Managing acute malnutrition with scarce resources in Pakistan
Dr. Mubina Agboatwalla, HOPE Pakistan
Dr. Mubina Agboatwalla is a pediatrician and chairperson of HOPE. She has worked extensively on maternal and child health programmes including community and hospital-based programmes to treat children with SAM.
Nutrition in Pakistan is a critical challenge with 44% of children under 5 years of age suffering from stunting and 18% with moderate or acute wasting1. Following the 2010 and 2011 floods, levels of global acute malnutrition (GAM) increased above the WHO designated emergency threshold of 15%. To address this rise in acute malnutrition, United Nations agencies supported Government, International Non-governmental Organizations (INGOs) and national NGOs to develop community-based management of acute malnutrition (CMAM) projects. After a year, the short-term emergency funding for CMAM was finished and activities to improve the nutritional situation ceased. This article outlines the experience of HOPE, a national NGO that received support to implement emergency CMAM activities in three districts (Thatta, Dadu and Shahdadkot) and how they addressed the continued problem of high levels of acute malnutrition after the emergency funding ended.
By April 2012, external funding for HOPE’s CMAM activities had finished. However, there were large areas, including the towns of Jhimpir, Sakro and Sujawal that continued to have a worryingly high GAM (21.1% based on an ACF/ UNICEF nutrition survey). HOPE decided to try to continue a reduced level of CMAM services with their existing resources in Thatta District, from April 2012 to March 2013.
HOPE’s reduced CMAM service included 1) building capacity of the health centre staff in screening for acute malnutrition and providing nutritional counseling, 2) community mobilisation and 3) providing locally made foods to those with acute malnutrition as described below.
Capacity building. HOPE’s core staff2 trained ministry staff working in Maternal and Child Health Centres (MCH) and Basic Health Units (BHUs), in IYCF counseling and screening for acute malnutrition. HOPE staffs at peripheral health centres, that were not initially part of the HOPE nutrition activities, were also trained. Training included breast-feeding promotion and appropriate complimentary feeding.
Community mobilisation. HOPE continued to support MNCH services in a network of peripheral health centres and community mobilisation for nutrition was integrated into these existing activities. Additionally, HOPE outreach teams, travelling to villages, integrated nutrition screening and counseling in these community visits and identified acutely malnourished children and transported them (with their mothers) to the appropriate health facility.
Outpatient Therapeutic Programme (OTP). HOPE provided limited OTP services at the level of the health facility. Children that were identified as having MAM (MUAC 11.5-12.5 cm) and SAM children without complications (MUAC <11.5 cm) received a meal and medical treatment when they presented at the health facility, while SAM children with complications were admitted to the Stabilisation Centre for inpatient care.
Ready-to-use Therapeutic Food (RUTF) was unavailable due to high costs so instead, low cost, locally available nutritious foods, such as Khirchri and Sooji (semi solid foods comprised of lentils, rice and wheat with some vegetable oil), were prepared daily. These foods were cooked by HOPE staff and fed to the children by their mothers or carers. Mothers were then instructed to prepare these foods at home daily (with the food they had in the household- no foods were given by HOPE) and return every two weeks for a follow up visit for the child.
Necessary medications for minor ailments such as cough, cold, diarrhoea, and vomiting were provided.
HOPE transported children back to their homes. Mothers were instructed to bring their children back in two weeks for a check up. As HOPE teams visited the villages every week they picked most of the children/mothers that needed to return to the programme.
Follow up visits included assessment of MUAC and weight, review of dietary history and provision of nutritional counseling. In cases of minor illnesses, medication was provided. For children who were not gaining weight, health facility staff counseled mothers and suggested feeding techniques.
SAM children (MUAC <11.5cm) with complications were taken to an inpatient hospital where their medical complications were treated. Nutritional treatment was based on the provision of khitchri, sooji, and sagodana (a rice based porridge). At the hospital mothers were given demonstrations on food preparations as well counseling on breast-feeding and IYCF practices. Patients were discharged based on > 15% weight gain and taken back to the villages by the CHWs in HOPE’s transport. Patients were encouraged to go to the nearest health facility (fixed OTP) for follow up on a monthly basis.
This reduced CMAM service project continued for almost a year, from April 2012 to March 2013. During this time a total of 9600 children with acute malnutrition were identified in the peripheral health facilities, see table below. Of the MAM children identified, 5616 (90%) were treated and recovered, though the default rate was high, 9.5% (593 children). Amongst the SAM children without complications, 1253 children (87%) recovered while 151 children (12%) defaulted.
|Children screened and admitted to the programme|
Total Children (under 5 years) Screened
|SAM Children without Complications||1440|
|SAM Children with Complications||231|
|Programme outcomes for children in OTP|
|SAM Children without Complications||87%(1253)||12%(173)||1%(14)|
|SAM children with complications||59.2% (137)||14%(32)||3% (7)|
During this period, 231 patients (13.8% of all SAM children) were admitted to the Stabilisation Centre. Of these, 137 (59.2%) recovered, while 32 patients (14%) defaulted (as they were unwilling to stay as inpatients). No change in weight was seen in 37 patients (16%) while 18 patients (7.8%) showed a loss in weight, .
An average duration of 5.4 months was needed to recover from MAM. Children with uncomplicated SAM stayed in the programme for an average of 6 months. Records show that 86% of children were followed up in their homes by the CHWs. It is recognised that the results for recovery of SAM children with complications do not meet the International Sphere Standards. This is though to be due to the limited nutritional support provided- there was no therapeutic milk (F-75 or F-100) or RUTF in the SC.
The programme had many challenges.
