Menu ENN Search

Aid and Erosion of Humanitarian Principles in Sierra Leone

Guinea - Sierra Leonean refugees in the Gueckeodou region

Published paper

David Keene's article which is largely based on a review of humanitarian agency documents about Sierra Leone written between 1992-5 and interviews with agency staff, asserts that at least three recent developments threaten further erosion of humanitarian principles in the provision of emergency relief.

These developments are:

  1. a growing emphasis on the need to repatriate refugees and the containment of would-be refugees within their home countries
  2. pressure on aid budgets
  3. the changing nature of contemporary conflicts, i.e. conflicts are protracted and often highly factionalised struggles where immediate economic goals often take precedence over political objectives.

According to Keene, aid agencies are having difficulty adapting to this combination of changing circumstances and there is often a reluctance even to find out about complicated realities that may call into question tried and trusted responses. For aid organisations, the chosen responses must be seen to be appropriate to the needs that have been recognised and publicised. But it may be easier to achieve this effect by misrepresenting the needs, misrepresenting the crisis and indeed by misrepresenting the response rather than by bringing the response into line with the actual needs and crisis.

Using Sierra Leone as a case-study (1991-5), Keene attempts to show that the aid system failed to deliver the needs that had been assessed, but that this failure was effectively disguised and accommodated through a variety of techniques. For example, the planning figure of 500,000 agreed in November 1994, was itself some 300,000 fewer than the number WFP felt were displaced at that time. Also, although the severity of the conflict was tending to increase over time the level of the ration was progressively reduced from 350 gms of cereal per person per day in 1992 to 300 in 1993 and again down to 200 in 1994 and 1995.

Distribution was also a major problem. Apart from the problem of insecurity, aid organisations were working to a tight budget and frequently did not have the flexibility to match the rising fees that were paid to truckers by commercial traders. WFP were facing a major funding crisis in Sierra Leone, with the crisis in Rwanda taking attention and resources away and donors supplying only a fraction of what they had pledged.

Keene identifies a number of methods that were used to give the appearance of a relief operation that was meeting assessed needs. Some of the arguments were apparently made in good faith while others were not. He asserts that these methods have been used much more widely than in Sierra Leone and that understanding them may help in appreciating how the erosion of humanitarian principles can be made to seem legitimate.

Conflating the needy and the accessible

This means conflating the assessment of needs with the assessment of numbers who can 'realistically' be reached. The 1994 plan to help only 500,000 people apparently took account of the limited NGO food distribution capacity and security constraints. Yet this figure took on a life of its own and according to one report, there were only 500,000 displaced people in S.Leone.

Accepting the constraints

Security constraints were never as immutable as claimed.

Neglecting the monitoring of aid

In spite of the diversion of aid, reported to be as much as 60% for some agencies, food aid distributions and receipts were not carefully monitored or recorded. Exposing impediments to the actual receipts of relief would have required investigation and discussion of many facets of the emergency that major donors were anxious to dismiss., e.g. the diversion of food aid by government soldiers and the emergence of economic interests in continued conflict.

Emphasising coping strategies

Ration reduction it was said would boost coping strategies and discourage dependence. Relief to Sierra Leonean refugees in Guinea and Liberia appears to have been phased out prematurely on the assumption that they had become self-sufficient. In reality many returned to conditions of considerable danger as a result of ration reductions. The failure to deliver the needs that had been assessed was justified in part with the contention that relief was not intended to meet people's nutritional needs. The ration, claimed WFP and UNHCR, was simply an income supplement. If this was its primary function it was difficult to explain the move from distributing rice to bulgur wheat, a commodity that was a much less valuable income supplement than rice. Keene argues that it was clear that its adoption reflected resource constraints in light of the considerably lower price of bulgur on international markets.

Closely related to the discussions of coping strategies were concerns about dependency - an enduring obsession with the UN system in particular. As in some other relief operations, the masterstroke of those in charge of faulty operations was to claim credit for a lack of relief, a failing that could be presented as cleverly avoiding the negative effects that relief could bring.

Keene explains how amid 'all this jargon and sloppy language', no evidence was advanced to support the suggestion that people were avoiding farming or other economic activities because of a dependency syndrome, rather than because they had been subjected to violence and feared for their safety. He also describes the impression reading WFP or UNHCR documents that arguments - some of them good, some bad and some merely incomprehensible, - were being picked up and dropped with a view to justifying a response that has been dictated by more prosaic resource constraints.

Reference

Keene. D (1998); Aid and Violence with Special Reference to Sierra Leone; Disasters, 1998 22 (4), pp 318-327.

More like this

FEX: The Nutrition Situation of Refugees and Displaced Persons

Summary of the ACC/SCN Refugee chapter by Jane Wallace The quarterly 'Reports on the Nutrition Situation of Refugees and Displaced Populations' (RNIS) are compiled and...

