase in programmatic caseloads. However, the findings suggest that different levels of treatment intensity may be appropriate for some of the children identified. Further operational research is required to determine the appropriate treatment intensity levels.

A strength of the findings of this study is that it is based on the analysis of many datasets of untreated children in different contexts. However, there are several limitations including a potential bias introduced by loss to follow-up masking deaths within the cohorts, as well as the possible bias introduced by the absence of data on oedema.

Conclusion  

A combined case definition (MUAC<115mm or WAZ<-3) has the ability to detect all, or nearly all, deaths associated with severe anthropometric deficits. The use of such definitions in existing community-level platforms suggests that therapeutic feeding programmes may achieve higher impact with this case definition. However, there remain questions related to the intensity of treatment required and also operational considerations that require further discussion.

References

McDonald C, Olofin I, Flaxman S, Fawzi W, Spiegelman D, Caulfield L et al (2013) The effect of mulitple anthropometric deficits on child mortality: Meta-analysis of individual data in 10 prospective studies from developing countries. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 97, 896-901. 

Myatt M, Khara T, Dolan C, Garenne M and Briend A (2019) Improving screening for malnourished children at high risk of death: a study of children aged 6-59 months in rural Senegal. Public Health Nutrition 22, 862-871.

 

More like this

FEX: Summary of wasting and stunting project meeting

In May, the Technical Interest Group (TIG) of the ENN-facilitated Wasting and Stunting (WaSt) project1 held its bi-annual meeting, made possible through the generous support of...

FEX: Improving screening for malnourished children at high risk of death

Research snapshot1 The purpose of this study was to investigate whether children with concurrent wasting and stunting (WaSt) require therapeutic feeding and to better...

FEX: Response to malnutrition treatment in low weight-for-age children: secondary analyses of ComPAS trial data

View this article as a pdf Research summary1 Location: Kenya and South Sudan What we know: Children who are concurrently wasted and stunted (WaSt) have a very high mortality...

FEX: Death of children with SAM diagnosed by WHZ or MUAC: Who are we missing?

Summary of presentation1 View this article as a pdf By Michael H. Golden and Emmanuel Grellety Michael Golden is a retired professor of medicine with 45 years' experience of...

FEX: Making connections: Joint meeting of WaSt Technical Interest Group and MAMI Special Interest Group

ENN coordinates two international technical groups, the Management of at-risk Mothers and Infants under six months Special Interest Group (MAMI SIG) and the Wasting and...

FEX: Is MUAC alone a sufficient criterion for admission of children at high risk of mortality in South Sudan?

Summary of research 1 Location: South Sudan What we know: The operational implications of using MUAC as the sole anthropometric admission criterion to therapeutic feeding...

FEX: Diagnostic criteria for severe acute malnutrition among infants under six months of age

Summary of research1 Location: Kenya What we know: Diagnosis of acute malnutrition in infants under six months old (U6M) is currently based on weight-for-length z score...

FEX: Wasting and Stunting Technical Interest Group (WaSt TIG) meeting

On the 15th of January 2018 the Wasting and Stunting (WaSt) Technical Interest Group (TIG) held their third face-to-face meeting at Trinity College, Oxford. This group of 30...

FEX: A reflection on the 2021 Lancet Maternal & Child Nutrition Series through a WaSt lens

View this article as a pdf This article provides a summary of the Lancet Maternal & Child Nutrition Series to date, reflecting upon the 2021 series from the perspective of the...

Resource: Improving screening for malnourished children at high risk of death: a study of children aged 6–59 months in rural Senegal

Abstract Objective: To investigate whether children with concurrent wasting and stunting require therapeutic feeding and to better understand whether multiple diagnostic...

en-net: Only MUAC for admission and discharge?

There has been a discussion about the use of ONLY MUAC as an admission and discharge criteria (http://www.en-net.org/question/468.aspx). Although I understand the challenge in...

Resource: The WaSt study Protocol and Opportunities for Collaboration: bringing new evidence on undernutrition and mortality risk into practice.

The ENN and the Wasting Stunting Technical Interest Group (WaSt TIG), with funding from USAID via the Bureau of Humanitarian Affairs (BHA) and Bureau for Global Health, in 2018...

en-net: Emergency standards for SAM/MAM when using MUAC

Can one use the same thresholds for SAM/MAM prevalence when using MUAC as the basis for measurement? For example can one equally use less than 15% GAM prevalence to classify...

en-net: WFH versus MUAC

I would like experts input in this regard. I wish Mark Myatt to be one of the respondent of my question. Much has been said about the discrepancy of MUAC and WFH in some...

Resource: Bringing new evidence on undernutrition and mortality risk into practice- Protocol for a prospective cohort study

Introduction The ENN coordinated Wasting and Stunting Technical Interest Group (WaSt TIG) have been investigating the relationship between wasting and stunting since 2014...

en-net: Key questions regarding MUAC only programming - towards a research agenda

I have started this thread in the hope that we can come together there to work out what we need to do to move forward with an informed debate on issues around MUAC-only...

FEX: Management of At risk Mothers and Infants (MAMI) meeting

A one-day meeting of the Management of At risk Mothers and Infants (MAMI)1 Special Interest Group (SIG) took place in London on 17 January 2018. The meeting was hosted by ENN...

Resource: Children who are both wasted and stunted are also underweight and have a high risk of death: a descriptive epidemiology of multiple anthropometric deficits using data from 51 countries

Abstract Background: Wasting and stunting are common. They are implicated in the deaths of almost two million children each year and account for over 12% of...

FEX: Children who are both wasted and stunted are also underweight and have a high risk of death

Research snapshot1 Wasting and stunting tend to be addressed as separate issues, despite evidence of common causality and the fact that children may suffer simultaneously from...

FEX: Substandard discharge rules in current severe acute malnutrition management protocols: An overlooked source of ineffectiveness for programmes?

View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici By Benjamin Guesdon and Dominique Roberfroid Benjamin Guesdon is a nutrition and health research advisor...

Close

Reference this page

Finding the best criteria to identify children at high risk of mortality. Field Exchange 67, April 2022. p56. www.ennonline.net/fex/67/researchsummarymortalityrisk

(ENN_7368)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.