- There was no external funding, HOPE ran the programme with their existing infrastructure, staff, and medical supplies.
- Personnel specifically dedicated to nutrition were few.
- RUTFs for the OTP or for the SC were not available and there was no F75 or F100 for inpatient care.
- Mothers were unwilling to stay in the hospital for a week or ten days because they had other children had home.
HOPE’s overall health programme cost was $68,000 for the year3. Nearly 35% of the budget went in staff remuneration, medicines 20%, logistics was 30% and nearly 15% on food. Based on HOPE’s experience, this amounts to about 40% of the costs of a similar-sized donor funded CMAM programme.
Due to limited resources, HOPE in consultation with their CMAM trained staff (pediatricians and nutritionists) designed and implemented a programme to treat acutely malnourished children using local ingredients, complemented by appropriate medical support for a year. While programme performance met international Sphere standards in terms of outpatient recovery, default was high and length of stay was much longer than recommended. In-patient SAM cases did not recover as per Sphere standards. However, community mobilisation continued as HOPE tried to foster behavior change to support positive health and nutrition practices in the absence of anything else.
While not an ideal situation, it is a situation that is often faced at the end of an emergency programme. Based on this experience, HOPE would urge donors to review their policy of short-term emergency funding to support nutrition programmes and advocate for longer term/flexible funding to enable programmes to continue beyond the emergency phase, particularly in high-burden, resource-poor, emergency prone contexts. In addition, HOPE supports the government to take ownership of nutrition services and encourages joint strategic planning to ensure sustainability.
1The State of the World Children UNICEF 2013
2Chief Nutrition Coordinator, Nutrition Officer, Social Welfare Office and Communication Officer
3This includes the CMAM activities as well as the wider health activities. As the CMAM activities were integrated into the wider health activities it is not possible to identify the cost of just the CMAM activities.
More like this
By Casie Tesfai Casie Tesfai is currently the Nutrition Technical Advisor for the International Rescue Committee based in New York. She has 10 years of nutrition experience...
FEX: En-net update
By Tamsin Walters, en-net moderator Over the past four months1, 32 questions have been posted on en-net, generating 69 responses. Two upcoming trainings have been advertised...
By Ruba Ahmad Abu-Taleb Ruba Ahmad Abu-Taleb is Nutrition coordinator at Jordan Health Aid Society (JHAS). She liaises between national and international NGOs and JHAS...
Hello every one During treatment of SAM children in OTP we often find some drop in weight for new enrolled children in initial couple of weeks. Pakistan CMAM guideline...
Government of Malawi guidelines Summary of published research1 A recent study assessed the cost-effectiveness of community-based management of acute malnutrition (CMAM) to...
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici By Daya Krishna Mangal and Shobana Sivaraman Daya Krishan Mangal is Professor and Dean of Research at the...
FEX: Treatment of severe acute malnutrition through the Integrated Child Development Scheme in Jharkand State, India
By Grana Pu Selvi and Colleen Emary View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Click here to listen to an interview with the authors on the ENN...
By Sarah Morgan, Robert Bulten and Dr Hector Jalipa Until the end of August 2014, Sarah Morgan was Senior Nutrition and Child Health Advisor for World Vision UK, with...
This is a summary of a Field Exchange field article that was included in issue 63 - a special edition on child wasting in South Asia. The original article was authored by Daya...
By Fekri Dureab, Dr Ayoub Al Jawaldeh and Dr Latifah Abbas View this article as a pdf Fekri Dureab MD was the head of the nutrition department at WHO Yemen office until June...
FEX: Follow-up status of children with SAM treated with RUTF in peri-urban and rural Northern Bangladesh
By Dr. Charulatha Banerjee, Monsurul Hoq and Dr. Ehsanul Matin Charulatha Banerjee is Regional Advisor on Maternal and Child Health & Nutrition, South Asia with the Terre des...
As per my information from colleague, NUGAG has recommended the 12.5cm discharge criteria as opposed to weight gain. The panel of expert agreed that % weight gain was incorrect...
By Regine Kopplow Regine is a former CMAM Advisor with Concern Nepal. She is a nutritionist with a background in rural development. She has worked in the field of nutrition...
View this article as a pdf This is a summary of the following report: UNICEF (2022) Evaluation of community-based management of acute malnutrition in Yemen. Background In...
By Ms Aminata Shamit Koroma, Faraja Chiwile, Marian Bangura, Hannah Yankson and Joyce Njoro Aminata Shamit Koroma is National Food and Nutrition Programme Manager, Ministry...
By Martin Eklund and Tsinuel Girma Martin Eklund holds an MSc in Clinical Nutrition from the University of Copenhagen. His specialisation is community-based management of...
CONSULTANT NEEDED for CMAM Capacity Building CMAM technical support for OTP activities and Community Mobilization Consultation Language: French Timeline: 16 days preferably...
FEX: Simplified approaches to treat acute malnutrition: Insights and reflections from MSF and lessons from experiences in NE Nigeria
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici By Kerstin Hanson Kerstin Hanson has a background in paediatrics and public health. She most recently...
By Emily Mates Emily Mates is a public health professional with a focus in nutrition. She recently left Concern Worldwide, Ethiopia where she worked for many years in...
View this article as a pdf Lisez cet article en français ici Summary of research1 By Naoko Kozuki, Jama Mohamud Ahmed, Mukhtar Sirat and Muna Abdirizak Jama Naoko...
Reference this page
Dr. Mubina Agboatwalla (). Managing acute malnutrition with scarce resources in Pakistan. Nutrition Exchange 4, July 2014. p13. www.ennonline.net/nex/4/en/pakistan