FEX: Revisiting Sphere: new standards of service delivery for new trends in protracted displacement

Summary of research1 Protracted refugee situations (PRS) are those in which refugees find themselves in a long-lasting and intractable state of limbo. Roughly half of the...

FEX: Experiences of the Sustainable Nutrition and Agriculture Promotion (SNAP) programme in the Ebola response in Sierra Leone

By Sibida George and Georgia Beans Sibida George is Team Leader with International Medical Corps/ SNAP and is based in Sierra Leone. Georgia Beans is the Chief Of Party with...

FEX: WFP Evaluation of Liberia programme

WFP recently commissioned an evaluation of the 1990- 1995 'period of WFP emergency operations in Liberia, Sierra Leone, Guinea and Cote dIvoire. Three million people have been...

FEX: Investing in Nutrition to Reduce Poverty

Summary of published research1 A malnourished child in a therapeutic feeding centre in Kenema Sierra Leone suffers from endemic and pervasive poverty due to long periods of...

FEX: Towards the Overdue Elimination of Deficiency Disease Epidemics

By André Briend Andre Briend is a medical doctor, working for the Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), a French public research institution with a mandate to...

FEX: Responding to the crisis in Congo-Zaire: emergency Feeding of Rwandan Refugees May-July 1997

Author:Susanne Jaspars, is an independent Consultant in Nutrition. This article was based on her experiences while working for CARE UK as a Food Policy Consultant. The...

FEX: Sale of Food Aid as Sign of Distress not Excess

Summary of Published Paper In February 1996, WFP reduced rations for refugees in Uvira, Zaire by 20% when visiting donors noted that food aid, primarily maize and oil, was...

FEX: Completing the Jigsaw Puzzle: Joint Assessment Missions (JAM)

By Allison Oman Allison is the Senior Regional Nutrition and Food Security Officer for UNHCR based in Nairobi, Kenya. She works with countries in the region to give technical...

FEX: Income generation in Guinea Conakry (Special Supplement 3)

By Alexandros Yiannopoulos, ACF Spain (ACF-E) Since the 1990s, Liberia, Sierra Leone and later on the Ivory Coast, have been embroiled in conflict. This has led to a mass...

FEX: How to assess and respond to Iraqi refugee needs in Syria

By Lucia Oliveira Lucia Oliveira has been working with ACF Spain since 2005 and is currently Head of Mission in Syria. Her background is International Relations, European...

FEX: Refugee Influx Can Improve Services for Locals

Summary of published paper There has been debate around the effects of service provision for refugees on host populations. The level / quality of care provided by local...

FEX: Kakuma Revisited

Kakuma Revisited Dear editors, I would like to comment on the article "Household Food Economy Assessment in Kakuma Refugee Camp" (Field Exchange, Issue 1, May 97)....

FEX: Persistent Micronutrient Problems among Refugees in Nepal

by Janack Upadhyay This article describes nutritional aspect of emergency food aid in Bhutanese refugee camps in Nepal; the author was regional Food & Nutrition...

FEX: Iraq - Sanctions Take Their Toll

By Killian Forde Under article 41 of the United Nations Charter, the UN Security Council (UNSC) may call upon member states to apply measures not involving the use of armed...

FEX: Don’t let them eat cake

By Susanne Jaspars Susane Jaspers is a Nutritionist specialising in emergency nutrition, food aid and food security. This article is based on her experiences in Albania and...

FEX: Evolution of WFP’s food assistance programme for Syrian refugees in Jordan

By Edgar Luce For the past two years, Edgar Luce has been working for WFP Jordan as a Programme Officer by monitoring operations, writing reports and acting as the VAM...

FEX: Resourcing Targeting (Special Supplement 1)

Agencies deciding to implement food aid targeting in emergencies often face constraints on targeting design. Three such factors are dealt with here: Quantity and quality of...

FEX: Concern’s Initial Response to the Kosovo Crisis

Delivering WFP wheat to the CONCERN store in Gjimij Connell Foley is part of the Concern Policy Development and Evaluation Directorate and went to Albania as part of Concern's...

FEX: Inadequate Refugee Rations: Is this a Result of Planning?

Published Lancet letters Two recent letters to the LANCET draw attention to two separate situations in which emergency food may have been used to promote longer term political...

Close

Reference this page

Aid and Erosion of Humanitarian Principles in Sierra Leone. Field Exchange 7, July 1999. p7. www.ennonline.net/fex/7/aid

(ENN_3378)

Close

Download to a citation manager

The below files can be imported into your preferred reference management tool, most tools will allow you to manually import the RIS file. Endnote may required a specific filter file to be used.